Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout28-02 RESOLUTIONRESOLUTION NO. 28-02 A RESOLUTION TO APPROVE AMENDMENT #1 TO THE CONTRACT WITH BURDI"IT ASSOCIATES "1"O INCREASE CITY FUNDING IN THE AMOUNT OF 533,000.00 TO COMPLETE THE CITY WIDE STREET" TREE INVENTORY BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, ARKANSAS: Section 1. That the City Council of the City of Fayetteville, Arkansas hereby authorizes the Mayor to execute Amendment #1 to the agreement with Burditt Associates (attached at Exhibit A) in the amount of $33,000.0() to complete the city wide street tree inventory. PASSED and APPROVED this the 19th day of February, 2002. APPROVED: By: • • • • Woodruff, City CI 4,, DAN COODY, Mad r • NAME OF FILE: CROSS REFERENCE: Resolution No. 28-02 • 02/19/02 Resolution No. 28-02 02/19/02 Exhibit "B" (Amended Scope of Work)(Addendum to Consultant Agreement extends the expiration date of the agreement to August 31, 2002) Unsigned Copy of Amendment No. 1 to the contract with Burditt Associates to increase city funding to complete the city wide street tree inventory (the new one is above) 05/15/02 Letter to Kim Hesse, from Wanda Collins, Project Manager, Burditt Associates 05/14/02 Memo to Mayor Coody and Peggy Vice, Purchasing Director, copy to Hugh Earnest, Urban Dev. Director, from Kim Hesse, regarding Tree Inventory Contract Amendment 04/30/02 Memo to Heather Woodruff, City Clerk, copy to Hugh Earnest, Uban Dev. Director, from Kim Hesse, regarding Tree Inventory Contract 05/14/02 Copy of Purchase Requisition Form 02/19/02 Staff Review Form 01/31/02 Urban Development Department Correspondence to Fayetteville City Council from Hugh Earnest, Urban Dev. Director, Kim Hesse, Tree and Landscape Administrator, regarding city-wide tree inventory 02/26/02 Memo to Kim Hesse, Public Lands -Landscape Division, from Heather Woodruff, City Clerk 04/29/02 Memo to Kim Hesse, Landscape Administrator, from Heather Woodruff, City Clerk 05/30/02 Memo Kim Hesse, Public Lands-Landscape/Urban Development, from Heather Woodruff, City Clerk NOTES: • . tees zs� 0z `B' MICR AMENDED SCOPE OF WORK �FILMrD This Addendum to Consultant Agreement is made and entered into the /9ti day of FeBaAb2002, by and between Burditt Associates of Montgomery County, Texas (hereinafter called the i/ "CONSULTANT ), and CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE (hereinafter calledCLIENT' ). This Addendum to Consultant Agreement extends the expiration date of the Consultant Agreement to August 31, 2002. DUTIES OF CONSULTANT: Burditt Associates will provide all labor, tools, equipment, supplies, products, personnel, and necessary supervision to provide the following: • Component One: Computerized Street Tree Inventory • Component Two: Filtered Tree Inventory Data (in Access File format) for use in Hansen Information Technologies System • Component Three: Urban Forestry Management Plan The project will be conducted under the direction of the City of Fayetteville's Public Lands Maintenance Department. Reporting and coordination of the project will be conducted through this department unless otherwise directed. The following services are to be supplied by Burditt Associates. This AMENDED SCOPE OF WORK supersedes the EXHIBIT 'A' SCOPE OF WORK contained in the original CONSULTANT AGREEMENT executed on May 15, 2001. CLIENT and CONSULTANT agree that Exhibit "A" SCOPE OF WORK was in full force and effect from the signing of the Consultant Agreement until the signing of this Amended Scope of Work, Exhibit "B". After the date herein, the Fees and Scope of Work will be amended as set forth herein. COMPONENT ONE: COMPUTERIZED STREET TREE INVENTORY Field Data Collection - All data collected to date (as of September 10, 2001) will be supplied to the City of Fayetteville in addition to data for specific street trees growing on City of Fayetteville maintained street ROW within only areas 1 and 2, as shown on Exhibit "C". Trees 8" in diameter and greater growing in ROW areas considered to be natural and unmaintained will be inventoried. No trees smaller than 8" in diameter growing in ROW's considered natural or unmaintained will be inventoried. In accordance with instruction by the City of Fayetteville's Public Lands Maintenance Department the ROW surrounded by the West Side of Shadow Ridge Drive and the East Side of Ridgeway will be excluded from the inventory. Tree Count for Areas 1 and 2 will be limited to 6,225 trees. No data will be collected on Planting Space locations. No data will be collected on Stump Removal locations. Data to be Collected - Items 1 - 7 will be based upon the same criteria established with City of Fayetteville for previously collected data. Following is the data and a description of each item: 1. Street Address - Address of tree location including street name and number City ofFaydt villc Page I Exhibit B Strad True btvanury M a,dcd Same of Work EXHIBIT `B' AMENDED SCOPE OF WORK 2. Tree Identification - Species of each individual tree by genus, species and common name 3. Size - Size of tree by diameter range measured 4. Condition of Tree - Rating according to the five condition factors developed by the International Society of Arboriculture including: • Trunk • Scaffold Branches • Smaller Branches and Twigs • Foliage • Roots 5. Defects - Identify the defects of each tree including: • Physical Defects • Insect Related Defects • Disease Related Defects 6. Maintenance Requirements - A priority list of work assignments using the following criteria: • Priority One Tree Removal Trees designated for removal have defects that cannot be cost effectively or practically treated. The majority of trees in this category have a large percentage of dead crown and re potential safety hazards Large dead and dying trees that are high liability risks are included in this Category. These trees are the first ones that should be removed. • Priority Two Tree Removal: Trees that should be removed but do not pose a liability as great as the first priority. • Priority Three Tree Removal: Trees that should be removed, but that pose minimal liability to persons or property, e.g. transplant failure or amenity removal Priority One Prune: Trees recommended for pruning to remove hazardous deadwood and dead or diseased limbs greater than 4 inches in diameter. • Priority Two Prune: These trees have dead, dying, diseased or weakened branches between two (2) and four (4) inches in diameter and are potential safety hazards. • Large Tree Routine Prune: These trees require horticultural pruning to correct structural problems or growth patterns which would eventually obstruct traffic Cay of Faydt ville Page 2 Exhibit n gree Troc btvddory Amonddl Saye of Work EXHIBIT `B' AMENDED SCOPE OF WORK or interfere with utility wires or buildings. Trees in this category are large enough to require bucket tree access or manual climbing. • Small Tree Routine Prune: These trees require routing horticultural pruning to correct structural problems or growth pattems which would eventually obstruct traffic or interfere with utility wires or buildings. There trees are small species, mature trees that can be evaluated and pruned from the ground. • Train Prune: Young large trees that are small still must be pruned to correct or eliminate weak, interfering, or objectionable branches in order to minimize future maintenance requirements. These trees, up to 20 feet in height, can be worked with a pole saw by a person standing on the ground. 7. Site Description - Three site description criteria will include: • Land Use: The dominant use of the property adjacent to the right-of-way: Apartment Municipal Boulevard Park Business Residence Church School Hospital Vacant Lot Island Industrial • Growing Space: The area between the curb and the edge of the right-of-way. • Growing Space is 1' to 4' wide • Growing Space is 5' to 9' wide • Growing Space is >9' wide • Sidewalk is integral with curb • No sidewalk • Growing Space is paved • Plant is behind a sidewalk yet within right of way. • Overhead Utilities: Describing the absence of presence of utility lines: • Electric • Communication • No Utilities 8. Tree Latitude and Longitude - Tree latitude and longitude will be collected from City of Fayetteville GIS base maps. 9. No data will be collected on available planting spaces . City of Fayetteville Pare 3 Exhibit B SYreet Tree invmtory Amended Scope of Work • • EXHIBIT `B' AMENDED SCOPE OF WORK Additional criteria or items to be provided but not specifically requested: 1. Tree Number - Tree numbering at each address i.e. TI, T2, etc. 2. Technical Memorandums - Provide technical memorandums to Fayetteville, Public Lands Department Director or Designee. 3. Hazard Tree Notification - Timely written notification of obvious eminent hazard trees to City Forestry Department during the inventory process. 4. Detailed and Sequential Files - Maintain Detailed and Sequential Files of the Project. COMPONENT TWO: FILTERED TREE INVENTORY DATA ((in Access File format) for use in Hansen Information Technologies System The City of Fayetteville has elected to utilize a data management system supplied by Hansen Information Technologies. Burditt Associates will supply all collected data in an Access File format that will then be utilized by Hansen to import into their system. Burditt Associates will filter and cleanup the data prior to transfer. Actual transfer into Hansen /Fayetteville system will be completed by Hansen staff or City's representative. The Lump Sum Fee for this service is fixed equal to the original set fee of $4,975.00. COMPONENT THREE: URBAN FORESTRY MANAGEMENT PLAN Following inventory of the remaining city wide tree resources applicable to the amended Scope of Work, Burditt Associates will develop a comprehensive Urban Forest Management Plan. The plan will target and address the needs as determined in the inventory phase, as well as be based upon interviews with City personnel responsible for tree management and maintenance. It shall also offer recommendations for future tree operations over the next 5 to 10 years. The plan will provide for: • Hazard Management - Risk management is necessary to ensure the safety of the residents of Fayetteville and also to reduce liability of the City and associated organizations. Treatment to mitigate and/or reduce hazard conditions should be a major part of the management criteria for urban forest management. Reducing the risk associated with hazardous trees will include the development of a policy that will protect the City and it's residents, employees, contractors and visitors from potential tragedy or damages. Tree removal operations to reduce hazard conditions will concentrate on trees the aro Priority One and Two and then move on to hazard prune operations. • Pruning Scheduling - Pruning operations in the Fayetteville must be cost effective and practical. While pruning every tree in the city would not be a practical approach at this time, a more realistic goal would implement a pruning cycle for all large trees that are growing in close proximity to areas frequented by people with an emphasis placed on those trees designated as Priority One and Two pruning. A schedule could be developed that would adequately address the health of the Urban Forest and the safety of the city residents and visitors. As extensive tree planting occurs, a regulated cycle should be implemented to provide for pruning at regular intervals. Cny of Fayetteville Patc 4 Exilibit B Stroa Trot Inventory Amended Soopc of Work • • EXHIBIT 'B' AMENDED SCOPE OF WORK • Insect, Disease Treatment and Fertilization - Tree maintenance issues will be necessary when dealing with insects, diseases, pests and nutrient deficiencies. General urban forest protection issues must be anticipated and addressed within the document. • Resource Allocation and Budgetary Requirements - With the limited resources of money, manpower and equipment that the City of Fayetteville and many other cities are facing, creative approaches are necessary to implement and utilize a comprehensive Urban Forest Management Plan. The approach necessary must be practical and implementable according to the commitment of the residents of Fayetteville. • Park Management - All parks cemeteries will be inspected and assessed for overall health, canopy cover, species diversity, and management needs. A section of the management plan will address any needs and recommendations for increased tree canopy cover and health. • Canopy Revitalization - Older, more established areas may require revitalization of the canopy cover and/or assessment of the same according to usage and purpose of the tree cover. • Preservation Planning - To preserve the existing trees within the city and enhance value, a preservation plan for site development (both new and redevelopment) and protection of the urban forest environment is essential. Preservation planning will be addressed within the Urban Forest Management Plan. • Community Awareness and Education Program/Plan - The key to any successful resource management program will be a well prepared community awareness plan. Municipal forestry departments, public works departments, parks and recreation departments and community associations all have a public image. This image may be real or imagined, but it exists in the eyes of the general public. Only through an effort to educate the public can many of the necessary management practices be implemented and adequate budgets be set aside with community support. • Tree Planting / Aforestation / Reforestation Initiatives - An assessment should be made of the needs for establishing or reestablishing tree cover throughout Fayetteville. Areas that have no tree cover should be assessed for aforestation (areas previously unforested) efforts Many of the new areas in the city currently do not have adequate tree cover and will require reforestation efforts utilizing proper species diversity and maintenance procedures favorable to survival. The existing tree cover should be assessed for overall health and longevity or need for reforestation. Goals of canopy cover and ability to maintain these areas must be taken into account during the process. • Urban/Rural or Wildland Interface - The sprawling nature of today's urban areas creates many challenges such as fire suppression, emergency services, and fragmentation of wildlife habitat, just to name a few. Methods to address these considerations should be included in any Urban Forest Management Plan. City of Fayetteville Page 5 Exhibit 8 Strocl Tree In 'aitory Amended scoot of Work EXHIBIT 'B' AMENDED SCOPE OF WORK • Additional Recommendations for Improved Management - Other recommendations for improvements to the Urban Forest of Fayetteville could include an Urban Ecosystem Analysis to determine the value and benefits of the existing tree cover. Specific assistance in planning future expansion of City services and infrastructure should be included. To be a working document, the plan should encompass the Parks Department's goals, objectives, strategies, administration, budget and overall work program. The plan should describe the day-to-day, short range, and long-range direction of the department Trees will be assessed for hazards by ocular methods. While this is quite effective at identifying obvious needs for hazard removals, many fractures, hollows, etc., may not be identifiable due to the time and budgetary restraints and the methods described above. Burditt Associates makes no warranty for hazard accuracy as applied to Acts of God, the negligence of others, or hazards not obvious from a visual inspection at the time of data collection. FEES: Component One: Urban Forest Inventory Street Tree Inventory - • Inventory of individual trees actually collected @ $ 1.95 per tree • No Planting Spaces will be inventoried after the signing of this Amendment. • Component One will include trees located in Areas 1 and 2 only (See Exhibit 'C') and will not exceed a budget of $ 12,139.75 Component Two: Inventory Software • Data filtering, cleanup, conversion, and preparation of data for import into Hansen software by Hansen personnel. Lump Sum Fee of $ 4,975.00 Component Three: Comprehensive Urban Forest Management Plan • Management Plan Lump Sum Fee of S 7,900.00 Outstanding Invoices: Client and Consultant agree that there is an outstanding invoice balance of $7,985 25 Client (City of Fayetteville) acknowledges the outstanding invoice and agrees to pay Consultant (Burditt Associates) the full balance owing within 15 days of the signing of this Amendment. The total of all fees for Components One, Two, and Three and the Outstanding Invoices will not exceed $ 33,000.00. Fees previously paid by City of Fayetteville are excluded. City of Frymevillc Page G Et.iba B Strut Tru: Inventory Ama,dod Scope of Work • • EXHIBIT 'B' AMENDED SCOPE OF WORK DUTIES OF CLIENT: CLIENT will pay CONSULTANT on the basis of monthly invoices showing the services performed during the preceeding month. CLIENT will expeditiously review Consultant's invoice. CLIENT will pay CONSULTANT within 30 days of receipt of an approved invoice and in accordance with the terms of the Consultant Agreement. CLIENT, Client's Agents or Representatives, will supply GIS -based street level maps. CLIENT will pay all outstanding invoices totaling $ 7,985.25 within 15 days from the date of execution of this Amended Scope of Work. Amended Scope of Work is accepted on ,,,,M/ e,Z , 2002 by: CLIENT CONSULTANT CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE BURDITT ASSOCIATES By: Date By: Charles Burditt Owner Date Coy of Faymailk Pago 7 &art B Shat Tree Inventory Mnmdod Soopc of Work AMENDMENT TO THE • cC',d AGREEMENT WITH &d,G11 " /_34,,e64 -1g5 AMENDMENT 4_ 1 This is an amendment to the Agreement for .�,i el' executed on the (-✓ day of/� /M c5242/ between the City of Fayetteville, Arkansas and IE tirt���T7 it .5.4 6' lel I :p' 1J Additional services required due to /2•,S411-1Sc-5 • The charge for the additional services shall not exceed CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE: Mayor • • Company. Title • Date Date • FOR OFFICE USE ONLY Existing P.O. # Contract # 3 • 1 .. Planning Design Management Nair PO. Box 1424 Conroe. TX 77305 Conroe: 2040 W. Loop 336 Conroe, TX 77304 936.756.3041 Houston: 261447.2111 Far 936.539.3240 hwwAurdinassociates.com inlo@Ourdittassociates.com • BURDITT ASSOCIATES • Urban Forest Consultants May 15, 2002 SENT OVERNIGHT DELIVERY VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS Ms. Kim 1, Hesse, RLA City of Fayetteville 113 W. Mountain Fayetteville, AR 72701 RE' Amended Consultant Agreement for Professional Services; City of Fayetteville Tree Inventory Dear Ms. Hesse Pursuant to your instructions, please find enclosed three (3) executed originals of the Amended Scope of Work. Please have them executed and return one original to us. Upon receipt of the executed document, we will schedule this next phase of inventory. We look forward to continuing this important project. /wc Enclosure • Sincerely, Vded Wanda Collins Project Manager • • FAYETTEVILLE THE CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, ARKANSAS LANDSCAPE ADMINISTRATION DATE: 5-14-2002 TO: Mayor Dan Coody; Peggy Vice, Purchasing Director COPY: Hugh Earnest, kkban Development Director FROM: Kim J. Hesse v\ RE: Tree Inventory Contract Amendment Included are three original copies of the amendment to the tree inventory contract with Burditt and Associates. Included for contract review are copies of Resolution No. 28-02 approving the amendment, the Contract Amendment Form, the signed staff review form and a Purchase Requisition. Please feel free to contact me if you have questions or comments. • • FAYETTEVILLE THE CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, ARKANSAS LANDSCAPE ADMINISTRATION DATE: 4-30-2002 TO: Heather•W o odruff.,,City Clerk COPY: Hugh Earnest, Urban Development Director FROM: Kim J. Hesse RE: Tree Inventory Contract We are reviewing the amendment to the contract as we speak. Peggy Vice and David Whitaker are reviewing the contract preliminarily. Once their suggestions are included, I will have Burditt and Associates supply three copies of an original contract, signed by them. I will send around the contract review form then. Thanks for checking. A CO N --• m 3 Requester. Kim Hesse 0. "Z n 0 Address: I P.O. Box 1424 Vendor #: management plan. tree inventory, management software and 1 Professional services for a city wide street v g S C". Q X m m' Vendor Name: Burditt Associates se Requisition (not. pun - lase ad Unit I Unit w. Cast u AA Dei Zip: 77305 O O VI o o 0 o $0.00 m X - aa 4470-9470-5315-00 Account Number 'Requester's Employee#: 531 Ship To Code: 215 c FOB Point: Fayetteville, AR 19 Mgr 'elO 96084 Z 3 cilia 3� 0 W o 5. o' ‘)b< < -I mo. � o z o < 3 c 1 P.O. Number. 'Expected Delivery Date: rRequisition No.: Dale: 05/14/02 �m $2.186.25 4;- { AGENDA REQUEST x CONTRACT REVIEW GRANT REVIEW SOF REVIEW FORM For the Fayetteville City Council meeting of: 19 -Feb -02 FROM: Kim J. Hesse Name Public Lands - Landscape Urban Development Division Department ACTION REQUIRED: Approve a Resolution authorizing a contract change with Burditt Assoc. in the amount of $33.000.to complete the city wide tree inventory and provide software and management plan. COST TO CITY: $33.000.00 Cost of this request 4470-9470-5315-00 Account Number 96084 Project Number 6--,C), nine') Forestry Program Category/Project Budget Category/Project Name — 0— Other CIP Funds Used to Date Program Name %O, (>00 Sales Tax Capital Remaining Balance Fund BUDGET REVIEW: udget Coordinator Budgeted Item II o'r Administrative Services Director Budget Adjustment Attached CONTRACT/GRANT/LEASE REVIEW: A ( GRANTING AGENCY: ateL ADA Coordinator 1 RAJ (1 Cary Ao� Date Internal Au itor Y1j �or Date Purchasing Officer Grants Coordinator Date Date Date STAFF RECO MEND ION: gepa, ent lirector Adm' strative Services Director ayor / c3/-OaCross Reference Date New Item: ILO Date Prev Ord/Res #: o ae ate e YES NO Orig. Contract Date: 1, ✓ IyQewilat GeSt ate-' chu ✓!19141 Ac4cec Y4iido %tac ertt ✓.ut y F,n�j ,, 5„1„+,7.„.cn� • Alts r� 'ku4nl fuel./ Ji- f1% .tt rico tM c �+rma SJV� p"" ' 'i-- �— l 1 •� �ce� AOAt_1L J✓' .4 L3'�.2 (,J t -i< 'i'rraMJrnia`t<°dl -in. Met TT" y� ,,,$„r.,�r�a4a j p� r✓t S53.mJt_� cQRS a+e o-'ui Cam D �f Description: • STAFF REVIEW FORM Comments: Budget Coordinator: Accounting Manager: City Attorney: Purchasing Officer: ADA Coordinator: Internal Auditor: Grants Coordinator •Page 2 Meeting Date: Reference Comments: FAYETTEVILLE THE CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, ARKANSAS 1 I3 W. Mountain St. Fayetteville, AR 72701 'Telephone: (50 I ) 575-8330 URBAN DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT CORRESPONDENCE To: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Fayetteville City Council Hugh Earnest, Urban Development Director Kim Hesse, Tree and Landscape Administrator January 31, 2002 City-wide Tree Inventory Back round On May 15th, 2001 the Council approved a resolution to award a contract to Burditt Association not to exceed $25,000.00, to conduct a City-wide street tree inventory. That contract amount was based on a per tree basis assuming that the city had approximately 4500 trees within the rights-of-way. The number of trees used in calculating the cost came from an earlier inventory done by Natural Path Forestry Consultants. The contract also included inventory of appropriate locations for future tree planting projects, a management plan for existing trees, and a software package that could combine with our GIS system. Work began on this effort in July of last year and continued until September 10, 2001, when the contractor was told to stop any work. The reason for the stoppage was the receipt of an invoice in excess of the amount authorized by council. No payment over the authorized amount has been made. A principal factor in this overage is that the number of trees inventoried by the consultant is now over 9,000 with slightly more than 60% of the city inventoried Simply put, we made an error in our original estimate of our tree inventory. That inventory has been ongoing and we find that the city contains possibly three times the trees originally assumed. Monthly statements should have been requested from the contractor, which would have enabled us to better manage the contract. We have corrected this situation. In our original presentaion to the Council for this project, we pointed out that this inventory and management plan will provide us with a guide as to which areas of town we should concentrate efforts for tree maintenance The CIP affords $60,000 yearly toward the Urban Forestry program, which includes tree pruning and removal of hazardous trees. Currently we respond to complaints and concerns about dead or hazardous trees. The crews for the Street Department spend several hours after each storm, sometime during the night and on weekends, removing tree limbs from roadways. The City should be pruning dead limbs and removing hazardous trees before problems • • occur. This inventory and the accompanying software and management plan will details key areas of concern and guide us towards determining how much of our funds should go towards maintenance and how much toward tree planting projects. In summary, this effort will enable us to do some level of pre -planning for tree maintenance and replacement. Current Status We are requesting that the Council approve additional funds to continue the inventory and complete the contract. In order to reduce the size and cost of the project, we are suggesting the remaining inventory include only the existing trees and discontinue the inventory of potential planting spaces. We will attempt to complete the planting space inventory through use of interns or as part of a college project. We do have several parts of town that are heavily tree covered and that need to be counted including Mt. Sequoia and the area west of the University of Arkansas. We also will need the software and management plan to implement a maintenance program for the trees. Recommendation We believe that this project is important in our overall effort to maintain Fayetteville's deserved reputation as a Tree City. In order to ensure that both staff and council are comfortable with the direction and scope of this project, we have requested that the principal in Burditt Association be present at the Council meeting to make a brief presentation and answer any questions that the Council may have. In order to complete this effort we are recommending that an additional $33,000 be added to the contract. In the event that a decision is made to discontinue this effort, we would ask that the council authorize the payment of the $8,000 that is in excess of the original amount. FAYETTEVhLE THE CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, ARKANSAS DEPARTMENTAL CORRESPONDENCE . To: Kim J. Hesse, Public Lands -Landscape Division From: Heather Woodruff, City Clerk Date: February 26, 2002 Please find attached a copy of Resolution No. 28-02 approving Amendment No. 1 to the contract with Burditt Associates to increase city funding to complete the city wide street tree inventory. As of February 25, 2002, we are waiting for Burditt Associates to send Ms. Hesse an original amendment for signatures. The original will be microfilmed and filed with the City Clerk. cc: Nancy Smith, Internal Audit Hugh Earnest, Urban Development