Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-24 RESOLUTION113 West Mountain Street Fayetteville, AR 72701 (479) 575-8323 Resolution: 97-24 File Number: 2024-1725 NON -UNIFORMED STAFF (PAY AND BENEFITS STUDY): A RESOLUTION TO APPROVE THE JER HR GROUP, LLC'S NON -UNIFORM STAFF PAY AND BENEFITS STUDY, TO APPROVE THE 2024 NON -UNIFORMED STAFF PAY PLAN STRUCTURE, AND TO APPROVE THE 6.34% BUDGET FOR THE PAY PLAN WHEREAS, the City of Fayetteville has employed JER HR Group, LLC to conduct annual compensation and benefit studies, alternating between the City's two pay plans: Non -uniformed (Merit) Staff Pay Plan and Uniformed Step Pay Plans; and WHEREAS, the City's compensation consultant, JER HR Group, LLC conducted the 2024 Non -uniformed (Merit) Staff Pay and Benefits Study and presented this study to the Fayetteville City Council; and WHEREAS, staff recommends the City Council approve the proposed 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure which is recommended by JER HR Group, LLC in compliance with the City's Total Rewards Compensation and Benefits Philosophy. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, ARKANSAS: Section 1: That the City Council of the City of Fayetteville, Arkansas hereby approves the 2024 Non -Uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure increasing compensation for eligible Non -uniformed staff by 6.34%, copies of which are attached to this Resolution. PASSED and APPROVED on March 5, 2024 Page 1 Attest: n.�': �G�� Y O,,%U& 1,21 Kara Paxton, City C c reasur ; FAYET-rEVILLI.; r tk. 9'% SPA ti, AN .J�. ,'��i i�iu%+O```` CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE ARKANSAS MEETING OF MARCH 5, 2024 TO: Mayor Jordan and City Council CITY COUNCIL MEMO 2024-1725 THRU: Susan Norton, Chief of Staff FROM: Missy Cole, Human Resources Director SUBJECT: Acceptance of the Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study and Approval of Proposed 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends the City Council approve the proposed 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure which is recommended by JER HR, the City's compensation consultant, as a result of the Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study. BACKGROUND: On February 6, 2018, the City Council approved guidelines for future compensation studies. These guidelines defined the data sources, survey frequency and types of employee benefits to be evaluated. The City of Fayetteville currently conducts annual compensation and benefits studies, alternating between the City's two pay plans: Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan and Uniformed Step Pay Plans. DISCUSSION: The JER HR 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study Report follows this staff memo. The Report provides a summary of the study and recommendations from JER HR. The study recommendations from JER HR are: Adoption of the 2024 Proposed Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure Budget 6.34% for the 2024 non -uniformed staff pay adjustments Continuation of current competitive employee benefits for non -uniformed staff personnel to meet the City's Total Rewards Compensation and Benefits Philosophy — Competitive base pay to attract applicants within the City's market recruitment area and retain competent employees by leading market recruitment area with total rewards (base pay and benefit) offerings. BUDGET/STAFF IMPACT: A separate agenda item with Mayor Jordan's recommendation for the 2024 Employee Compensation Appropriation Authority and Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure Adjustment will be presented to City Council for consideration. ATTACHMENTS: SRF (#3), 2024 Non -Uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study Report Cover Page (#4), 2024 Non -Uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study Final (#5), Appendix 1 Powerpoint Non - Uniformed Staff Survey Mailing address: 113 W. Mountain Street www.fayetteville-ar.gov Fayetteville, AR 72701 (#6), Appendix 2 2024 Non -Uniformed Staff Study Summary of Findings and Recs (#7), Appendix 3 Geographical Compensation Differential Percentage and GCD Multiplier (#8), Appendix 4 Proposed 2024 Non - uniformed Staff Pay Plan - Hourly and Salary Ranges by Pay Grade (#9), Appendix 5 Individual Pay Study Worksheets for 98 Benchmark Position Titles (#10), Appendix 6 Rolled up Pay Study Variances Analysis Worksheet for all 98 Position Titles (#11), Appendix 7 Consolidated Benefits Study Summary Worksheets (#12) Mailing address: 113 W. Mountain Street www.fayetteville-ar.gov Fayetteville, AR 72701 == City of Fayetteville, Arkansas Y 113 West Mountain Street Fayetteville, AR 72701 (479)575-8323 - Legislation Text File #: 2024-1725 Acceptance of the Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study and Approval of Proposed 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure A RESOLUTION TO APPROVE THE JER HR GROUP, LLC'S NON -UNIFORM STAFF PAY AND BENEFITS STUDY, TO APPROVE THE 2024 NON -UNIFORMED STAFF PAY PLAN STRUCTURE, AND TO APPROVE THE 6.34% BUDGET FOR THE PAY PLAN WHEREAS, the City of Fayetteville has employed JER HR Group, LLC to conduct annual compensation and benefit studies, alternating between the City's two pay plans: Non -uniformed (Merit) Staff Pay Plan and Uniformed Step Pay Plans; and WHEREAS, the City's compensation consultant, JER HR Group, LLC conducted the 2024 Non - uniformed (Merit) Staff Pay and Benefits Study and presented this study to the Fayetteville City Council; and WHEREAS, staff recommends the City Council approve the proposed 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure which is recommended by JER HR Group, LLC in compliance with the City's Total Rewards Compensation and Benefits Philosophy. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE, ARKANSAS: Section 1: That the City Council of the City of Fayetteville, Arkansas hereby approves the 2024 Non - Uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure increasing compensation for eligible Non -uniformed staff by 6.34%, copies of which are attached to this Resolution. Page 1 Missy Cole Submitted By City of Fayetteville Staff Review Form 2024-1725 Item ID 3/5/2024 City Council Meeting Date - Agenda Item Only N/A for Non -Agenda Item 2/12/2024 HUMAN RESOURCES (120) Submitted Date Division / Department Action Recommendation: Staff recommends the City Council approve the 2024 proposed Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure which is recommended by JERHR, the City's compensation consulting company, as a result of the 2023 Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study. ####. ###. ####- 51##. ## Account Number Project Number Budgeted Item? Yes Does item have a direct cost? No Is a Budget Adjustment attached? No Purchase Order Number: Change Order Number: Original Contract Number: Comments: Budget Impact: Total Amended Budget Expenses (Actual+Encum) Available Budget Item Cost Budget Adjustment Remaining Budget All Funds Fund Project Title $ 85,191,863.00 $ 10,021,488.00 75,170,375.00 S 75,170,375.00 Previous Ordinance or Resolution # Approval Date: V20221130 r CITY OF FAYETTEVI LLE 2024 NON -UNIFORMED STAFF PAY AND BENEFITS STUDY REPORT February 12, 2024 PRESENTED TO: The Honorable Mayor Lioneld Jordan Honorable Members of the City Council PRESENTED BY: Blair Johanson and Cliff Sandsmark Senior Managing Consultant and Senior Compensation Consultant HRGroup CamulnnK•R.w-ruiunK.TrunnK COMPENSATION MANAGEMENT SERVICES ARKANSAS OFFICE z9z8 McKee Circle, Ste 123 Fayetteville, AR 72703 479.521.2697 February 12, 2024 To: The Honorable Mayor Lioneld Jordan Honorable Members of the City Council From: Blair Johanson, Managing Consultant Cliff Sandsmark, Senior Consultant JER HR Group, Inc. Subject: 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study Report JER HR Group is pleased to provide this Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits study report. It is based on an analysis of non -uniformed staff position classifications, actual pay and pay range comparisons with competing municipalities in the City's primary labor market (Bentonville, Rogers, and Springdale) and two benchmark cities (Jonesboro, AR and Lawrence, KS) located outside the Northwest Arkansas region. In addition, with City Council direction, we included pay and pay range comparisons with public and private organizations' data from published pay studies inclusive of the 2023 NOARK Wage and Benefits survey, DOL-BLS survey for the NWA Metro area, Compdata and CompAnalyst. This memo narrative summarizes the 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study findings and recommendations. City Council Directives for Biennial Non -uniformed and Civil Service Pay and Benefits Studies • Total Rewards: Compensation & Benefits Philosophy — Competitive base pay to attract applicants within the City's market recruitment area and retain competent employees by leading market recruitment area with total rewards (base pay and benefit) offerings • Study Data Sources include Market Area Cities (Bentonville, Rogers, Springdale, Jonesboro and Lawrence, KS) and published compensation and benefits studies: 2023 NOARK Wage and Benefits survey, DOL-BLS survey for the NWA Metro area, Compdata and CompAnalyst • Evaluation of Employee Benefit Options — Five major prevalent benefits: Retirement, Medical/Dental, Time Off, Shift/On-Call Pay, and Tuition Reimbursement • Frequency of surveys — Every other year (Civil Service -odd years and non -uniformed -even years) • Financially sustainable structures for step & non -uniformed pay plans • Apples to apples comparison on step and non -uniformed range mins and maxes DISCUSSION OF THE NON -UNIFORMED STAFF PAY PLAN STRUCTURE The non -uniformed staff pay grade structure was established and implemented on March 27, 2017, with the most recent revision on April 4, 2022. The 2024 non -uniformed staff pay study is based on 98 benchmark positions that were recommended by the members of the City's executive Page 1 1 leadership team. The selected benchmark positions represent a cross-section among the City's non -uniformed staff pay plan grades. The study included average hourly pay rates and average hourly pay range minimums, midpoints, and maximums by each benchmarked job title. In addition, average pay range spreads by job title were studied. Actual Average Hourly Pay by Job Title As part of the market compensation study, JER HR Group asked the market study municipalities to provide average hourly pay rates by job title. JER HR Group obtained the same information from the published pay studies as requested for the non -uniformed staff pay study. The Fayetteville non - uniformed staff employees' average pay for the 98 benchmark positions is above the market pay average by 0.80%. The study summary of actual pay variance appears in Appendix 2 and the detailed market pay study worksheets for each of the 98 individual benchmark job titles are in Appendix 5. Pay Range Comparisons by Job Title In addition to average hourly pay, the market study municipalities submitted average hourly pay range minimums, midpoints, and maximums for the 98 benchmarked positions. The Fayetteville non -uniformed staff employees' pay grade range minimums, midpoints, and maximums for the 98 benchmark positions are below the market pay range averages by-2.21%, -6.34% and -3.83% respectively. The study summary of pay range minimum, midpoint and maximum variance percentages appears in Appendix 2, and the detailed market study pay range worksheets for each of the 98 individual benchmark job titles are in Appendix 5. It is our recommendation that the City increase its current non -uniformed staff pay plan structure by 6.34%. With this proposed market pay adjustment, the City's non -uniformed staff pay plan structure will maintain its market competitiveness until the next review in 2026. Market Pay Study for Employee Pay Increases for 2024 The City of Fayetteville budgeted 5% in 2022 and 6% in 2023 of its current annual base wages for non -uniformed staff pay adjustments. This has been a non -uniformed staff competitive pay positioning and retention tool for the City of Fayetteville. A market pay study for employee pay increases for 2024 is a one -page summary document found in Appendix 2. A recommendation for a budgeted 6.34%for 2024 non -uniformed staff pay increases is based on the findings summarized in Appendix 5 document. DISCUSSION OF THE EXTERNAL PREVALENT MARKET BENEFITS STUDY Retirement Plan The City of Fayetteville has adopted and continues to offer a 401(a)-457 retirement plan for its non - uniformed staff employees. The City contributes 12% of an employee's annual base salary; and non -uniformed staff employees can contribute 3% up to the 457 annual maximum of their respective annual base salaries. This compares to the market benefit study for retirement plans where the average city employer's annual base salary percentage contribution is 9.73% and the average employee annual base salary contribution is 4.4%. The City of Fayetteville's non - Page 1 2 uniformed staff retirement plan annual contribution exceeds the market average by 2.27% as noted in Appendix 2. Medical and Dental Plans The City of Fayetteville offers several medical health insurance plan options, and the most popular plan is the High Deductible Health Plan (HDHP) with Health Savings Account contributions made by the City. The City of Fayetteville's cost share of the HDHP insurance monthly premiums and annual HSA contributions for its employees exceed the market. The City of Fayetteville offers dental and the dental insurance premiums are paid by employees. The market average cost share for dental insurance premiums is 40%. The dental premiums cost share percentage is an area for market competitiveness improvement for the City of Fayetteville. The City's HDHP with a Health Savings Account contribution creates a positive total rewards outcome for employees based on monthly employee cost share of health care insurance premiums, annual employee deductibles and out of pocket expenses as compared to market health care benefit averages as shown in Appendix 7. The City of Fayetteville's employee wellness plan is competitive by offering flu shots, Hep B shots, well-being day, individual health coaching and wellness incentives. The five municipal cities in the non -uniformed staff benefits study offer various wellness components, but their plans are not as comprehensive as the plan offerings provided under the City's current wellness plan program. Time Off Plans Non -uniformed staff employees' annual time off plans inclusive of holidays, vacation days, sick days and personal days are competitive with market study averages except for annual sick day accrual. The City offers 12 annual holidays, accrual for 10 to 26 annual vacation days, accrual for 12 annual sick days and 2 personal days. The market average for accrued annual sick days is 14.8 days. Market study averages for time off plans are displayed on page 2 of Appendix 2. Tuition Reimbursement Plans Only one of the five market study municipalities offers a tuition reimbursement plan. The City of Bentonville offers a tuition reimbursement plan with an annual maximum benefit of $1,500. If the City of Fayetteville decides to offer a tuition reimbursement plan in the near future, it is our recommendation to include an annual maximum benefit level as offered in the City of Bentonville's plan. Shift/On-Call Pay The non -uniformed staff pay study included questions about shift differential pay and on -call pay. The five market study municipalities do not offer shift differential pay for non -uniformed staff positions based on their survey responses. The 2023 NOARK study with a higher weighting of manufacturing companies has a mode shift differential of $1.25 per hour. The market average for On -Call pay is $15 as compared to $20.15 per day for the City of Fayetteville. Page 13 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR THE NON -UNIFORMED STAFF PAY AND BENEFITS STUDY • Adoption of the 2024 Proposed Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan Structure • Budget 6.34% for the 2024 non -uniformed staff pay adjustments • Continuation of current competitive employee benefits for non -uniformed staff personnel to meet the City's Total Rewards Compensation and Benefits Philosophy — Competitive base pay to attract applicants within the City's market recruitment area and retain competent employees by leading market recruitment area with total rewards (base pay and benefit) offerings. List of Appendices: 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study Report Cover Page Appendix 1: PowerPoint Non -uniformed Staff Survey 2024 Appendix 2: Pay and Benefits Study Summary of Findings and Recommendations Appendix 3: Geographical Compensation Differential Percentage and GCD Multiplier Appendix 4: Proposed 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay Plan — Hourly and Salary Ranges by Pay Grade Appendix 5: Individual Pay Study Worksheets for 98 Benchmark Position Titles Appendix 6: Rolled up Pay Study Variances Analysis Worksheet for All 98 Position Titles Appendix 7: Consolidated Benefits Study Summary Worksheets JER HR Group would be pleased to answer any questions you have concerning this report and the recommendations for the 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study. It has been a pleasure working with the City's Human Resources team, Administration, Chiefs and Department Directors on the 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study. Sincerely, Blair Johanson Managing Consultant JER HR Group, Inc. Phone: 479-521-2697 www.jerhrgroup.com Page 14 CITY OF FAYETTEVILLE ARKANSAS 2024 Non -uniformed Positions Base Pay and Benefits Study City Council Agenda Session 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Non -uniformed Staff Positions City Council — Future Pay and Benefits Studies • Total Rewards: Comp. &Benefits Philosophy - Competitive base pay to attract applicants within the City-s market recruitment area - Retain competent employees by leading market recruitment area with total rewards (base pay and benefit) offerings • Study Market Area: Bentonville, Rogers, Springdale, Jonesboro and Lawrence; NOARK Study, DOL, Compdata & CompAnalyst • Evaluation of Employee Benefit Options - 5 major benefits - Retirement Plan, Medical/Dental, Time Off Plans, Shift/On-call Pay and Education Reimbursement Plans • Frequency of surveys - Every other year, alternate Uniformed and Non -uniformed • Financially sustainable structures for step & Non -uniformed pay plans • Apples to apples on step and Non -uniformed range mins and m axes 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Non -uniformed Staff Positions Total Rewards: Base Pay Study Results Market Market Market Market Actual Average Average Average Pay Avg. Pay Range Pay Range Pay Range Minimum Midpoint Maximum Overall 0.80% -2.21 % -6.34% -3.90% Base pay study overall variance averages are based on 98 benchmark positions. 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Non -uniformed Staff Positions Base Pay Plan Study Recommendation Current Non -uniformed Positions Pay Structure since 4-4-2022 Proposed Non -uniformed Positions Pay Structure Adjustment for 2024: 6.34% Market Pay Structure Midpoint Variance Based on the Non -uniformed Staff Positions Study of 98 Benchmarked Positions PROPOSED NON -UNIFORMED STAFF PAY PLAN EFFECTIVE DATE 4/1/2024 Annualized amounts are based on hourly rates. GRADEiDESC HOURS HOURLY RATE ANNUALIZED MIN MARKET MAX I MIN MARKET MAX MERIT EMPLOYEES J410 T 2080 $14.74 $17.76 $22.02 $30.659.20 $36,940.80 $45,801.60 J411 T' 2080 $16.17 $19.48 $24.16 $33,633.60 $40,518.40 $50,252.80 J412 T 2080 S16.71 $20.13 $24.96 $34,756.80 $41,870.40 $51,916.80 J413 T ' 2080 $17.79 $21.43 $26.57 $37,003.20 $44,574.40 $55,265.60 J414 T 2080 S18.84 $22.70 $28.15 $39,187.20 S47,216.00 $58,552.00 J415 T' 2080 $19.92 $24.00 $29.76 $41,433.60 $49,920.00 $61,900.80 J416 T 1 2080 S20.99 $25.29 $31.36 $43,659.20 $52,603.20 $65,228.80 J417 T1 2080 $22.05 $26.57 $32.95 $45,864.00 $55,265.60 $68,536.00 J418 T1 2080 S23.12 $27.86 $34.55 $48,089.60 S57,948.80 $71,864.00 J419 T1 2080 $24.19 $29.15 $36.15 $50,31520 $60,632.00 $75,192.00 J420 T' 2080 $25.27 $30.45 $37.76 $52,561.60 $63,336.00 $78,540.80 J421 T2 2080 $25.31 $30.49 $37.81 $52,644.80 $63,419.20 $78,644.80 J422 T_' 2080 S2627 $31.65 $39.25 $54.641.60 S65,832.00 $81,640.00 J423 T 2080 S27.28 $32.87 $40.76 $56,742.40 $68,369.60 $84,780.80 J424 T= .080 S28.83 $34.73 $43.07 $59.966.40 $72,238.40 $89,585.60 J425 T_ 2080 $30.87 $37.19 $46.12 $64,209.60 $77,355.20 $95,929.60 J426 T_ 2080 S32.91 $39.65 $49.17 1 $68.452.80 S82,472.00 $1021,2173.60 J427 T2 2080 $34.95 $42.11 $5222 $72.696.00 $87,588.80 $108,617.60 J428 T2 -1080 S37.00 $44.58 $55.28 $76.960.00 $92,726.40 $114,982.40 J429 T2 2080 $39.03 $47.03 $58.32 $81,182.40 $97,822.40 $121,305.60 J430 T2 2080 $41.09 $49.50 $61.38 $85A67.20 $102,960.00 $127,670.40 J431 73 2080 $40.89 $4926 $61.08 $85,051.20 $102,460.80 $127,046.40 J432 T3 2080 $43.07 $51.89 $64.34 $89.585.60 $107,931.20 $133,827.20 J433 T3 2080 $45.26 $54.53 $67.62 $94,140.80 $113,422.40 $140,649.60 J434 T3 2080 $47.46 $57.18 $70.90 $98.716.80 $118,934.40 $147,472.00 J435 T3 2080 S49.64 $59.81 $74.16 $103,251.20 $124,404.80 $154,252.80 J436 T3 2080 S51.83 $62.45 $77.44 $107,806.40 $129,896.00 $161,075.20 J437 T3 2080 $54.02 $65.09 $80.71 $112,361.60 $135,387.20 $167,876.80 J438 T_ 2080 S56.22 $67.73 $83.99 $116,937.60 $140,878.40 $174,699.20 J439 T3 2080 $58.41 $70.37 $87.26 $121,492.80 $146,369.60 $181,500.80 J440 T_ 2080 S60.61 $73A2 $90.54 $126,068.80 $151,881.60 $188,323.20 J441 T_ 2080 $62.80 $75.66 $93.82 $130,624.00 $157,372.80 $195,145.60 J442 T-1 2080 S64.99 $78.30 $97.09 S135,179._20 $162,864.00 $201,94720 J443 T; 2080 $67.76 $81.64 S101.23 $140,940.80 $169,811.20 $210,558.40 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Non -uniformed Staff Positions Market Employee Pay Adjustments for 2024 Bentonville: 3.0% Non -uniformed Rogers: 3.5% COLA and 1% Non -uniformed Springdale: Pay Step Plan Adjustment of 5.22% for 2024 and an average 2.56% Step Jonesboro: 4% COLA and a 2% Step Lawrence: 2.5% COLA and a 5% Step NW Arkansas — Public and Private Organizations: 3.5% to 4.5% Recommendation for 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Budget Pool: 6.34% 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Evaluation of Employee Benefits Top Five Prevalent Benefits —Non-uniformed Staff • Retirement plans • Medical/Dental plans • Time off plans • Shift/On-call pay • Education reimbursement plans 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Evaluation of Employee Benefits Retirement Plan —Non-uniformed Staff Market Study Market Study Fayetteville Fayetteville Employer Employee Employer Employee Average Average Match Contribution Match Contribution 9.73% 4.4% 12% 3% up to 457 Annual Max. 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Evaluation of Employee Benefits Medical/Dental Plans Non -uniformed Staff Positions - FYV Majority HDHP Plan • EE Cost Share: 14-15 • Monthly Prem. $64-$204 • OOP-HSA: Ind. $2,150 • OOP-HSA: Fam. $4,120 Dental Plan • EE Cost Share: 100% • Monthly Prem. $30-$108 Market Medical/Dental PPO & HDHP Plans - One HRA • EE Cost Share: Avg. 16-23 • Monthly Prem. $72-$272 • OOP: Ind. $3,405 • OOP: Fam: $7,725 Dental Plan • EE Cost Share: 40% • Monthly Prem. $0-$105 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Evaluation of Employee Benefits Time Off Plans —Non-uniformed Staff Positions Market Annual Accrued or Offered Days Fayetteville - Days Holidays 11.3 12 Vacation Days 10.2 — 22.7 10 - 26 Sick Days 14.8 12 Personal Days 1 2 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Evaluation of Employee Benefits Shift/On-call Pay • Shift pay is rarely offered for Non -uniformed positions by the market study municipalities. • Shift pay mode is $1.25 per hour for mostly manufacturing positions based the 2023 NOA RK Wage Study. • On -call pay averages $15 per day based on the market study as compared to $20.15 per day for the City of Fayetteville. 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Evaluation of Employee Benefits MEME '"' Zeimbursement Plans � Bentonville is the only city in the surveyed municipalities to offer a tuition reimbursement plan. The plan offers $1,500 maximum reimbursement per year with a passing grade of a "B"or better. • 71 % of the NOARK surveyed organization - company participants in the 2023 wage and benefits study offer tuition reimbursement plans. 2024 Base Pay and Benefits Study Non -uniformed Staff Positions Recommendations • Increase current Non -uniformed Staff pay plan structure by 6.34 to meet the City's competitive base pay compensation philosophy and to maintain momentum from compression adjustments that occurred in 2023. • Continue to retain competent employees by leading the market recruitment area with total rewards (base pay and benefits) offerings. APPENDIX 2 City of Fayetteville Non -uniformed Staff Pay and Benefits Study 2024 Pay and Benefits Study Summary of Findings and Recommendations February 2024 The market pay study overall variances for actual pay and pay range minimums, midpoints, and maximums based on 98 benchmark positions are noted below. Market Actual Pay Avg. Market Average Pay Range Min. Market Average Pay Range Mid. Market Average Pay Range Max. Overall 0.80% -2.21% -6.34% -3.83% Current Non -uniformed Positions Pay Structure based on 2022 survey data. Pay structure adjustment based on current pay structure grade midpoint values for 98 benchmark positions compared to market average pay range midpoints. Non -uniformed Staff Positions Pay Structure Adjustment for 2024 Pay Plan: 6.34% Market Pay Study Employee Pay Increases for 2024 Bentonville: 3.0% Non -uniformed Rogers: 3.5% COLA and 1% Non -uniformed Springdale: Pay Step Plan Adjustment of 5.22% for 2024 and an average 2.56% Step Jonesboro: 4% COLA and a 2% Step Lawrence: 2.5% COLA and a 5% Step NW Arkansas — Public and Private Organizations: 3.5% to 4.5% Recommendation for 2024 Non -uniformed Staff Pay Adjustments: 6.34% Benefits Study Results Retirement Plans Market Study Market Study Fayetteville Fayetteville Employer Average Employee Average Employer Employee Match Contribution Match Contribution 9.73% 4.4% 12% 3% up to 457 Annual Max. Page 1 1 APPENDIX 2 Employee Medical Premium Expense Comparison Market Avg. FYV HDHP Variance Employee Only 16% 14% $72/Mo. $64/Mo. $8/Mo. Employee & Spouse 21% 15% $167/Mo. $146/Mo. $21/Mo. Employee & Child(ren) 20% 15% $144/Mo. $110/Mo. $34/Mo. Employee & Family 23% 15% $272/Mo. $204/Mo. $68/Mo. Employee Deductible and Out of Pocket Expense Comparison Market OOP — HSA$ OOP-HSA$ Variance Individual $3,405 $2,150 $1,255 Family $7,725 $4,120 $3,605 Time -off Plans Market Annual Accrued or Offered Days Fayetteville - Days Holidays 11.3 12 Vacation Days 10.2 — 22.7 10 - 26 Sick Days 14.8 12 Personal Days 1 2/yr. Wellness Plans The City's wellness plan is competitive with market study offerings. Tuition Reimbursement Bentonville: $1,500 maximum per year - Other study cities do not offer tuition reimbursement plans. Shift/On Call Pay Only NOARK Study information on Shift Pay: Mode of $1.25 per hour. On Call Pay: $15/day for market pay study cities and $20.15/day for City of Fayetteville. Page 1 2 APPENDIX 3 2023 Geographical Salary Comparison Administrative Assistant - Average Fayetteville Salary = $40,243 CompAnalyst DOL AR & DOL KS Salary.com Glassdoor / Indeed ERI Nerd Wallet Overall Average Geographic Compensation Differential GCD Multiplier Fayetteville $39,500 $39,460 $41,202 $38,002 $43,292 $40,000 $40,243 1.00 1.00 Bentonville $39,500 $39,460 $41,202 $38,002 $43,292 $40,000 $40,243 1.00 1.00 Rogers $39,500 $39,460 $41,202 $38,002 $43,292 $40,000 $40,243 1.00 1.00 Springdale $39,500 $39,460 $41,202 $38,002 $43,292 $40,000 $40,243 1.00 1.00 Jonesboro $39,400 $36,425 $41,715 $37,530 $41,918 $39,598 $39,431 0.98 1.02 Lawrence $41,500 $40,362 1 $42,721 $43,201 $44,591 1 $41,478 $42,309 1.05 0.95 APPENDIX 4 COMBINED PAY PLAN GRIDS PROPOSED NON -UNIFORMED STAFF PAY PLAN EFFECTIVE DATE 4/1/2024 Annualized amounts are based on hourly rates. GRADE/DESC HOURS HOURLY RATE ANNUALIZED MIN I MARKET MAX MIN MARKET MAX MERIT EMPLOYEES J410 T1 2080 $14.74 $17.76 $22.02 $30,659.20 $36,940.80 $45,801.60 J411 T1 2080 $16.17 $19.48 $24.16 $33,633.60 $40,518.40 $50,252.80 J412 T1 2080 $16.71 $20.13 $24.96 $34,756.80 $41,870.40 $51,916.80 J413 T1 2080 $17.79 $21.43 $26.57 $37,003.20 $44,574.40 $55,265.60 J414 T1 2080 $18.84 $22.70 $28.15 $39,187.20 $47,216.00 $58,552.00 J415 T1 2080 $19.92 $24.00 $29.76 $41,433.60 $49,920.00 $61,900.80 J416 T1 2080 $20.99 $25.29 $31.36 $43,659.20 $52,603.20 $65,228.80 J417 T1 2080 $22.05 $26.57 $32.95 $45,864.00 $55,265.60 $68,536.00 J418 T1 2080 $23.12 $27.86 $34.55 $48,089.60 $57,948.80 $71,864.00 J419 T1 2080 $24.19 $29.15 $36.15 $50,315.20 $60,632.00 $75,192.00 J420 T1 2080 $25.27 $30.45 $37.76 $52,561.60 $63,336.00 $78,540.80 J421 T2 2080 $25.31 $30.49 $37.81 $52,644.80 $63,419.20 $78,644.80 J422 T2 2080 $26.27 $31.65 $39.25 $54,641.60 $65,832.00 $81,640.00 J423 T2 2080 $27.28 $32.87 $40.76 $56,742.40 $68,369.60 $84,780.80 J424 T2 2080 $28.83 $34.73 $43.07 $59,966.40 $72,238.40 $89,585.60 J425 T2 2080 $30.87 $37.19 $46.12 $64,209.60 $77,355.20 $95,929.60 J426 T2 2080 $32.91 $39.65 $49.17 $68,452.80 $82,472.00 $102,273.60 J427 T2 2080 $34.95 $42.11 $52.22 $72,696.00 $87,588.80 $108,617.60 J428 T2 2080 $37.00 $44.58 $55.28 $76,960.00 $92,726.40 $114,982.40 J429 T2 2080 $39.03 $47.03 $58.32 $81,182.40 $97,822.40 $121,305.60 J430 T2 2080 $41.09 $49.50 $61.38 $85,467.20 $102,960.00 $127,670.40 J431 T3 2080 $40.89 $49.26 $61.08 $85,051.20 $102,460.80 $127,046.40 J432 T3 2080 $43.07 $51.89 $64.34 $89,585.60 $107,931.20 $133,827.20 J433 T3 2080 $45.26 $54.53 $67.62 $94,140.80 $113,422.40 $140,649.60 J434 T3 2080 $47.46 $57.18 $70.90 $98,716.80 $118,934.40 $147,472.00 J435 T3 2080 $49.64 $59.81 $74.16 $103,251.20 $124,404.80 $154,252.80 J436 T3 2080 $51.83 $62.45 $77.44 $107,806.40 $129,896.00 $161,075.20 J437 T3 2080 $54.02 $65.09 $80.71 $112,361.60 $135,387.20 $167,876.80 J438 T3 2080 $56.22 $67.73 $83.99 $116,937.60 $140,878.40 $174,699.20 J439 T3 2080 $58.41 $70.37 $87.26 $121,492.80 $146,369.60 $181,500.80 J440 T3 2080 $60.61 $73.02 $90.54 $126,068.80 $151,881.60 $188,323.20 J441 T3 2080 $62.80 $75.66 $93.82 $130,624.00 $157,372.80 $195,145.60 J442 T3 2080 $64.99 $78.30 $97.09 $135,179.20 $162,864.00 $201,947.20 J443 T3 2080 $677 76 $81.64 $101.23 $140,940.80 $169,811.20 $210,558.40 APPENDIX 5 ACCOUNTING CLERK- PAYABLES Index Tab 1-ACCOUNTING CLERK-PAYABLES Job Description and Qualifications: Perform all aspects of accounts payable. Process purchase order and P-card payments, print checks, balance accounts, maintain A/P files and vendor accounts and manage 1099's. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Accounting (320) Certificates & Licenses Notary City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $22.15 $17.20 $21.50 $25.80 $22.15 $17.20 $21.50 $25.80 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $23.90 $17.36 $21.70 $27.10 $24.38 $17.71 $22.13 $27.64 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $22.18 $18.75 $23.93 $27.73 $21.07 $17.81 $22.73 $26.34 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $20.44 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 $20.44 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $25.64 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 $25.64 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $21.86 $17.88 $22.35 $26.82 $21.86 $17.88 $22.35 $26.82 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $22.22 $18.88 $23.60 $28.32 1 $22.22 $18.88 $23.60 $28.32 0.50% Averages Match $22.63 1 $17.97 1 $22.53 1 $27.21 1 $22.54 1 $17.88 1 $22.42 1 $27.09 1 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $22.08 $18.73 $22.57 $27.99 t___2"49% $ Difference $-0.46 $0.85 $0.15 $0.90 Difference 1 -2.08% 1 4.54% 1 0.66% 1 3.22% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 1 of 98 APPENDIX 5 ACCOUNTING DIRECTOR Index Tab 12-ACCOUNTING DIRECTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for providing management, coordination and supervision of accounting, payroll, pension, investing and debt activities of the City. Responsible for producing the comprehensive annual financial report and overseeing the external audit. Education FLSA B.S./B.A Degree in Accounting or Business Administration Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Accounting (320) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $42.82 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 $42.82 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $46.42 $38.68 $48.35 $60.37 $47.35 $39.45 $49.32 $61.58 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $59.13 $50.21 $61.04 $74.23 $56.17 $47.70 $57.99 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $52.12 $41.51 $51.88 $64.85 $52.12 $41.51 $51.88 $64.85 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $53.78 $42.57 $53.21 $63.85 $53.78 $42.57 $53.21 $63.85 0.50% Corn ata Match $52.16 $41.26 $51.58 $61.90 $52.16 $41.26 $51.58 $61.90 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $60.39 $47.54 $59.42 $71.30 $60.39 $47.54 $59.42 $71.30 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $54.57 $44.02 $55.03 $66.04 $54.57 $44.02 $55.03 $66.04 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 -1.04% 1 1 -4.23% 1 -2.61% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 2 of 98 APPENDIX 5 ACCOUNTING MANAGER -PAYROLL AND PENSION Index Tab 13- ACCOUNTING MANAGER - PAYROLL AND PENSION Job Description and Qualifications: Oversee payroll, accounts receivable and travel and training. Responsible for electronic timekeeping system maintenance and update requirements. Education FLSA B.S./B.A Degree in Accounting or Finance Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 4 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 2 years Accounting (320) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $38.20 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 $38.20 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $31.80 $26.50 $33.13 $41.36 $32.44 $27.03 $33.79 $42.19 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $48.80 $39.32 $47.80 $58.14 $46.36 $37.35 $45.41 $55.23 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $41.70 $34.79 $43.23 $54.04 $41.70 $34.79 $43.23 $54.04 0.55% City of Springdale, AR Less $28.95 $20.59 $25.73 $30.88 $28.95 $20.59 $25.73 $30.88 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $45.71 $36.18 $45.23 $54.28 $45.71 $36.18 $45.23 $54.28 0.50% Compdata Match $44.34 $35.07 $43.84 $52.61 $44.34 $35.07 $43.84 $52.61 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $48.31 $38.98 $48.72 $58.46 $48.31 $38.98 $48.72 $58.46 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $44.75 $36.90 $46.12 $55.34 $44.75 $36.90 $46.12 $55.34 0.50% Averages Match $41.40 $33.16 $41.61 $50.71 $41.20 $33.00 $41.42 $50.48 0.53% Citv of Favetteville. AR Match 542.07 534.79 541.92 551.98 0.49% 1%Difference 1 2.07% 1 5.15% 1 1.19% 1 2.89% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 3 of 98 APPENDIX 5 AIRPORT MAINTENANCE WORKER III Index Tab 14- AIRPORT MAINTENANCE WORKER III Job Description and Qualifications: Provide customer service to airport tenants. Successfully communicate with vendors regarding airport maintenance. Accurately complete work orders for various maintenance needs. Perform maintenance of lights on and off field. Perform electrical, plumbing, janitorial, metal fabrication, HVAC, landscaping and building duties as assigned. Operate heavy equipment and serve as technician for both automotive and heavy equipment. Perform daily runway check on lights. Education -H.S. Diploma or GED FLSA Non -Exempt IMF- Related Experience Supervisory Position 1 year Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Airport (95) Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid driver's license City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $20.77 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 1 $20.77 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 1 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $25.83 $21.25 $25.83 $31.42 $24.54 $20.19 $24.54 $29.85 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $21.22 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 $21.22 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $18.39 $15.09 $18.87 $22.64 $18.39 $15.09 $18.87 $22.64 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $21.35 $16.58 $20.73 $24.88 $21.35 $16.58 $20.73 $24.88 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $21.04 $16.68 $20.85 $25.02 $21.04 $16.68 $20.85 $25.02 0.509/o i Averages i Match $21.43 $17.06 $21.21 $25.72 $21.22 $16.88 $21.00 $25.45 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $23.47 111.71 $18.93 523.47 0.49% $ Difference $2.25 $-1.17 $-2.07 $-1.98 %Difference 9.59% -7.45%-10.94% -8.44% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 4 of 98 APPENDIX 5 ANIMAL SERVICES OFFICER Index Tab Education 15- ANIMAL SERVICES OFFICER Job Description and Qualifications: Enforce state and local laws pertaining to animals. Issue citations to violators and effectively manage difficult situations. Investigate animal cruelty and bite cases. Prepare investigative reports. FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 6-12 months of animal handling experience Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Animal Services (330) Certificates & Licenses Animal Cruelty Investigations Euthanasia, Chemical Capture and Bite Stick City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $17.45 $16.08 $20.10 $24.12 $17.45 $16.08 $20.10 $24.12 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $17.99 $16.58 $20.73 $25.88 $18.35 $16.91 $21.14 $26.40 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $24.55 $18.75 $23.93 $27.73 $23.32 $17.81 $22.73 $26.34 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $17.94 $16.71 $20.89 $26.11 $17.94 $16.71 $20.89 $26.11 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $15.57 $16.01 $20.01 $24.01 $15.57 $16.01 $20.01 $24.01 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $21.67 $17.15 $21.44 $25.73 $21.67 $17.15 $21.44 $25.73 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $21.95 $17.56 $21.95 $26.34 1 $21.95 $17.56 $21.95 $26.34 1 0.50% i Averages i Match $19.59 $16.98 $21.29 $25.70 $19.46 $16.89 $21.18 1 $25.58 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 519.53 516.72 $20.15 122 0.49% $ Difference $0.07 $-0.17 $-1.03 $-0.59 %Difference 0.36% -1.02% -5.11% -2.36% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 5 of 98 APPENDIX 5 ASSISTANT FIRE CHIEF Index Tab 16- ASSISTANT FIRE CHIEF Job Description and Qualifications: Oversee administrative or operational services and emergency activities of the Fire Department. Assist the Fire Chief in the development of standards and technical progression for officers and firefighters. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 10 years Supervisory Management Experience Department Battalion Chief 2 years Fire (700) Certificates & Licenses National Incident Management System, Firefighter and EMT City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $54.61 $40.85 $50.74 $60.63 $54.61 $40.85 $50.74 $60.63 0.48% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $45.66 $41.83 $44.38 $48.83 $46.57 $42.67 $45.27 $49.81 0.17% City of Lawrence, KS Match $64.09 $50.21 $62.57 $74.23 $60.89 $47.70 $59.44 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $55.82 $43.71 $54.77 $68.46 $55.82 $43.71 $54.77 $68.46 0.57% City of Springdale, AR Match 1 $53.63 $39.41 $48.16 $59.11 $53.63 1 $39.41 $48.16 $59.11 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $58.22 $43.59 $54.49 $65.39 $58.22 $43.59 $54.49 $65.39 0.50% Compdata Match $57.65 $42.29 $52.86 $63.43 $57.65 $42.29 $52.86 Lill 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $64.02 $46.56 $58.20 $69.84 $64.02 $46.56 $58.20 $69.84 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 11.26% 1 -1.86% 1 -3.33% 1 0.30% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.46% 0.49% Page 6 of 98 APPENDIX 5 ASSISTANT WATER SEWER OPERATIONS MANAGER Index Tab 17 - ASSISTANT WATER & SEWER OPERATIONS MANAGER Job Description and Qualifications: Assists in planning rehabilitation and preventive maintenance work. Estimates job costs for manpower and materials. Prepares bid specifications for outside vendors for projects or for materials and equipment. Assists in the planning, scheduling, developing and supervising an effective installation and maintenance program for the City's water and sewer system. Education FLSA High School Plus Specialized Schooling Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 Years Supervisory Management Experience Department 12-18 Months W&S Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid driver's license; ability to obtain a Class A CDL preferred. Must obtain a Grade IV Water distribution license and a Class III Wastewater Treatment Operator license within 2 years of hire. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $41.71 $28.99 $37.47 $45.95 1 $41.71 $28.99 $37.47 $45.95 1 0.59% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $47.31 $36.16 $43.95 $53.45 $44.94 $34.35 $41.75 $50.78 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $45.51 $37.01 $46.27 $55.52 $45.51 $37.01 $46.27 $55.52 0.50% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $40.79 $32.30 $40.38 $48.46 $40.79 $32.30 $40.38 $48.46 0.50% Compdata Match $39.36 $31.86 $39.82 $47.78 $39.36 $31.86 $39.82 $47.78 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $43.89 $32.42 $40.53 $48.64 $43.89 $32.42 $40.53 $48.64 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $40.97 $32.72 $40.90 $49.08 $40.97 $32.72 $40.90 $49.08 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1-12.51% 1 -6.01% 1-10.00% 1 -6.96% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.51% 0.49% Page 7 of 98 APPENDIX 5 AUTOMOTIVE PARTS SPECIALIST Index Tab 18- AUTOMOTIVE PARTS SPECIALIST Job Description and Qualifications: Maintain the inventory of automotive parts, supplies and materials for the fleet equipment storeroom. Identify competitive vendors, compare prices for cost-effectiveness, evaluate the quality and suitability of materials and supplies and recommend an appropriate vendor. Education FLSA High School Plus Specialized Schooling Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 4 Years ]Fleet Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver's License City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $22.25 $19.75 $24.31 $29.17 $22.25 $19.75 $24.31 $29.17 0.48% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $23.93 $20.01 $25.54 $29.58 $22.73 $19.01 $24.26 $28.10 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $20.99 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 $20.99 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $22.04 $19.31 $24.14 $28.97 $22.04 $19.31 $24.14 $28.97 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $24.68 $19.25 $24.06 $28.87 $24.68 $19.25 $24.06 $28.87 0.50% Averages Match $22.78 $19.47 $24.36 $29.26# $22.54 $19.27 $24.11 $28.96 0.50% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $20.92 $19.74 $23.78 529.49 0.49% $ Difference 61 $0.47 $-0.33 $0.53 %Difference -7.14% 2.38% -1.39% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 8 of 98 APPENDIX 5 BACKFLOW PREVENTION TECHNICIAN Index Tab 19-13ACKFLOW PREVENTION TECHNICIAN Job Description and Qualifications: Review plans, permit applications, drawings, and specifications for backflow code and ordinance violations on commercial, industrial, nonprofit, residential, and fire protection to ensure proper backflow protection. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Related Experience 2 years Non -Exempt Supervisory Position Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department W/S Services (160) Certificates & Licenses Arkansas Dept. of Health Backflow Testing and Repair Licenses and Certified Program Specialist in Cross Connection Control within one year. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $23.12 $19.07 $23.28 $27.48 $23.12 $19.07 $23.28 $27.48 0.44% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.60 $21.25 $25.83 $31.42 $26.22 $20.19 $24.54 $29.85 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $23.66 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 $23.66 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $24.09 $18.36 $22.95 $27.54 $24.09 $18.36 $22.95 $27.54 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $23.77 $19.19 $23.99 $28.79 $23.77 $19.19 $23.99 $28.79 0.50% i Averages i Match $24.45 $19.38 $23.96 $28.99 �$24.17 $19.17 $23.71 $28.67 0.50% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 523.92 $18.73 $22.57 527.99 0.49% $ Difference $-0.44 $-1.14 $-0.68 Difference -1.05% -2.35% -5.05% -2.43% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 9 of 98 APPENDIX 5 BENEFITS LEAVE ADMINISTRATOR Index Tab 30 - BENEFITS & LEAVE ADMINISTRATOR Job Description and Qualifications: Day-to-day administration of health, dental, life and vision insurance. Responsible for administering short and long-term disability programs, medical and dependent care, flexible spending accounts, HSA, AD&D and supplemental insurance plans. Provides new hire orientation. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma B.S./B.A. in HR or related field preferred Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years and 2 years of Benefits Adm. Experience Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Human Resources (390) Certificates & Licenses PHR or SHRM - CP desirable City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $22.63 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 $22.63 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $29.41 $24.96 $30.35 $36.91 $27.94 $23.71 $28.83 $35.06 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $27.58 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 $27.58 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $26.43 $19.67 $25.73 $30.88 $26.43 $19.67 $25.73 $30.88 0.57% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $29.45 $22.65 $28.31 $33.97 $29.45 $22.65 $28.31 $33.97 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $27.69 $22.22 $27.77 $33.32 $27.69 $22.22 $27.77 $33.32 0.509/o Averages Match $27.20 $22.28 $27.90 $33.81 i $26.95 1 $22.08 1 $27.65 1 $33.50 0.52% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 122 78 122 75 526.20 532.49 0.49% $ Difference I $-0.33 $-1.45 $-1.01 %Difference 2.99% -1.52% -5.53% 111% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 10 of 98 APPENDIX 5 BUDGET DIRECTOR Index Tab 11-BUDGET DIRECTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Provide day to day management and coordination of the Budget and Research Division. Assure development of and timely completion of the annual budget, coordinating the effort with both internal and external personnel. Oversee the preparation of an Annual Budget and Work Plan for the City. Education r FLSA Bachelor's Degree in Accounting or related field. Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 6 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 5 years Budget(325) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $42.82 1 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 $42.82 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 1 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $65.04 $50.21 $62.57 $74.23 $61.79 $47.70 $59.44 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $59.62 $41.51 $51.88 $64.85 $59.62 $41.51 $51.88 $64.85 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $61.96 $49.02 $61.28 $73.54 $61.96 $49.02 $61.28 $73.54 0.50% Compdata Match $60.29 $47.70 $59.62 $71.54 $60.29 $47.70 $59.62 $71.54 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $64.12 $47.54 $59.42 $71.30 $64.12 $47.54 $59.42 $71.30 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $58.22 $47.12 $58.90 $70.68 $58.22 $47.12 $58.90 $70.68 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 8.16% 1 -6.39% 1-11.35% 1 -8.82% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 11 of 98 APPENDIX 5 BUSINESS LICENSE CLERK Index Tab 112 - BUSINESS LICENSE CLERK Job Description and Qualifications: Greet and interact with citizens and city employees, assist with needs and questions either in person or over the phone. Resolve a wide variety of situations that arise, either by researching and/or answering questions personally or forwarding to appropriate person. Review and accept business license applications; review applications for completeness and accuracy; calculate and collect applicable fees; prepare and issue receipts; forward applications to appropriate staff for review. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Dev Svcs Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $19.10 $16.08 $20.10 $25.80 $19.10 $16.08 $20.10 $25.80 0.60% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $21.12 $18.75 $23.93 $27.73 $20.06 $17.81 $22.73 $26.34 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $20.20 $16.71 $20.89 $26.11 $20.20 $16.71 $20.89 $26.11 0.56% City of Springdale, AR More $20.01 $16.01 $20.01 $24.01 $20.01 $16.01 $20.01 $24.01 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $19.87 $16.69 $20.86 $25.03 $19.87 $16.69 $20.86 $25.03 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $20.01 $16.46 $20.57 $24.68 $20.01 $16.46 $20.57 $24.68 0.509/o Averages Match $20.05 $16.78 $21.06 $25.56 $19.88 $16.63 $20.86 $25.33 0.52% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 519.23 $16.72 122 122 0.49% $ Difference $-0.65 $0.09 $-0.71 $-0.34 Difference -3.38% 0.54% -3.52% -1.36% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 12 of 98 APPENDIX 5 BUSINESS SYSTEMS ANALYST Index Tab 113- BUSINESS SYSTEMS ANALYST Job Description and Qualifications: Configure, customize, implement and provide application support for city departments. Serve as a liaison between I.T. staff and users. Consults efficiencies. with users concerning their information needs and system requirements to maximize data entry and reporting Education FLSA B.S. / B.A. Degree I.T. Degree Preferred Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Information Technologies (370) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $37.94 $26.98 $36.46 $45.94 1 $37.94 $26.98 $36.46 $45.94 1 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $42.68 $35.11 $42.68 $51.91 $40.55 $33.35 $40.55 $49.31 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $37.39 $27.67 $34.58 $43.23 $37.39 $27.67 $34.58 $43.23 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $42.56 $28.37 $35.46 $42.56 $42.56 $28.37 $35.46 $42.56 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $37.79 $29.59 $36.99 $44.39 $37.79 $29.59 $36.99 $44.39 0.50% Compdata Match $36.63 $28.70 $35.87 $43.04 $36.63 $28.70 $35.87 $43.04 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $43.53 $32.41 $40.51 $48.61 $43.53 $32.41 $40.51 $48.61 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $37.79 $28.83 $36.04 $43.25 $37.79 $28.83 $36.04 $43.25 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 -6.16% 1 -1.58% 1 -5.98% 1 -3.87% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 13 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CAD DRAFTER Index Tab 114 - CAD DRAFTER Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for the drafting and preparation of construction plans for water/sewer, street and drainage improvements, exhibits, misc. maps and other documents as required. Prepare construction and miscellaneous drawings as required. Education FLSA 2 Years College Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Engr Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $26.14 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 $26.14 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $32.72 $22.69 $27.57 $33.54 $31.08 $21.56 $26.19 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $27.24 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 $27.24 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $27.78 $21.09 $26.36 $31.63 $27.78 $21.09 $26.36 $31.63 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $23.94 $19.30 $24.13 $28.96 $23.94 $19.30 $24.13 $28.96 0.50% i Averages i Match $27.56 $20.76 $25.80 $31.30 $27.24 $20.54 $25.52 $30.96 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $28.85 $20.74 524.99 530.99 0.49% $ Difference $1.61 $0.20 $-0.53 $0.03 %Difference 5.58%-2.12% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 14 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER Index Tab 15- CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER Job Description and Qualifications: Ensure compliance with accounting and finance administrative principles, practice and policies, laws, regulations and reporting requirements pertainingto municipal finance. Create and develop long-range financial planning, provide financial forecasts and develop annual budgets. Education FLSA Bachelor's Degree in Accounting or related field. Master's or MBA preferred Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 9 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 8 years Mayor/Executive (500) Certificates & Licenses Preferred: CPA, CPFO, CGFM, CFA, CIA or CPM City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $60.10 $45.82 $61.93 $78.03 $60.10 $45.82 $61.93 $78.03 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $69.57 $69.75 $86.69 $102.86 $66.09 $66.26 $82.36 $97.72 0.47% City of Rogers, AR Match $74.52 $57.65 $72.07 $90.08 $74.52 $57.65 $72.07 $90.08 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $49.20 $39.36 $49.20 $59.04 $49.20 $39.36 $49.20 $59.04 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $81.20 $63.01 $78.76 $94.51 $81.20 $63.01 $78.76 $94.51 0.50% Compdata Match $80.01 $62.09 $77.61 $93.13 $80.01 $62.09 $77.61 $93.13 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $74.63 $57.97 $72.46 $86.95 $74.63 $57.97 $72.46 $86.95 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $72.25 $56.38 $70.47 $84.56 $72.25 $56.38 $70.47 $84.56 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 8.10% 1-10.37% 1-15.36% 1-12.65% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.52% 0.49% Page 15 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CHIEF OF STAFF Index Tab 116 - CHIEF OF STAFF Job Description and Qualifications: Functions as the Chief Operating Officer for the City. Performs a variety of executive level duties to coordinate the administrative and operational activities of the Mayor. Responsible for providing executive oversight ensuring the policy directives from the Mayor and City Council are implemented. Education FLSA B.S. / B.S. in Public or Business Administration Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years CEO or COO Supervisory Management Experience Department 5 years Mayor/Executive (501) Certificates & Licenses Mayor/Council form of government experience City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $68.31 $42.73 $57.71 $72.68 $68.31 $42.73 $57.71 $72.68 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $51.35 $45.64 $57.06 $71.23 $52.38 $46.55 $58.20 $72.65 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $91.03 $76.53 $93.03 $113.14 $86.48 $72.70 $88.38 $107.48 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $74.52 $57.65 $72.07 $90.08 $74.52 $57.65 $72.07 $90.08 0.56% City of Springdale, AR More $72.78 $48.52 $60.65 $72.78 $72.78 $48.52 $60.65 $72.78 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $83.52 $66.16 $82.70 $99.24 $83.52 $66.16 $82.70 $99.24 0.50% Compdata Match $82.12 $65.19 $81.49 $97.79 $82.12 $65.19 $81.49 $97.79 DOL- BLS -NWA Match $75.04 $57.83 $72.29 $86.75 $75.04 $57.83 $72.29 $86.75 NOARK 2023 Match $74.61 $60.00 $75.00 $90.00 $74.61 $60.00 $75.00 $90.00 Averages Match $74.81 $57.81 $72.44 $88.19 $74.42 $57.48 $72.05 $87.72 0.53% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 572.41 554.92 566.17 582.05 0.49% 1%Difference 1 -2.78% 1 -4.66% 1 -8.89% 1 -6.91% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 16 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CITY ATTORNEY Index Tab 117 - CITY ATTORNEY nn�Job Description and Qualifications:111111111 Advise the City Council, Mayor and Senior City Staff about the legality and constitutionality of proposed actions, ordinances and resolutions. Defend the City in litigation and prepare ordinances and resolutions. Education FLSA Juris Doctorate Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position ]City Supervisory Management Experience Department Attorney (530) Certificates & Licenses Arkansas Law License Admission to AR Bar and practice in Federal Courts City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $83.27 $48.96 $66.17 $83.37 $83.27 $48.96 $66.17 $83.37 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $55.21 $44.17 $55.21 $66.25 $56.31 $45.05 $56.31 $67.58 0.50% City of Lawrence, KS Match $97.38 $76.53 $93.03 $113.14 $92.51 $72.70 $88.38 $107.48 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $73.46 $53.04 $66.30 $82.87 $73.46 $53.04 $66.30 $82.87 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $68.88 $46.69 $58.36 $70.03 $68.88 $46.69 $58.36 $70.03 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $82.16 $66.24 $82.80 $99.36 $82.16 $66.24 $82.80 $99.36 0.50% Compdata Match $80.77 $65.27 $81.59 $97.91 $80.77 $65.27 $81.59 $97.91 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $77.79 $59.12 $73.90 $88.68 $77.79 $59.12 $73.90 $88.68 0.50% NOARK 2023 Averages Match $77.36 $57.50 $72.17 $87.70 $76.89 $57.13 $71.73 $87.16 0.53% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 571.54 554.92 566.17 582.05 0.49% 1%Difference 1 -7.48% 1 -4.02% 1 -8.40% 1 -6.23% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 17 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CITY CLERK -TREASURER Index Tab 18-CITY CLERK -TREASURER Job Description and Qualifications: Act as the official records custodian for the City by ensuring the safekeeping and management of the City's records, contracts, releases, resolutions and ordinances and as the official custodian of the City seal ensuring certification of all ordinances, resolutions, contracts, and other documents. Develop and manage division budget. Responsible for the coordination of elections with various governmental agencies. Perform administrative functions for the City® legislative workflow application. Serve on Police and Fire Pension Boards as a voting member. Education FLSA A.A, Degree preferred Related Experience 4 years of office administration Exempt Supervisory Position Supervisory Management Experience Department City Clerk (550) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR City of Jonesboro, AR Match $42.24 $33.79 $42.24 $50.69 $43.08 $34.47 $43.08 $51.70 0.50% City of Lawrence, KS Match $47.80 $39.32 $50.19 $58.14 $45.41 $37.35 $47.68 $55.23 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $51.45 $39.20 $49.00 $61.25 $51.45 $39.20 $49.00 $61.25 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $52.67 $46.69 $58.36 $70.03 $52.67 $46.69 $58.36 $70.03 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $62.80 $49.26 $61.57 $73.88 $62.80 $49.26 $61.57 $73.88 0.50% Compdata Match $61.10 $47.92 $59.90 $71.88 $61.10 $47.92 $59.90 $71.88 0.50% DOL- BLS - NIA Match $57.27 $41.25 1 56 $61.87 $57.27 $41.25 $51.56 $61.87 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $51.78 1 $41.96 1 $52.45 $62.94 $51.78 $41.96 $52.45 $62.94 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 -3.16% 1 -4.35% 1 -8.50% 1 -5.11% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.50% 0.49% Page 18 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CITY PROSECUTOR Index Tab 119 -CITY PROSECUTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Review trial docket and assign cases. Negotiate plea offers with defense bar. Oversee docket in regard to flow and trial settings. Prepare and manage cases to be tried. Try cases set in District Court and County Circuit Court. Education FLSA Juris Doctorate Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 5 years Prosecuting Attorney (560) Certificates & Licenses Arkansas Law License Admission to AR Bar and practice in City/County Courts City Job Average Hourly I Salary Range Geo Adjusted Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Match Salary Minimum Midpoint Maximum Hourly Salary Minimum Midpoint Maximum Width City of Bentonville, AR Match $62.99 $39.54 $53.44 $67.33 $62.99 $39.54 $53.44 $67.33 0.70% Citv of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $47.82 $35.11 $44.81 $51.91 $45.43 $33.35 $42.57 $49.31 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $56.81 $39.20 $49.00 $61.25 $56.81 $39.20 $49.00 $61.25 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $40.42 $26.54 $44.57 $56.29 $40.42 $26.54 $44.57 $56.29 1.12% CompAnalyst Match $63.57 $49.99 $62.49 $74.99 $63.57 $49.99 $62.49 $74.99 0.50% Compdata Match $61.45 $48.29 $60.36 $72.43 $61.45 $48.29 $60.36 $72.43 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $58.34 $43.38 $54.22 $65.06 $58.34 $43.38 $54.22 $65.06 0.50% I NOARK 2023 1 Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 8.16% 1 1.14% 1 -7.34% 1 -5.45% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.59% 0.49% Page 19 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER Index Tab 120 - CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER Job Description and Qualifications: codes including property conditions, storage of vehicles, unsafe buildings, zoning compliance, grading violations, storm water violations and recycling and trash collection violations. Effectively communicate information about municipal codes and regulations while maintaining working relationships with property owners, business owners and representatives from other agencies and the general public. Seek remedies to property violations including but not limited to correction letters and violation Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 1 Year Exp only preferred Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Building Safety (134) Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver's License City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $27.47 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 $27.47 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $16.90 $16.58 $20.73 $25.88 $17.24 $16.91 $21.14 $26.40 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $31.64 $20.63 $26.32 $30.49 $30.06 $19.60 $25.00 $28.97 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $21.89 $16.71 $20.89 $26.11 $21.89 $16.71 $20.89 $26.11 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $16.61 $16.01 $20.01 $24.01 $16.61 $16.01 $20.01 $24.01 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $22.93 $18.53 $23.16 $27.79 $22.93 $18.53 $23.16 $27.79 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $22.34 $17.70 $22.13 $26.56 $22.34 $17.70 $22.13 $26.56 0.50% Averages Match $22.83 $18.10 $22.71 $27.39 $22.65 $18.00 $22.58 $27.24 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $20.99 $18.73 522.57 527.99 0.49% $ Difference $-1.66 $0.73 $-0.01 $0.75 %Difference -7.91% 3.90% -0.04% 2.68% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 20 of 98 APPENDIX 5 COMMUNICATIONS MARKETING DIRECTOR Index Tab 121- COMMUNICATIONS &MARKETING DIRECTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Guide and develop the communications, marketing and volunteer services department. Oversee the Media Services division, content management for the City's internet and intranet websites and community outreach and information efforts. Provide administration with advice on policies, procedures, programs and public correspondence. Education FLSA Bachelor's Degree in related field. Master's preferred Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Mayor/Executive (500) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $46.15 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 $46.15 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $38.48 $33.46 $41.83 $52.22 $39.25 $34.13 $42.67 $53.26 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $58.13 $50.21 $61.04 $74.23 $55.22 $47.70 $57.99 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $53.36 $41.51 $51.88 $64.85 $53.36 $41.51 $51.88 $64.85 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $22.38 1 $19.67 $25.73 $35.00 $22.38 1 $19.67 $25.73 $35.00 0.78% CompAnalyst Match $58.57 $45.92 $57.40 $68.88 $58.57 $45.92 $57.40 $68.88 0.50% Compdata Match $56.77 $44.50 $55.63 $66.76 $56.77 $44.50 $55.63 $66.76 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $61.93 $48.10 $60.13 $72.16 $61.93 $48.10 $60.13 $72.16 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $56.62 $47.05 $58.81 $70.57 $56.62 $47.05 $58.81 $70.57 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 5.39% 1 4.72% 1 0.45% 1 1.46% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.54% 0.49% Page 21 of 98 APPENDIX 5 COMMUNICATIONS PROJECT MANAGER- WEB Index Tab 122- COMMUNICATIONS PROJECT MANAGER - WEB Job Description and Qualifications: Work closely with the Director of Communications and the Communications Department staff to implement the city®communication goals and objectives, provide good customer service, strengthen community relations, and improve organizational communication. Education FLSA Bachelor's Degree in related field. Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience IF Department 2 years Communications (500) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $29.58 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 $29.58 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $31.02 $27.45 $33.36 $40.58 $29.47 $26.08 $31.69 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $28.29 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 $28.29 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $32.15 $25.74 $32.18 $38.62 $32.15 $25.74 $32.18 $38.62 0.50% Compdata Match $31.15 $24.96 $31.20 $37.44 $31.15 $24.96 $31.20 $37.44 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $32.80 $24.93 $31.16 $37.39 $32.80 $24.93 $31.16 $37.39 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $30.46 $23.68 $29.60 $35.52 $30.46 $23.68 $29.60 $35.52 0.50% Averages Match $30.78 $24.74 $30.80 $37.24 $30.56 $24.55 $30.56 $36.95 0.51% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 525.80 523.80 525.67 535.55 0.49% 1%Difference 1 -6.11% 1 -3.15% 1 -6.59% 1 -3.94% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 22 of 98 APPENDIX 5 COMMUNITY RESOURCES DIRECTOR -EQUITY OFFICER Index Tab 123 - COMMUNITY RESOURCES DIRECTOR -EQUITY OFFICER Job Description and Qualifications: Provide day to day management and coordination of the Community Development programs (CDBG, SNAPS and/or other grants), Animal Services programs and the Equity Program. Develop and implement policies and procedures for the efficient operation of the Community Development and Animal Services programs, and the Equity Program. Education FLSA 4 Years College Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 4 Years Supervisory Management Experience Department 2 Years Comm Resources Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver's License. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $44.23 $33.26 $44.95 $56.63 1 $44.23 $33.26 $44.95 1 $56.63 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $61.04 $50.21 $62.57 $74.23 $57.99 $47.70 $59.44 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $43.50 $34.59 $43.23 $54.04 $43.50 $34.59 $43.23 $54.04 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $23.48 $20.59 $25.73 $30.88 $23.48 $20.59 $25.73 $30.88 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $54.70 $43.27 $54.09 $64.91 $54.70 $43.27 $54.09 $64.91 0.50% Compdata Match $53.03 $41.96 $52.45 $62.94 $53.03 $41.96 $52.45 $62.94 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $54.36 $40.66 $50.82 $60.98 $54.36 $40.66 $50.82 $60.98 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $47.44 $37.72 $47.15 $56.58 $47.44 $37.72 $47.15 $56.58 0.50% Averages Match $47.72 $37.78 $47.62 $57.65 $47.34 $37.47 $47.23 $57.18 0.53% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 551.98 534.79 541.92 551.98 0.49% 1%Difference 1 8.93% 1 -7.70% 1-12.67% 1-10.00% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 23 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CONSTRUCTION LEAD MAINTENANCE WORKER Index Tab 124 - CONSTRUCTION LEAD MAINTENANCE WORKER Job Description and Qualifications: Perform supervisory responsibilities which may include training employees; planning, assigning, and directing work; appraising performance, addressing complaints and resolving problems. Responsible for crew maintaining all equipment and material used on a daily basis. Basic understanding of shop drawing and plans as related to streets, sidewalks, trails and drainage. Utilize transit to shoot and set grade. Prepare daily reports to record materials, labor hours and equipment for system entry. Provide initial citizen contact on work sites. Responsible for usage of P-card for purchases of materials needed for completion of job task. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 Years Supervisory Management Experience Department Transportation (342) Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid driver®license. Must possess or have the ability to obtain a valid Class A Commercial Driver® License. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $24.12 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 $24.12 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $25.83 $21.25 $25.83 $31.42 $24.54 $20.19 $24.54 $29.85 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $22.13 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 $22.13 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $24.24 $18.35 $22.94 $27.53 $24.24 $18.35 $22.94 $27.53 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $22.13 $17.87 $22.34 $26.81 $22.13 $17.87 $22.34 $26.81 0.50% Averages Match $23.69 $18.96 $23.55 $28.57 $23.43 $18.74 $23.29 $28.25 Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $22.50 $17.72 $21.35 526.47 0.49% $ Difference $-0.93 $-1.02 $-1.94 $-1.78 %Difference -4.13% -5.76% -9.09 o -6.12% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 24 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CREW LEADER -TRANSPORTATION Index Tab 125-CREW LEADER - TRANSPORTATION Job Description and Qualifications: MENEF- ON_ Supervise all materials, personnel and equipment required to complete assigned projects. Read and comprehend drawings of plans for streets, sidewalks, trails and drainage. Utilize transit to shoot and set grade. Exercise independent judgment to make on site decisions to overcome unforeseen problems. Operate equipment required to perform all jobs in the department. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 Years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Transportation Certificates & Licenses Ability to obtain valid Commercial Drivers License Class A within 120 days of hire date. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $25.72 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 $25.72 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $21.29 $17.36 $21.70 $27.10 $21.72 $17.71 $22.13 $27.64 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $25.49 $22.69 $27.57 $33.54 $24.22 $21.56 $26.19 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $24.09 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 $24.09 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $23.63 $20.59 $25.73 $30.88 $23.66 $20.59 $25.73 $30.88 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $25.45 $19.26 $24.08 $28.90 $25.45 $19.26 $24.08 $28.90 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $23.77 $19.19 $23.99 $28.79 $23.77 $19.19 $23.99 $28.79 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $24.21 $19.81 $24.65 $29.97 i $24.08 1 $19.70 1 $24.52 1 $29.81 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 123.23 518.73 $22.57 527.99 0.49% $ Difference $-0.85 $-0.97 $-1.95 $-1.82 %Difference -3.66 o -5.18% -8.64% -6.50% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 25 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CREW LEADER WATER LICENSE Index Tab 126- CREW LEADER WATER LICENSE Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for evaluating the condition of the sewer collection system, streets and other areas as needed. Make decisions on repairs needed, replacements, or types of rehab to be used. Generate a flow of work needed to maintain smooth operations. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 Years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required W&S Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid drivers license and be able to obtain a Class A Commercial Drivers License with tanker endorsement within six months of employment. Must have minimum Grade 2 Water Distribution License and Class 1 Wastewater License within 2 years City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly5alary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $26.86 $21.69 $27.12 $32.54 $26.86 $21.69 $27.12 $32.54 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $31.44 $24.96 $30.35 $36.91 $29.87 $23.71 $28.83 $35.06 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $24.86 $20.49 $25.61 $30.73 $24.86 $20.49 $25.61 $30.73 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $28.00 $20.22 $25.28 $30.34 $28.00 $20.22 $25.28 $30.34 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $26.25 $20.51 $25.64 $30.77 $26.25 $20.51 $25.64 $30.77 0.50% Averages Match $27.48 $21.57 $26.80 $32.26 $27.17 1 $21.32 $26.50 $31.89 0.50% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 527.49 520.74 524.99 530.99 0.49% $ Difference $0.32 $-0.58 $-1.51 $-0.90 %Difference 1.16% -2.80% -6.04% -2.90% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 26 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CRIME SCENE TECHINICIAN Index Tab 127- CRIME SCENE TECHINICIAN Job Description and Qualifications: Respond to major crime scenes (homicides, sexual assaults, armed robbery, property crimes, etc.), and any other crime scenes at the discretion of a supervisor. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Police (650) Certificates & Licenses Certification as Law Enforcement Crime Scene Technician City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum of Bentonville, AR Match $27.16 $21.69 $27.12 $32.54 $27.16 $21.69 $27.12 $32.54 0.50% I�City Citv of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.52 $24.96 $30.35 $36.91 $26.14 $23.71 $28.83 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $26.86 $19.59 $24.49 $29.39 $26.86 $19.59 $24.49 $29.39 0.50% City of Springdale, AR More $35.76 $28.65 $34.66 $42.16 $35.76 $28.65 $34.66 $42.16 0.47% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $28.25 $21.53 $26.91 $32.29 $28.25 $21.53 $26.91 $32.29 0.50% INOARK 2023 1 i Averages i Match $29.11 $23.28 $28.71 $34.66 $28.83 1 $23.03 1 $28.40 1 $34.29 0.49% Citv of Favetteville, AIR Match 526.80 $20.74 $24.99 530.99 0.49% $ Difference $-2.03 $-2.29 5-3.41 5-3.30 Difference -7.57%-11.04%-13.65%-10.65% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 27 of 98 APPENDIX 5 CUSTOMER SERVICE COORDINATOR I Index Tab 128 - CUSTOMER SERVICE COORDINATOR I Job Description and Qualifications: Exhibit excellent customer service while assisting customers to set up new service, transfer service to new addresses, or disconnect service. Effectively present information and respond to questions from customers and the general public. Research and respond to difficult customer problems and complaints. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related ExperienceOil Supervisory Position 2 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Utilities Financial Services (420) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $16.53 $16.08 $20.10 $24.12 $16.53 $16.08 $20.10 $24.12 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $21.25 $18.75 $23.93 $27.73 $20.19 $17.81 $22.73 $26.34 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $18.76 $17.38 $21.72 $26.06 $18.76 $17.38 $21.72 $26.06 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $19.54 $17.17 $21.46 $25.75 $19.54 $17.17 $21.46 $25.75 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $22.29 $18.01 $22.51 $27.01 $22.29 $18.01 $22.51 $27.01 0.50% Averages Match 1 $19.67 $17.48 $21.94 $26.13 $19.46 $17.29 $21.70 $25.86 0.49% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 517.89 $17.72 521.35 526.47 0.49% $ Difference $-1.51 $0.43 $-0.35 $0.61 Difference -8.78% 2.43% -1.64% 2.301. Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 28 of 98 APPENDIX 5 DEPUTY COURT CLERK Index Tab 129 - DEPUTY COURT CLERK Job Description and Qualifications: Performs clerical work that involves the responsibility for money, data entry, filing and scheduling trial dates. Maintain records, prepare orders and arraignment reports. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department District Court (380) Certificates & Licenses Bilingual abilities preferred Arkansas District Courts Clerk Association City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $21.92 $18.33 $22.91 $27.49 $21.92 $18.33 $22.91 $27.49 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $26.78 $20.63 $26.32 $30.49 $25.44 $19.60 $25.00 $28.97 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $18.65 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 $18.65 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $14.84 $16.01 $20.01 $24.01 $14.84 $16.01 $20.01 $24.01 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $23.85 $18.16 $22.70 $27.24 $23.85 $18.16 $22.70 $27.24 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $23.02 $18.71 $23.39 $28.07 $23.02 $18.71 $23.39 $28.07 0.509/o Averages Match of Favetteville, AR Match .53 73 $ Difference V.19 $0.61 %Difference 13.03% 3.31% 522.72 1 527.28 1 0.51% $22.57 $27.99 0.49% $-0.15 $0.71 -0.66% 2.54% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 29 of 98 APPENDIX 5 DIRECTOR OF ECONOMIC VITALITY Index Tab 130- DIRECTOR OF ECONOMIC VITALITY Job Description and Qualifications: Develop and oversee the City's vitality efforts including managing strategies, plans, programs and contractors to support new and existing businesses. Responsible for developing and overseeing business incentive programs. Education Bachelor's Degree in related field. Master's preferred ptRelated Experience visory Position10 years visoryManagement EDepartment Experience 7 years r/Executive (500) Certificates & Licenses Preferred: CEcD, PCED, EDFP City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $52.45 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 1 $52.45 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $55.36 $50.21 $61.04 $74.23 $52.59 $47.70 $57.99 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $56.67 $41.51 $51.88 $64.85 $56.67 $41.51 $51.88 $64.85 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $59.28 $46.66 $58.33 $70.00 $59.28 $46.66 $58.33 $70.00 0.50% Compdata Match $57.55 $45.31 $56.64 $67.97 $57.55 $45.31 $56.64 $67.97 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $62.45 $47.58 $59.48 $71.38 $62.45 $47.58 $59.48 $71.38 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $53.78 $43.52 $54.40 $65.28 $53.78 $43.52 $54.40 $65.28 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 -0.36% 1 -3.62% 1 -8.07% 1 -6.04% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 30 of 98 APPENDIX 5 DIRECTOR OF PARKS, NATURAL RESOURCES CULTURAL AFFAIRS Index Tab 131- DIRECTOR OF PARKS, NATURAL RESOURCES & CULTURAL AFFAIRS Job Description and Qualifications: Oversee the Parks, Recreation, Natural Resources and Cultural Affairs Department including, recreational programs, park maintenance, horticulture, park planning and urban forestry. Develop, study and recommend actions to improve and provide high quality parks, services and recreation programs. Education FLSA MENEE B.S. / B.A. in Parks and Recreation Management or related field Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 10 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 7 years Parks (120) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $67.98 $42.73 $57.71 $72.68 $67.98 $42.73 $57.71 $72.68 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Less $39.32 $33.46 $41.83 $52.22 $40.11 $34.13 $42.67 $53.26 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $74.57 $50.21 $62.57 $74.23 $70.84 $47.70 $59.44 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $60.53 $48.43 $60.53 $75.67 $60.53 $48.43 $60.53 $75.67 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Less $60.50 $41.19 $51.49 $61.79 $60.50 $41.19 $51.49 $61.79 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $64.02 $50.14 $62.68 $75.22 $64.02 $50.14 $62.68 $75.22 0.50% Compdata Match $62.16 $48.69 $60.86 $73.03 $62.16 $48.69 $60.86 $73.03 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $65.00 $52.79 $65.99 $79.19 $65.00 $52.79 $65.99 $79.19 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $58.89 $48.16 $60.20 $72.24 $58.89 $48.16 $60.20 $72.24 0.50% Match AR Match .86 1%Difference 1 -3.82% 1 5.64% 1 1.33% 1 3.34% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 31 of 98 APPENDIX 5 DISPATCH MANAGER Index Tab 132 - DISPATCH MANAGER Job Description and Qualifications: Oversee the 24-hour operation of an emergency response central dispatch center. Oversees policies and procedures, training programs and a three site simulcast radio system. Manage special projects, draft RFPs, negotiate contracts as assigned. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Police - Dispatch (670) Certificates & Licenses ACIC Level I and II NIMS Training Requirements City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $45.08 $27.42 $35.18 $42.94 $45.08 $27.42 $35.18 $42.94 0.57% City of Jonesboro, AR More $35.13 $33.46 $41.83 $52.22 $35.83 $34.13 $42.67 $53.26 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $47.80 $39.20 $47.80 $58.14 $45.41 $37.24 $45.41 $55.23 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $43.92 $32.28 $40.35 $50.44 $43.92 $32.28 $40.35 $50.44 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $34.83 $26.54 $33.17 $39.81 $34.83 $26.54 $33.17 $39.81 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $47.80 $34.14 $42.68 $51.22 $47.80 $34.14 $42.68 $51.22 0.50% Compdata Match $46.41 $33.15 $41.44 $49.73 $46.41 $33.15 $41.44 $49.73 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $45.42 $34.61 $43.26 $51.91 $45.42 $34.61 $43.26 $51.91 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $44.39 $33.42 $41.77 $50.12 $44.39 $33.42 $41.77 $50.12 0.509/c Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 11.96% 1 0.97% 1 -2.68% 1 -0.63% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.52% 0.49% Page 32 of 98 APPENDIX 5 DISPATCH SHIFT SUPERVISOR Index Tab 133- DISPATCH SHIFT SUPERVISOR Job Description and Qualifications: Monitor all dispatcher activity and ensure all calls and radio traffic are handled per policy in an efficient manner. Check call logs for spelling/grammatical errors and policy violations. Perform monthly quality assurance checks and review all call delay sheets to ensure the shift runs smoothly and efficiently. Update employees with new or changed policy/procedure information and answer any questions regarding current policies and procedures. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma / GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 years of Public Safety Dispatch Supervisory Management Experience Department 2 years Dispatch (670) Certificates & Licenses ACIC Level I and II NIMS Training Requirements City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $27.37 $22.03 $27.25 $32.46 $27.37 $22.03 $27.25 $32.46 0.47% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $23.47 $19.97 $24.97 $31.17 $23.94 $20.37 $25.47 $31.79 0.56% City of Lawrence, Ks Match $33.20 $27.45 $33.36 $40.58 $31.54 $26.08 $31.69 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $28.87 $25.36 $31.70 $39.62 $28.87 $25.36 $31.70 $39.62 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $27.71 1 $23.33 $29.17 $35.00 $27.71 1 $23.33 $29.17 $35.00 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $33.72 $24.06 $30.08 $36.10 $33.72 $24.06 $30.08 $36.10 0.50% Compdata Match $32.69 $23.34 $29.18 $35.02 $32.69 $23.34 $29.18 $35.02 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $31.45 $24.03 $30.04 $36.05 $31.45 $24.03 $30.04 $36.05 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $30.46 $23.68 $29.60 1 $35.52 $30.46 $23.68 $29.60 1 $35.52 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 0.13% 1 0.88% 1 -2.37% 1 -0.06% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.51% 0.49% Page 33 of 98 APPENDIX 5 DISPATCHER Index Tab 134 -DISPATCHER I Job Description and Qualifications: Operate complex communication equipment including a radio console, mobile and portable radio, satellite phone, recorder equipment, fire alarm panel, alerting systems, and other related equipment to dispatch Police, Fire and 911 calls. Monitor public safety radio and respond appropriately. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position ME Prefer 1 year of Public Safety Dispatch Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Police - Dispatch (671) Certificates & Licenses ACIC Basic and Advanced Certification City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $20.77 $18.08 $21.92 $25.04 $20.77 $18.08 $21.92 $25.04 0.38% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $18.69 $17.36 $21.70 $27.10 $19.06 $17.71 $22.13 $27.64 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $24.59 $20.63 $25.02 $30.49 $23.36 $19.60 $23.77 $28.97 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $20.34 $16.71 $20.89 $26.11 $20.34 $16.71 $20.89 $26.11 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $19.11 $18.76 $23.44 $28.13 $19.11 $18.76 $23.44 $28.13 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $21.98 $18.78 $23.48 $28.18 $21.98 $18.78 $23.48 $28.18 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $21.42 1 $18.67 $23.34 $28.01 1 $21.42 $18.67 $23.34 $28.01 1 0.50% Averages Match 1 $20.99 1 $18.43 1 $22.83 1 $27.58 1 $20.86 1 $18.33 1 $22.71 1 $27.44 1 0.50% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $19.35 $18.73 $22.57 $27.99 t---2"49% $ Difference 51 $0.40 $-0.14 $0.55 Difference 1 -7.80% 1 2.14% 1 -0.62% 1 1.96% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 34 of 98 APPENDIX 5 DISTRICT COURT ADMINISTRATOR Index Tab 135- DISTRICT COURT ADMINISTRATOR Job Description and Qualifications: Oversee clerical support activities relating to the administration of legal processes and procedures. Maintain the Judge's calendar and prepare daily schedule. Act as a liaison between the Judge and a variety of departments and agencies. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position AK - 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 2 years District Court (380) Certificates & Licenses Notary preferred City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $49.27 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 1 $49.27 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $47.05 $35.11 $44.81 $51.91 $44.70 $33.35 $42.57 $49.31 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $42.02 $36.89 $46.12 $57.64 $42.02 $36.89 $46.12 $57.64 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $36.49 $26.54 $33.17 $39.81 $36.49 $26.54 $33.17 $39.81 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $50.76 $40.66 $50.83 $61.00 $50.76 $40.66 $50.83 $61.00 0.50% Compdata Match $49.51 $39.42 $49.28 $59.14 $49.51 $39.42 $49.28 $59.14 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $51.19 $39.28 $49.10 $58.92 $51.19 $39.28 $49.10 $58.92 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $48.63 $37.72 $47.15 $56.58 $48.63 $37.72 $47.15 $56.58 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 4.84% 1 8.13% 1 3.63% 1 6.08% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 35 of 98 APPENDIX 5 ENVIRONMENTAL DIRECTOR Index Tab 136- ENVIRONMENTAL DIRECTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Oversee operations and policy formulation for the City's sustainability and strategic planning. Directs the activities of the Sustainability Department including oversight of the Recycling & Trash Collections Division. Education FLSA Bachelor's degree in Engineering, Environmental Sciences Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 10 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 7 years Sustainability/Parking (240) Certificates & Licenses Licensed Professional Engineer City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $56.92 $39.54 $53.44 $67.33 $56.92 $39.54 $53.44 $67.33 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $61.50 $50.21 $61.04 $74.23 $58.43 $47.70 $57.99 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $56.50 $46.12 $57.65 $72.06 $56.50 $46.12 $57.65 $72.06 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $62.10 $48.64 $60.80 $72.96 $62.10 $48.64 $60.80 $72.96 0.50% Compdata Match $60.30 $47.22 $59.03 $70.84 $60.30 $47.22 $59.03 $70.84 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $68.00 $51.45 $64.31 $77.17 $68.00 $51.45 $64.31 $77.17 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $60.99 $47.61 $59.51 $71.41 $60.99 $47.61 $59.51 $71.41 0.509/o Averages Match $60.90 $47.26 $59.40 $72.29 $60.46 $46.90 $58.96 $71.76 0.53% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 557.73 546.68 556.24 569.74 0.49% 1%Difference 1 -4.73% 1 -0.47% 1 -4.84% 1 -2.90% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 36 of 98 APPENDIX 5 EQUIPMENT MECHANIC II Index Tab 37-EQUIPMENT MECHANICII -1111119 Job Description and Qualifications: This position is a journeyman level mechanic position requiring training and experience on a variety of automotive, utility and construction equipment. Perform diagnostic procedures regular maintenance and major repairs and rebuilds. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED and specialize auto repair training Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Fleet (410) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $24.38 $18.33 $22.91 $27.49 $24.38 $18.33 $22.91 $27.49 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $20.97 $17.36 $21.70 $27.10 $21.39 $17.71 $22.13 $27.64 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.27 $22.96 $27.57 $33.54 $25.91 $21.81 $26.19 $31.86 0.46% City of Rogers, AR Match $22.18 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 $22.18 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $19.40 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 $19.40 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $24.13 $19.17 $23.96 $28.75 $24.13 $19.17 $23.96 $28.75 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $22.52 $18.21 $22.76 $27.31 $22.52 $18.21 $22.76 $27.31 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $22.98 1 $18.98 1 $23.57 1 $28.67 $22.84 $18.87 $23.43 1 $28.50 1 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AIR Match $21.63 118.73 $22.57 527.99 0.49% $ Difference 21 $-0.1.4 $-0.86 $-0.51 %Difference -5.59% -0.75% -3.81% -1.82% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 37 of 98 APPENDIX 5 FACILITIES BUILDING MAINTENANCE MANAGER Index Tab 138 - FACILITIES & BUILDING MAINTENANCE MANAGER Job Description and Qualifications: Plan administer and supervise and routine building maintenance services including electrical plumbing and HVAC. Coordinate new construction or remodeling with supervisor. Prepare bids specifications. Oversee performance of outside P 1 g g .p g g P P P contractors to ensure quality results. Prepare the budget for the Facilities Management Division. Oversee all accounts within division programs, monitor overtime expenses and ensure purchases are within budgeted amounts. Serve as ADA Coordinator for Education FLSA High school diploma or GED. Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Facilities Mgmt (323) Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver®License. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $38.11 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 $38.11 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $38.48 $33.46 $41.83 $52.22 $39.25 $34.13 $42.67 $53.26 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $41.68 $35.11 $44.81 $51.91 $39.60 $33.35 $42.57 $49.31 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $40.67 $32.28 $40.35 $50.44 $40.67 $32.28 $40.35 $50.44 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Less $27.71 1 $23.33 $29.17 $35.00 $27.71 1 $23.33 $29.17 $35.00 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $42.79 $33.83 $42.29 $50.75 $42.79 $33.83 $42.29 $50.75 0.50% Compdata Match $41.49 $32.81 $41.01 $49.21 $41.49 $32.81 $41.01 $49.21 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $45.68 $34.92 $43.65 $52.38 $45.68 $34.92 $43.65 $52.38 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $40.97 $32.72 $40.90 $49.08 $40.97 $32.72 $40.90 $49.08 0.50% Averages Match $39.73 $32.06 $40.52 $49.14 $39.59 $31.94 $40.37 $48.97 0.53% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 539.68 532.87 539.60 549.10 0.49% 1%Difference 1 0.23% 1 2.83% 1 -1.94% 1 0.26% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 38 of 98 APPENDIX 5 FIELD OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR - FORESTRY Index Tab 139 - FIELD OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR - FORESTRY Job Description and Qualifications: Advise supervisor of potential operational problems and propose and implement corrective actions as necessary using independent judgment. Maintain records to document materials, manpower, and equipment required. Developing and scheduling annual work program and goals. Develop improvement and maintenance projects with estimated costs. Coordinate with utilities, state agencies, and contractors in order to expedite projects. Manage contracts and contractors as necessary when tasks are Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 1 year Park Operations (651) Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid driver® license. Must possessor have the ability to obtain a valid Class A Commercial Driver®License. Must obtain a Class A CDL within 120 days of hire date. Must possessor be able to obtain a Commercial Pesticide Applicator license and Certified Arborist certification from the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) within six months of hire date. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $28.11 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 $28.11 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $35.03 $27.45 $33.36 $40.58 $33.28 $26.08 $31.69 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $25.62 $22.48 $28.09 $35.12 $25.62 $22.48 $28.09 $35.12 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $32.74 $24.85 $31.06 $37.27 $32.74 $24.85 $31.06 $37.27 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $27.95 $22.56 $28.20 $33.84 $27.95 $22.56 $28.20 $33.84 0.50% Averages Match $29.89 $24.03 $29.85 $36.21 $29.54 $23.76 $29.51 $35.80 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $26.63 522.75 $27.41 533.99 0.49% $ Difference $-2.91 $-1.01 $-2.10 $-1.81 %Difference -10.93% -4.44% -7.66% -5.33% M a rket Ave rage Hourly Rates and M a rket Ave rage Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 39 of 98 APPENDIX 5 FIELD OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR -TRANSPORTATION Index Tab 140- FIELD OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR - TRANSPORTATION Job Description and Qualifications: Provide supervision of sidewalk, street, drainage and trail construction programs. Visit work sites to inspect work in progress and ensure projects are completed properly and according to schedule. Respond to citizen and service requests; make independent decisions in the field as to course of action to be taken. Develop improvement and maintenance projects with estimated costs. Estimate annual material needs and assist in preparing bids. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma / GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 1 year Transportation (130) Certificates & Licenses Class "A" CDL within 120 days City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $29.12 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 $29.12 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $34.57 $27.45 $33.36 $40.58 $32.84 $26.08 $31.69 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $27.99 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 $27.99 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $41.53 $30.20 $37.75 $45.30 $41.53 $30.20 $37.75 $45.30 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $32.74 $24.85 $31.06 $37.27 $32.74 $24.85 $31.06 $37.27 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $29.34 $23.01 $28.76 $34.51 $29.34 $23.01 $28.76 $34.51 0.509/o Averages Match $32.55 $25.33 $31.50 $38.14 $32.26 $25.10 $31.22 $37.80 1 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $30.61 522.75 $27.41 533.99 0.49% $ Difference $-1.65 $-2.35 5-3.81 5-3.81 Difference -5.39%-10.33% -13.90 o-11.2116 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 40 of 98 APPENDIX 5 FIELD SERVICE REPRESENTATIVE Index Tab 141- FIELD SERVICE REPRESENTATIVE Job Description and Qualifications: Locate water and sewer underground utilities using utility maps and sensitive electronic equipment. Calculate distances to ensure exact locations; mark the location of utilities using locating equipment, paint and line tracers. Respond to emergency situations to give information and directions to contractors, City employees, and the general public to prevent further damage and lessen health and safety hazards. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department 1 year W/S Services (160) Certificates & Licenses CDL Class A with Tanker endorsement. Grade 3 Water Distribution License, Arkansas Wastewater License Class 1, Confined Space License City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $29.36 $21.70 $27.12 $32.54 $29.36 $21.70 $27.12 $32.54 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $30.48 $26.63 $32.37 $39.37 $28.96 $25.30 $30.75 $37.40 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $26.10 $21.31 $26.63 $31.96 $26.10 $21.31 $26.63 $31.96 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $31.10 $23.61 $29.51 $35.41 $31.10 $23.61 $29.51 $35.41 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $28.69 $21.86 $27.32 $32.78 $28.69 $21.86 $27.32 $32.78 0.50% i Averages i Match $29.15 $23.02 $28.59 $34.41 $28.84 $22.76 $28.27 $34.02 0.49% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 530.20 $21.75 526.20 532.49 0.49% $ Difference $1.36 $-1.01 $-2.07 $-1.53 %Difference 4.50% -4.64% -7.90% -4.71% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 41 of 98 APPENDIX 5 FINANCIAL ANALYST - FIRE Index Tab 142- FINANCIAL ANALYST -FIRE Job Description and Qualifications: Advise, consult, and assist with the development, management, and planning of the department®annual budget, and bidding/quotes. Prepare weekly, monthly, quarterly, and annual reports related to each division of the assiged Department and the department®operating and capital projects. Education FLSA B.S. / B.A. in related field Exempt Related Experience W Supervisory Position 2 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department 6 months Various (Various) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $28.90 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 $28.90 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $34.57 $31.35 $38.12 $46.36 $32.84 $29.78 $36.21 $44.04 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $31.50 $23.63 $29.64 $36.92 $31.50 $23.63 $29.64 $36.92 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $33.66 $26.14 $32.68 $39.22 $33.66 $26.14 $32.68 $39.22 0.50% Compdata Match $32.36 $25.38 $31.73 $38.08 $32.36 $25.38 $31.73 $38.08 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $31.59 $24.00 $30.00 $36.00 $31.59 $24.00 $30.00 $36.00 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $30.98 $25.42 $31.78 $38.14 $30.98 $25.42 $31.78 $38.14 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 6.05% 1 -6.34% 1 -9.91% 1 -7.14% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.50% 0.49% Page 42 of 98 APPENDIX 5 FIRE CHIEF Index Tab 143 -FIRE CHIEF Job Description and Qualifications: Manage the daily operations of the fire department. Develop internal policies and operating procedures to maintain high levels of efficiency and compliance. Education FLSA B.S. / B.A. in related field Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 11 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 9 years Fire (700) Certificates & Licenses Firefighter, Fire Management, Fire Executive Management and Incident Command City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $55.77 $46.86 $58.45 $70.04 $55.77 $46.86 $58.45 $70.04 0.49% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $51.49 $48.97 $52.03 $57.32 $52.52 $49.95 $53.07 $58.47 0.17% City of Lawrence, KS Match $80.54 $69.57 $86.69 $102.86 $76.51 $66.09 $82.36 $97.72 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $72.75 $55.35 $69.18 $86.48 $72.75 $55.35 $69.18 $86.48 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match 1 $69.75 $48.52 $60.65 $72.78 $69.75 1 $48.52 $60.65 $72.78 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $72.84 $56.58 $70.72 1 $84.86 $72.84 1 $56.58 1 $70.72 1 $84.86 0.50% Compdata Match $71.31 $55.39 $69.24 $83.09 $71.31 $55.39 $69.24 $83.09 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $75.63 $58.20 1 $72.75 $87.30 $75.63 $58.20 1 $72.75 1 $87.30 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 0.25% 1 -7.52% 1 -9.54% 1 -5.52% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.47% 0.49% Page 43 of 98 APPENDIX 5 FLIGHT LINE OPERATIONS TECHNICIAN Index Tab 144- FLIGHT LINE OPERATIONS TECHNICIAN Job Description and Qualifications: Monitor access to the terminal aircraft parking area and restrict access as may be appropriate. Moves aircraft in and out of hangars and on ramp areas using hand and motor -drive tugs. Parks, fuels and ties down/chocks aircraft; perform minor service such as airing tires on aircraft as needed. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 12-18 Months Non -Supervisory Management Experience IF Department Not Required Airport Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid drivers license. Certification from NATA, FAA, or NFPA preferred. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $17.38 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 $17.38 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $20.01 $20.01 $24.32 $29.58 $19.01 $19.01 $23.10 $28.10 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 $18.09 $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $20.72 $15.62 $19.53 $23.44 $20.72 $15.62 $19.53 $23.44 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $21.04 $16.68 $20.85 $25.02 $21.04 $16.68 $20.85 $25.02 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $19.45 $16.56 $20.56 $24.96 $19.25 1 $16.36 $20.32 1 $24.66 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $17.81 515.71 $18t9 523.47 0.49% $ Difference $-1.44 $-0.65 $-1.39 $-1.19 %Difference -8.09% -4.14% -7.34% -5.07% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 44 of 98 APPENDIX 5 G IS ANALYST Index Tab 145 - GIS ANALYST Job Description and Qualifications: Develop and maintain maps and data downloader. This includes using and maintaining the ArcGIS server and ArcGIS online. Responsible for data collection and maintenance of all Public Works related infrastructure. Perform simple to complex spatial analysis to assist departments with information gathering and decision making. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED and 2 years college Prefer B.S./ B.A. related field Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years or 3 years with BS/BA Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Information Technologies (370) Certificates & Licenses Master's degree in GIS or related field and 2 years of experience City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $30.91 $26.75 $33.44 $40.12 $30.91 $26.75 $33.44 $40.12 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $19.10 $19.10 $23.88 $29.81 $19.48 $19.48 $24.36 $30.41 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $29.43 $27.45 $35.03 $40.58 $27.96 $26.08 $33.28 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $35.78 $26.71 $33.39 $40.07 $35.78 $26.71 $33.39 $40.07 0.50% City of Springdale, AR Match $24.52 $22.42 $28.02 $33.63 $24.52 $22.42 $28.02 $33.63 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $34.14 $26.78 $33.48 $40.18 $34.14 $26.78 $33.48 $40.18 0.50% Compdata Match $33.39 $25.96 $32.45 $38.94 $33.39 $25.96 $32.45 $38.94 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $ 3 1 . 5 3 $25.63 $32.04 $38.45 $31.53 $25.63 $32.04 $38.45 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $31.74 $24.53 $30.66 $36.79 $31.74 $24.53 $30.66 $36.79 0.50% Averages Match $30.06 $25.04 $31.38 $37.62 $29.94 $24.93 $31.24 $37.46 0.50% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 529.06 525.66 530.91 538.33 0.49% 1%Difference 1 -3.03% 1 2.84% 1 -1.07% 1 2.27% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 45 of 98 APPENDIX 5 GIS MANAGER Index Tab 146-GIS MANAGER Job Description and Qualifications: Supervise the collection and assignment of addresses and other geographical information critical for E 911 dispatchers and other emergency service related geography. Manage the City's GIS website and mobile mapping applications. Supervise GIS modeling of City water, sewer and stormwater networks. Education FLSA B.S./B.A Degree in GIS or related field Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 2 years Information Technologies (370) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $42.89 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 $42.89 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $31.09 $23.02 $28.77 $35.92 $31.71 $23.48 $29.35 $36.64 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $52.70 $39.32 $47.80 $58.14 $50.07 $37.35 $45.41 $55.23 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $43.01 $34.59 $43.23 $54.04 $43.01 $34.59 $43.23 $54.04 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $39.90 $28.37 $35.46 $42.56 $39.90 $28.37 $35.46 $42.56 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $48.91 $38.14 $47.68 $57.22 $48.91 $38.14 $47.68 $57.22 0.50% Compdata Match $47.41 $37.00 $46.25 $55.50 $47.41 $37.00 $46.25 $55.50 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $46.71 $36.34 $45.42 $54.50 $46.71 $36.34 $45.42 $54.50 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $44.32 $35.09 $43.86 1 $52.63 $44.32 $35.09 $43.86 $52.63 0.50% Averages Match $44.10 $33.55 $42.13 $51.31 $43.88 $33.39 $41.93 $51.07 0.53% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 546.69 534.79 541.92 551.98 0.49% 1%Difference 1 6.02% 1 4.02% 1 -0.02% 1 1.75% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 46 of 98 APPENDIX 5 GISTECNICIAN Index Tab 147-GIS TECNICIAN Job Description and Qualifications: EWA Develop and maintain an accurate and current pavement center -line database, land records system, address location system, water/sewer and storm water utility database and GIS information. Education FLSA or H.S. Diploma or GED and 2 Years College Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Information Technologies (370) Certificates & Licenses Bachelor's Degree in GIS or related field and 1 year of experience City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $22.63 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 $22.63 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $22.69 $22.69 $28.95 $33.54 $21.56 $21.56 $27.50 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $28.62 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 $28.62 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $28.27 $21.59 $26.99 $32.39 $28.27 $21.59 $26.99 $32.39 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $26.75 $20.40 $25.50 $30.60 $26.75 $20.40 $25.50 $30.60 0.50% Averages Match $25.79 $21.08 $26.47 $31.78 $25.57 $20.86 $26.18 $31.44 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 130.99 $20.74 $24.99 530.99 0.49% $ Difference $5.42 $-0.12 $-1.19 $-0.45 %Difference 17.49% -0.58% -4.76% -1.45% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 47 of 98 APPENDIX 5 HORTICULTURAL ASSISTANT II Index Tab 148 - HORTICULTURAL ASSISTANT II Job Description and Qualifications: Assist with cultivation and care of flowers, plants, shrubs and trees on city public spaces. Assist with design of gardens and public spaces. Assist in selection and acquisition of appropriate plant materials for public spaces. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Parks(120) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $16.70 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 $16.70 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $19.89 $20.01 $24.32 $29.58 $18.90 $19.01 $23.10 $28.10 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $17.25 $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 $17.25 $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 0.56% City of Springdale, AR More $20.59 $20.59 $25.73 $30.88 $20.59 $20.59 $25.73 $30.88 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $18.74 $16.28 $20.35 $24.42 $18.74 $16.28 $20.35 $24.42 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $18.25 $16.03 $20.04 $24.05 $18.25 $16.03 $20.04 $24.05 0.50% Averages Match $18.57 1 $17.23 1 $21.42 1 $25.95 1 $18.40 1 $17.06 1 $21.22 1 $25.70 1 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $17.63 $15.71 $18.93 $23.47 t--2"49% $ Difference $-0.77 $-1.35 $-2.29 $-2.23 Difference 1 -4.37% 1 -8.59%1 -12.10% 1 -9.50% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 48 of 98 APPENDIX 5 HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR Index Tab 149- HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Management and oversight for City's Human Resources Department. Creation and interpretation of the City's HR policies. HR Functional management of employee compensation, benefits, recruitment, retention, personnel records, EEOC charges, EEO compliance, FLSA, Employee Training, FMLA, Discrimination laws and ADA. Education FLSA Bachelor's Degree in HR Mgmt. or related field. Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Human Resources (390) Certificates & Licenses Professional HR Certification Desirable City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $54.88 $39.54 $53.44 $67.33 $54.88 $39.54 $53.44 $67.33 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $40.99 $33.46 $41.83 $52.22 $41.81 $34.13 $42.67 $53.26 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $61.49 $58.56 $71.18 $86.57 $58.42 $55.63 $67.62 $82.24 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $59.04 $46.12 $57.65 $72.06 $59.04 $46.12 $57.65 $72.06 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match 1 $54.12 $39.36 $49.20 $59.04 $54.12 1 $39.36 $49.20 $59.04 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $64.70 $51.00 $63.75 $76.50 $64.70 $51.00 $63.75 $76.50 0.50% Compdata Match $63.07 $49.46 $61.83 $74.20 $63.07 $49.46 $61.83 $74.20 0.50% DOL- BLS-NWA Match $69.06 $52.41 $65.51 $78.61 $69.06 $52.41 $65.51 $78.61 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $64.88 552.18 $65.22 $78.26 $64.88 $52.18 $65.22 $78.26 0.50% Averages Match $59.14 $46.90 $58.85 $71.64 $58.89 $46.65 $58.54 $71.28 0.53% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 558.45 544.63 553.77 566.67 0.49% 1%Difference 1 -0.75% 1 -4.53% 1 -8.87% 1 -6.91% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 49 of 98 APPENDIX 5 HUMAN RESOURCES GENERALIST Index Tab 150-HUMAN RESOURCES GENERALIST Job Description and Qualifications: Participate in the development and implementation of HR goals, objectives, policies and priorities. Coordinate HR programs and activities including: performance management, drug screening, recruiting, and benefits. Education FLSA Bachelor's Degree in HR Mgmt. or related field. Exempt Related Experience ff Supervisory Position 5 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience IF Department 2 years Human Resources (390) Certificates & Licenses PHR or SHRM-CP desirable. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $29.93 $23.94 $29.93 $35.91 $29.93 $23.94 $29.93 $35.91 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $20.97 $18.23 $22.79 $28.45 $21.39 $18.59 $23.25 $29.02 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $32.92 $27.45 $35.03 $40.58 $31.27 $26.08 $33.28 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $27.58 $25.36 $31.70 $39.62 $27.58 $25.36 $31.70 $39.62 0.56% City of Springdale, AR More $32.34 $26.54 $33.17 $39.81 $32.34 $26.54 $33.17 $39.81 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $32.98 $25.86 $32.33 $38.80 $32.98 $25.86 $32.33 $38.80 0.50% Compdata Match $31.35 $24.69 $30.86 $37.03 $31.35 $24.69 $30.86 $37.03 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $38.33 $28.54 $35.68 $42.82 $38.33 $28.54 $35.68 $42.82 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $34.50 $27.90 $34.88 $41.86 $34.50 $27.90 $34.88 $41.86 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 -0.52% 1 1.48% 1 -2.46% 1 0.44% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.51% 0.49% Page 50 of 98 APPENDIX 5 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES DIRECTOR Index Tab 151- INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES DIRECTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for day-to-day operations, maintenance, security and performance of the City's information technology infrastructure and applications, including GIS and Communications (telephony, VOIP, cell phones, wireless functionality). Education FLSA B.S. / B.A. related field Prefer I.T. Degree Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 7 years ]Information Supervisory Management Experience Department 5 years Technologies (370) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $49.06 $39.54 $53.44 $67.33 $49.06 $39.54 $53.44 $67.33 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $38.48 $33.46 $41.83 $52.22 $39.25 $34.13 $42.67 $53.26 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $74.57 $64.42 $78.30 $95.24 $70.84 $61.20 $74.38 $90.48 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $55.28 $46.12 $57.65 $72.06 $55.28 $46.12 $57.65 $72.06 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $56.64 $41.19 $51.49 $61.79 $56.64 1 $41.19 $51.49 $61.79 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $66.33 $53.02 $66.28 $79.54 $66.33 $53.02 $66.28 $79.54 0.50% Compdata Match $65.03 $51.42 $64.28 $77.14 $65.03 $51.42 $64.28 $77.14 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $75.83 $56.94 $71.18 $85.42 $75.83 $56.94 $71.18 $85.42 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $65.35 $52.98 $66.22 $79.46 $65.35 $52.98 $66.22 $79.46 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 2.94% 1 -3.90% 1 -8.18% 1 -6.18% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 51 of 98 APPENDIX 5 INSPECTOR -COMMERCIAL RESIDENTIAL Index Tab 152- INSPECTOR -COMMERCIAL &RESIDENTIAL Job Description and Qualifications: Review permit applications, drawings, and specifications for code and ordinance compliance. Inspect residential and commercial building during construction of new buildings, alternations, additions & repairs. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Building Safety (220) Certificates & Licenses ICC Certification AR State Plumbing, Electrical and Mechanical Inspection Lics. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $29.32 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 $29.32 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $20.11 $17.36 $21.70 $27.10 $20.51 $17.71 $22.13 $27.64 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $30.46 $22.69 $30.35 $36.91 $28.94 $21.56 $28.83 $35.06 0.63% City of Rogers, AR Match $21.99 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 $21.99 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $19.88 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 $19.88 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $28.36 $21.04 $26.30 $31.56 $28.30 $21.04 $26.30 $31.56 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $24.15 $20.34 $25.42 $30.50 $24.15 $20.34 $25.42 $30.50 0.50% Averages Match $24.89 $20.32 $25.69 $31.22 $24.73 $20.21 $25.53 $31.04 0.54% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 523.97 $20.74 524.99 530.99 0.49% $ Difference $-0.76 $0.53 $-0.54 $-0.05 %Difference -3.17% 2.56% -2.16% -0.16% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 52 of 98 APPENDIX 5 INTERNALAUDITOR Index Tab 153- INTERNAL AUDITOR Job Description and Qualifications: The scope of internal audit encompasses the examination and evaluation of the adequacy and effectiveness of the City's governance, risk management process system of internal control structure and the quality of performance in carrying -out assigned responsibilities to achieve organization's stated goals and objectives. Education FLSA B.S. / B.A. Accounting, Finance or related field Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years with 2 years of Auditing Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Internal Audit (315) Certificates & Licenses Prefer one of the following: Certified Internal Auditor, Certified Information Systems Audit or Certified Fraud Examiner, City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $39.88 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 $39.88 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $42.03 $35.11 $44.81 $51.91 $39.93 $33.35 $42.57 $49.31 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $37.04 $32.28 $40.35 $50.44 $37.04 $32.28 $40.35 $50.44 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $40.80 $32.38 $40.48 $48.58 $40.80 $32.38 $40.48 $48.58 0.50% Compdata Match $39.56 $31.38 $39.23 $47.08 $39.56 $31.38 $39.23 $47.08 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $39.09 $31.76 $39.70 $47.64 $39.09 $31.76 $39.70 $47.64 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $39.64 $32.57 $40.71 $48.85 $39.64 $32.57 $40.71 $48.85 0.50% Averages Match $39.72 $32.23 $40.85 $49.40 $39.42 $31.98 $40.53 $49.03 0.53% Citv of Favetteville. AR Match 537.80 532.87 539.60 549.10 0.49% 1%Difference 1 -4.29% 1 2.71% 1 -2.35% 1 0.14% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 53 of 98 APPENDIX 5 LEAD MAINTENANCE WORKER GROUNDS- PARKS Index Tab 154- LEAD MAINTENANCE WORKER GROUNDS - PARKS Job Description and Qualifications: Perform supervisory responsibilities which may include training employees; planning, assigning, and directing work; appraising performance, addressing complaints and resolving problems. Perform ground maintenance including mowing, string trimming, edging, blowing, mulching, and chemical applications including pest and weed management. Responsible for crew maintaining all equipment and material used on a daily basis. Utilize design plans and locator equipment to troubleshoot and repair irrigation leaks. Prepare daily reports to record materials, labor hours and equipment for system entry. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Supervisory Management Experience Department Park Operations (645) Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid driver®license. Must possess or have the ability to obtain a valid Class A Commercial Driver®License within 120 days of hire date. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $24.84 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 $24.84 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $30.77 $23.02 $28.77 $35.92 $31.39 $23.48 $29.35 $36.64 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $26.28 $22.69 $27.57 $33.54 $24.97 $21.56 $26.19 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $19.42 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 $19.42 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $19.29 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 $19.29 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $22.34 $17.86 $22.32 $26.78 $22.34 $17.86 $22.32 $26.78 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $22.13 $17.87 $22.34 $26.81 1 $22.13 $17.87 $22.34 $26.81 0.50% i Averages i Match $23.58 $19.51 $24.28 $29.56 $23.48 $19.42 1 $24.16 $29.42 0.52% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $21.60 517.72 $21.35 526.47 0.49% $ Difference $-1.88 $-1.70 $-2.81 $-2.95 %Difference -8.70% -9.59%-11.14% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 54 of 98 APPENDIX 5 MAINTENANCE WORKER II PARKS Index Tab 155- MAINTENANCE WORKER II PARKS Job Description and Qualifications: Perform semi -skilled physical labor and operation of light and heavy duty equipment in the construction, maintenance and repair of park facilities. Mow grass and trim weeds on park grounds. Prune, trim or remove trees. Operate loaders, tree trimmers and other construction equipment as needed. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 1-6 Months Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Parks Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver's License. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $16.70 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 $16.70 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $16.11 $14.43 $18.04 $22.53 $16.43 $14.72 $18.40 $22.98 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $22.70 $18.75 $22.79 $27.73 $21.57 $17.81 $21.65 $26.34 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $17.27 $14.40 $18.00 $22.50 $17.27 $14.40 $18.00 $22.50 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $15.92 $15.09 $18.87 $22.64 $15.92 $15.09 $18.87 $22.64 0.50' DOL-BLS-NWA Match $17.55 $13.59 $16.99 $20.39 $17.55 $13.59 $16.99 $20.39 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $17.94 $13.60 $17.00 $20.40 $17.94 1 $13.60 $17.00 $20.40 0.50% Averages Match $17.74 $14.97 $18.62 $22.66 $17.63 $14.87 $18.51 $22.53 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 517.05 513.86 $16.70 520.71 0.49% $ Difference $-0.58 $-1.01 $-1.81 $-1.82 Difference -3.40% -7.21%-10.841-8.791 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 55 of 98 APPENDIX 5 MAINTENANCE WORKER III PARKS Index Tab 156- MAINTENANCE WORKER III PARKS Job Description and Qualifications: Perform various repairs and improvements as assigned using all types of equipment. Operate and maintain equipment. Assist as assigned in all aspects of the division including grounds maintenance, facilities maintenance, equipment maintenance, athletic field maintenance and urban forestry. Operate loaders, tree trimmers and other construction equipment as needed. Education 9r FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 1 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Parks(120) Certificates & Licenses Obtain a CDL [A license within six (6) months of hire City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $19.46 $16.08 $20.10 $24.12 $19.46 $16.08 $20.10 $24.12 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $23.89 $20.01 $24.32 $29.58 $22.70 $19.01 $23.10 $28.10 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $18.13 $19.44 $24.31 $18.13 $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL - BLS - NWA Match $19.74 $15.62 $19.53 $23.44 $19.74 $15.62 $19.53 $23.44 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $19.60 $15.53 $19.41 $23.29 $19.60 $15.53 $19.41 $23.29 0.50% Averages Match $20.16 $16.56 $20.56 $24.95 $19.93 $16.36 $20.32 $24.65 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $17.79 515.21 $18.32 522.72 0.49% $ Difference $-2.14 $-1.15 $-2.00 $-1.93 Difference-12.03% -7.56%-10.92% -8.49, Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 56 of 98 APPENDIX 5 MAINTENANCE WORKER III TRANSPORTATION Index Tab 157- MAINTENANCE WORKER III TRANSPORTATION lowJob Description and Qualifications: Perform hand labor for asphalt, concrete or other material as needed. Operate concrete saws to make necessary cuts in order to continue workflow. Operate loader, tree trimmer, chainsaw, chipper, compactor and other equipment as needed. Perform traffic control. Train on use of heavy equipment. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Transportation (130) Certificates & Licenses Class B CDL within 120 days City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $19.06 $16.08 $20.10 $24.12 $19.06 $16.08 $20.10 $24.12 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $15.48 $15.10 $18.87 $23.56 $15.79 $15.40 $19.25 $24.03 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $22.88 $20.01 $24.32 $29.58 $21.74 $19.01 $23.10 $28.10 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $18.16 $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 $18.16 $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $18.51 $15.09 $19.51 $24.01 $18.51 $15.09 $19.51 $24.01 0.59% DOL - BLS - NWA Match $19.74 $15.61 $19.53 $23.44 $19.74 $15.62 $19.53 $23.44 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $19.60 $15.53 $19.41 $23.29 1 $19.60 $15.53 $19.41 $23.29 1 0.50% Averages Match $19.06 1 $16.14 1 $20.17 1 $24.62 1 $18.94 1 $16.04 1 $20.05 1 $24.47 1 0.53% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $17.48 $15.21 $18.32 $22.72 t___2"49% $ Difference $-1.46 $-0.83 $-1.73 $-1.75 Difference 1 -8.35% 1 -5.46% 1 -9.44% 1 -7.70% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 57 of 98 APPENDIX 5 MAINTENANCE WORKER III WATER SEWER Index Tab 158- MAINTENANCE WORKER III WATER SEWER Job Description and Qualifications: Fix water and sewer leaks in order to keep the City's water lines intact and in good working order. Install mains for both water and sewer and install water and sewer taps. Maintain truck, equipment and related tools. Drive backhoe and dump truck as assigned. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 6 months Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Water & Sewer (160) Certificates & Licenses Class A CDL with tanker endorsement within 6 months City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $25.96 $19.07 $23.28 $27.48 $25.96 $19.07 $23.28 $27.48 0.44% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.60 $22.69 $27.57 $33.54 $26.22 $21.56 $26.19 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $19.74 $18.08 $22.59 $27.11 $19.74 $18.08 $22.59 $27.11 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $21.66 $17.97 $22.46 $26.95 $21.66 $17.97 $22.46 $26.95 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $21.79 $17.04 $21.30 $25.56 $21.79 $17.04 $21.30 $25.56 0.50% Averages Match $23.35 $18.97 $23.44 $28.13 $23.07 $18.74 $23.16 $27.79 0.48% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 518.76 $17.72 521.35 526.47 0.49% $ Difference $-4.31 $-1.02 $-1.81 $-1.31 %Difference-22.97% 1116% -8.48% -4.99% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 58 of 98 APPENDIX 5 MAINTENANCE WORKER IV CONCRETE Index Tab 159 - MAINTENANCE WORKER IV CONCRETE Job Description and Qualifications: Provide supervision of Maintenance III and other workers in the absence of the Crew Leader or lead workers. Operate heavy construction equipment such as: backhoe, bobcat, skid loader, dump truck, front end loader and slipform paver. Assist and/or lead in all aspects of the division. Assist with basic grades construction of sidewalks, street, trails and drainage. Perform basic carpentry and concrete finishing skills. Move equipment and materials to and from job sites. Maintain equipment through daily maintenance, check and grease applications. Education FLSA High school diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience 18 months Supervisory Position Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Transportation (130) Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver®License. Possess or obtain CDLM within 120 days of hire date. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $20.46 $17.20 $21.50 $25.80 $20.46 $17.20 $21.50 $25.80 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $17.92 $15.52 $19.40 $24.22 $18.28 $15.83 $19.79 $24.70 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $24.45 $21.25 $25.83 $31.42 $23.23 $20.19 $24.54 $29.85 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $19.35 $16.82 $21.02 $25.22 $19.35 $16.82 $21.02 $25.22 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $23.08 $18.30 $22.88 $27.46 $23.08 $18.30 $22.88 $27.46 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $19.46 $16.68 $20.85 $25.02 $19.46 $16.68 $20.85 $25.02 0.50% Averages Match $20.79 $17.63 $21.91 $26.52 $20.64 $17.50 $21.76 $26.34 0.50% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 518.43 5166 2 $20.15 122 0.49% $ Difference $-2.21 $-0.78 $-1.61 $-1.35 Difference-11.99% -4.67% -7.99% -5.40% M a rket Ave rage Hourly Rates and M a rket Ave rage Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 59 of 98 APPENDIX 5 MAINTENANCE WORKER IV WATER SEWER LICENSED Index Tab 160 - MAINTENANCE WORKER IV WATER & SEWER LICENSED Job Description and Qualifications: Assist Supervisor with the planning and preparation of jobs. Function as supervisor in the absence of the foreman. Maintain and operate equipment, and drive dump trucks. Know and understand other utility markings. Communicate with the public in a professional manner. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Water & Sewer (160) Certificates & Licenses Grade I Water Distribution License. Arkansas Class I Wastewater License within two years City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $29.11 $20.42 $24.80 $29.17 $29.11 $20.42 $24.80 $29.17 0.43% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $28.41 $22.69 $28.95 $33.54 $26.99 $21.56 $27.50 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $22.05 $18.57 $23.22 $27.86 $22.05 $18.57 $23.22 $27.86 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $23.20 $19.49 $24.36 $29.23 $23.20 $19.49 $24.36 $29.23 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $22.28 $18.74 $23.43 $28.12 $22.28 $18.74 $23.43 $28.12 0.50% Averages Match 1 $25.01 1 $19.98 1 $24.95 1 $29.58 $24.73 $19.76 $24.66 $29.25 0.48% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 521.86 $18.73 $22.57 527191 0.49% $ Difference $-2.87 -2.09 $-1.26 %Difference-13.13% -5.50% -9.26% -4.50% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 60 of 98 APPENDIX 5 METER MAINTENANCE TECHNICIAN Index Tab 161- METER MAINTENANCE TECHNICIAN Job Description and Qualifications: Test meters and keep accurate data of each meter. Rebuild and make necessary repairs of meters after testing and failure of standard requirements. Install large commercial size meters. Connect high tech reading devices to meters in order to facilitate electronic data exchange. Education High School or GED xempt Related Experience visory Position 2 Years upervisory rDepartment Management Experience Not Required METER Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid Drivers License. Ability to obtain certificates from various meter repair and testing seminars throughout time in the position. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $26.22 $20.57 $25.71 $30.85 $26.22 $20.57 $25.71 $30.85 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $29.82 $22.69 $28.95 $33.54 $28.33 $21.56 $27.50 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $24.96 $18.57 $23.22 $27.86 $24.96 $18.57 $23.22 $27.86 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $26.35 $19.49 $24.36 $29.23 $26.35 $19.49 $24.36 $29.23 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $24.70 $19.19 $23.99 $28.79 $24.70 $19.19 $23.99 $28.79 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $26.41 $20.10 $25.25 $30.05 i $26.11 $19.88 1 $24.96 $29.72 1 0.50% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 525.56 518.73 $222 " 527.99 0.49% $ Difference $-0.55 $-1.15 $-2.39 $-1.73 %Difference -2.15% -6.14%-10.59% -6.18% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 61 of 98 APPENDIX 5 METER READER Index Tab 162 - METER READER Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for reading water meters. Assist with turnons and turnoffs and perform minor meter maintenance. Assist with customer service related jobs such as connecting and disconnecting water meters. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 1-6 Months Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required W/S Services - Meter (430) Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid Drivers License City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $17.66 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 $17.66 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $23.29 $20.01 $24.32 $29.58 $22.13 $19.01 $23.10 $28.10 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $17.75 $15.66 $19.58 $23.49 $17.75 $15.66 $19.58 $23.49 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $20.31 $16.22 $20.28 $24.34 $20.31 $16.22 $20.28 $24.34 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $18.25 $16.07 $20.09 $24.11 $18.25 $16.07 $20.09 $24.11 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $19.45 $16.57 $20.59 $24.79 $19.22 1 $16.37 1 $20.34 1 $24.49 0.50% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $17.90 115.71 $1E3 523.47 0.49% $ Difference $-1.31 $-0.66 $-1.41 $-1.02 %Difference -7.37% -4.20% -7.45% -4.35% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 62 of 98 APPENDIX 5 NETWORK ANALYST Index Tab 163-NETWORK ANALYST ff Job Description and Qualifications: Maintain and administer the Local Area Network (LAN) and Wide Area Network (WAN). Install and configure routing and switching devices. Administer and maintain the Voice Over IP (VoIP) Telephony system including upgrades, call handlers, adds, moves and changes, etc. Manage all wireless devices/services. Education FLSA High School Plus Specialized Schooling Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 7 Years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required IT Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid Drivers license. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $31.84 $26.75 $33.44 $40.12 $31.84 $26.75 $33.44 $40.12 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $32.19 $24.76 $30.95 $38.64 $32.83 $25.26 $31.57 $39.41 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $35.99 $35.11 $42.68 $51.91 $34.19 $33.35 $40.55 $49.31 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $31.78 $27.67 $34.58 $43.23 $31.78 $27.67 $34.58 $43.23 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $33.20 $28.37 $35.46 $42.56 $33.20 $28.37 $35.46 $42.56 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $34.62 $27.58 $34.47 $41.36 $34.62 $27.58 $34.47 $41.36 0.50% Corn ata Match $33.56 $26.73 $33.41 $40.09 $33.56 $26.73 $33.41 $40.09 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $35.37 $28.49 $35.61 $42.73 $35.37 $28.49 $35.61 $42.73 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $32.73 $26.58 $33.22 $39.86 $32.73 $26.58 $33.22 $39.86 0.50% Averages Match $33.48 $28.00 $34.87 $42.28 $33.35 $27.86 $34.70 $42.08 0.51% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 531.65 527.11 532.66 140.50 0.49% 1%Difference 1 -5.37% 1 -2.77% 1 -6.25% 1 -3.90% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 63 of 98 APPENDIX 5 NETWORK ENGINEER Index Tab 164 - NETWORK ENGINEER Job Description and Qualifications: Design, analyze, implement and maintain LAN/WAN systems for optimal data integrity, reliability and speed. Troubleshoot network, server, user management and other computer related problems. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or B.S./ B.A. related field Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 10 years or 5 years with BS/BA Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Information Technologies (370) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $37.94 $26.98 $36.46 $45.94 $37.94 $26.98 $36.46 $45.94 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $53.53 $44.04 $53.53 $65.11 $50.85 $41.84 $50.85 $61.85 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $43.01 $34.59 $43.23 $54.04 $43.01 $34.59 $43.23 $54.04 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $47.78 $38.05 $47.56 $57.07 $47.78 $38.05 $47.56 $57.07 0.50% Compdata Match $46.49 $37.03 $46.29 $55.55 $46.49 $37.03 $46.29 $55.55 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $43.60 $33.89 $42.36 $50.83 $43.60 $33.89 $42.36 $50.83 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $41.61 $32.26 $40.33 $48.40 $41.61 $32.26 $40.33 $48.40 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 9.39% 1 -6.33% 1-10.78% 1 -8.72% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 64 of 98 APPENDIX 5 OPERATIONS ASSISTANT - TRANSPORTATION Index Tab 165 - OPERATIONS ASSISTANT - TRANSPORTATION Job Description and Qualifications: Provide customer service by handling telephone calls, greeting visitors, and dispatching requests of service. Data entry of daily work orders and maintenance of databases. Respond to communication from public and internal sources; input and monitor service requests. Obtain quotes, prepare payment requests, submit purchase requisitions, procurement card requests, and place orders for materials and supplies. Reconciliation of procurement card purchases. Maintain office supplies, check -in deliveries, and coordinate the loaning of equipment to various activity groups. Assist with Division Safety Program. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 1 year Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Transportation Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $18.34 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 $18.34 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $28.45 $18.23 $22.79 $28.45 $29.02 $18.59 $23.25 $29.02 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $22.86 $20.01 $24.32 $29.58 $21.72 $19.01 $23.10 $28.10 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $19.76 $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 $19.76 $15.56 $19.44 $24.31 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $20.35 $16.21 $20.26 $24.31 $20.35 $16.21 $20.26 $24.31 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $20.01 $16.46 $20.57 $24.68 $20.01 $16.46 $20.57 $24.68 0.50% Averages Match $21.63 $16.90 $21.01 $25.63 $21.53 $16.79 1 $20.88 1 $25.48 1 0.52% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 519.47 515.71 518.93 523.47 0.49% $ Difference $-2.06 $-1.08 $-1.95 $-2.00 %Difference-10.58% -6.87%-10.30% -8.52% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 65 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PARK OPERATIONS DIRECTOR Index Tab 166 - PARK OPERATIONS DIRECTOR iiiiiii Job Description and Qualifications: Plan, administer and supervise Parks Operations Division. This work includes oversight of programs for ground and trail maintenance, athletic fields, turf grass, urban forestry, horticulture, public lands, swimming pool, park facilities and capital improvements. Education FLSA B.S./.B.A degree in related field Related Experience 4 years Exempt Supervisory Position Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Park Operations (658) Certificates & Licenses National Playground Safety Inspection Certification, Certified Pool Operator within 2 years City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $50.90 $33.26 $44.95 $56.63 $50.90 $33.26 $44.95 $56.63 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $56.23 $44.04 $56.21 $65.11 $53.42 $41.84 $53.40 $61.85 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $50.25 $36.89 $46.12 $57.64 $50.25 $36.89 $46.12 $57.64 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Less $34.92 $30.20 $37.75 $45.30 $34.92 $30.20 $37.75 $45.30 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $51.22 $39.31 $49.14 $58.97 $51.22 $39.31 $49.14 $58.97 0.50% Compdata Match $49.73 $38.95 $48.69 $58.43 $49.73 $38.95 $48.69 $58.43 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $49.79 $37.84 $47.30 $56.76 $49.79 $37.84 $47.30 $56.76 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $48.83 $36.12 $45.15 $54.18 $48.83 $36.12 $45.15 $54.18 0.50% Averages Match $48.98 $37.08 $46.91 $56.63 $48.63 $36.80 $46.56 $56.22 CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 552.83 536.71 144.23 554.85 49% 1%Difference 1 7.95% 1 -0.25% 1 -5.27% 1 -2.50% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 66 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PARK PLANNING SUPERINTENDENT Index Tab 167- PARK PLANNING SUPERINTENDENT Job Description and Qualifications: Perform project management duties on assigned capital improvement projects (CIP) including park improvement and expansion projects, development of new and improved community facilities, and trail development. Education FLSA Bachelor's degree (B.A. or B.S.) in Landscape Architecture or Engineering Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 6 years Supervisory Management Experience Department Ell 2 years Parks(120) Certificates & Licenses Arkansas Landscape Architect®license or Professional Engineer®license City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $38.63 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 $38.63 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $46.21 $36.16 $46.15 $53.45 $43.90 $34.35 $43.84 $50.78 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $38.87 $29.97 $37.47 $46.83 $38.87 $29.97 $37.47 $46.83 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS-NWA Match $42.41 $30.22 $37.77 $45.32 $42.41 $30.22 $37.77 $45.32 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $42.56 $30.78 $38.48 $46.18 $42.56 $30.78 $38.48 $46.18 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $42.26 $31.86 $40.40 $48.82 i $41.27 1 $31.09 $39.65 1 $48.08 1 0.53% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $46.03 530.95 537.29 $46.24 0.49% $ Difference $4.76 $-0.14 $-2.36 4 %Difference 10.34% -0.45% -6.33% -3.11$-1.8. Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 67 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER Index Tab 168- PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER Job Description and Qualifications: Enforce laws, codes and city ordinance requirements for parking regulations. Inspect Downtown and Entertainment Districts for violations of various City codes including: parking regulations and compliance, residential parking ordinances, traffic regulations related to parking and pedestrian safety. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 1 year Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Parking (450) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $21.77 $18.33 $22.91 $27.49 $21.77 $18.33 $22.91 $27.49 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $23.18 $18.75 $23.93 $27.73 $22.02 $17.81 $22.73 $26.34 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $20.99 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 $20.99 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $21.61 $17.71 $22.14 $26.57 $21.61 $17.71 $22.14 $26.57 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $22.24 $18.10 $22.63 $27.16 $22.24 $18.10 $22.63 $27.16 0.50% Averages Match 1 $21.96 $18.15 $22.79 $27.37 $21.73 $17.96 1 $22.55 1 $27.09 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 521.61 $18.73 522.57 527.99 0.49% $ Difference $-0.12 $0.77 $0.02 $0.90 %Difference -0.56% 4.1T 0.09% 3.221. Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 68 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PERMIT COORDINATOR Index Tab 169- PERMIT COORDINATOR 1111111 Job Description and Qualifications: Primary responsibility for management and efficiency of the commercial and multi -review building permit program. Communicate with contractors and other customers the permit requirements for multi -review projects, verify that applications and attachments are complete and enter information into database. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience 2 years Supervisory Position Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Building Safety (220) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $19.10 $16.08 $20.10 $24.99 $19.10 $16.08 $20.10 $24.99 0.55% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $20.54 $19.10 $23.88 $29.81 $20.95 $19.48 $24.36 $30.41 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.64 $20.63 $25.07 $30.49 $26.26 $19.60 $23.82 $28.97 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $21.01 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 $21.01 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $16.98 $15.09 $18.87 $22.64 $16.98 $15.09 $18.87 $22.64 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $20.71 $17.44 $21.80 $26.16 $20.71 $17.44 $21.80 $26.16 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $20.82 $16.46 $20.57 $24.68 $20.82 1 $16.46 $20.57 $24.68 0.50% i Averages i Match $20.97 $17.69 $22.01 $26.93 $20.83 $17.60 $21.90 1 $26.79 0.52% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 119.53 $16.72 $20.15 524.99 0.49% $ Difference $-1.30 $-0.88 $-1.75 $-1.80 %Difference -6.66% -5.26% -8.68% -7.20% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 69 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PLANNER Index Tab 170-PLANNER Job Description and Qualifications: Prepare and present staff recommendations and reports regarding development within the City's jurisdiction at public meetings. Present projects to various committees, the Planning Commission and City Council. Conduct research on planning policy issues and best practices. Education FLSA B.A. or B.S. in a related field Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Planning (230) Certificates & Licenses AICP Certification preferred City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $25.18 $21.70 $27.12 $32.54 $25.18 $21.70 $27.12 $32.54 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $31.99 $24.96 $31.87 $36.91 $30.39 $23.71 $30.28 $35.06 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $29.64 $25.36 $31.70 $39.62 $29.64 $25.36 $31.70 $39.62 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $20.42 $18.76 $23.97 $29.51 $20.42 $18.76 $23.97 $29.51 0.57% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $29.06 $23.63 $29.54 $35.45 $29.06 $23.63 $29.54 $35.45 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $29.58 $23.09 $28.86 $34.63 $29.58 $23.09 $28.86 $34.63 0.50% Averages Match $27.64 1 $22.92 1 $28.84 1 $34.78 1 $27.38 1 $22.71 1 $28.58 1 $34.47 1 0.52% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $27.89 $22.75 $27.41 $33.99 t--2"49% $ Difference $0.51 $0.04 $-1.17 $-0.48 Difference 1 1.83% 1 0.18% 1 -4.27% 1 -1.41% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 70 of 98 APPENDIX 5 POLICE CAPTAIN Index Tab 171-POLICE CAPTAIN Job Description and Qualifications: Under the direction of the Deputy Chief, the incumbent is responsible for the daily operational functions of the City's Police Department. Assist the Deputy Chief in the planning, coordination, supervision, and evaluation of police department operations. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Exempt Related Experience 9 -10 years Supervisory Position Supervisory Management Experience Department 5 years Police (600) Certificates & Licenses Certified Law Enforcement Officer, ACIC and NCIC City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $58.09 $34.52 $44.85 $55.18 $58.09 $34.52 $44.85 $55.18 0.60% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $43.85 $36.22 $38.26 $42.99 $44.73 $36.94 $39.03 $43.85 0.19% City of Lawrence, KS Match $64.89 $50.21 $64.09 $74.23 $61.65 $47.70 $60.89 $70.52 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $54.39 $46.12 $57.65 $72.06 $54.39 $46.12 $57.65 $72.06 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match 1 $58.60 $41.78 $51.05 $62.66 $58.60 1 $41.78 $51.05 $62.66 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $59.89 $43.59 $54.49 $65.39 $59.89 $43.59 $54.49 $65.39 0.50% Compdata Match $58.15 $42.29 $52.86 $63.43 $58.15 $42.29 $52.86 Lill 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $64.02 $46.56 $58.20 $69.84 $64.02 $46.56 $58.20 $69.84 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 9.20% 1 0.28% 1 -2.15% 1 1.13% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.48% 0.49% Page 71 of 98 APPENDIX 5 POLICE CHIEF Index Tab 172 - POLICE CHIEF Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for planning, organizing and directing activities of the Fayetteville Police Department to ensure effective enforcement of laws and ordinances. The Police Chief performs the functions and duties specified and set forth by City ordinance and civil service rules and regulations, as well as conduct responsibilities pursuant to state statues and other related work as required under the general direction of the Mayor and City Council. Law enforcement procedures, state and federal laws and department policy and procedures govern this position. Education FLSA B.S./B.A. Degree in Criminal Justice or related field Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 11 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 9 years Police (600) Certificates & Licenses Advanced Law Enforcement Management or Executive Development Schooling, such as UofA Criminal Justice Institute, FBI National Academy, Police Executive Research Forum or Senior Management Institute City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $64.39 $43.34 $56.34 $69.33 $64.39 $43.34 $56.34 $69.33 0.60% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $60.10 $48.97 $52.03 $57.32 $61.30 $49.95 $53.07 $58.47 0.17% City of Lawrence, KS Match $80.54 $69.57 $86.69 $102.86 $76.51 $66.09 $82.36 $97.72 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $71.83 $55.35 $69.18 $75.90 $71.83 $55.35 $69.18 $75.90 0.37% City of Springdale, AR Match $69.75 $48.52 $60.65 $72.78 $69.75 $48.52 $60.65 $72.78 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $76.39 $58.20 $72.75 $87.30 $76.39 $58.20 $72.75 $87.30 0.50% NOARK 2023 i Averages i Match 1 $71.25 $54.49 $67.20 $79.18 $70.03 $53.58 1 $65.72 1 $76.92 0.45% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 175.77 $50.80 $61.21 $75.90 0.49% $ Difference $5.74 $-2.78 $-4.51 $-1.02 %Difference 7.58% -5.47% -1.34% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 72 of 98 APPENDIX 5 POLICE SUPPORT SPECIALIST Index Tab 173 - POLICE SUPPORT SPECIALIST Job Description and Qualifications: Effectively interview citizens (some are very upset), both in person and over the phone, to determine if a crime was committed. Document crimes against persons and/or property. Take photographs of evidence and collect evidence. Submit evidence as required. Transcribe and code report utilizing proper crime reporting protocol. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position < 1 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Police (650) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $21.77 $17.20 $21.50 $25.80 $21.77 $17.20 $21.50 $25.80 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $23.12 $18.75 $23.93 $27.73 $21.96 $17.81 $22.73 $26.34 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $22.60 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 $22.60 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Less $17.98 $16.92 $21.15 $25.39 $17.98 $16.92 $21.15 $25.39 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $21.80 $17.74 $22.17 $26.60 $21.80 $17.74 $22.17 $26.60 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $21.12 $17.78 $22.23 $26.68 $21.12 $17.78 $22.23 $26.68 0.50% Averages Match $21.40 $17.71 $22.22 $26.68 $21.21 $17.55 $22.02 $26.45 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 519.09 $17.72 521.35 526.47 0.49% $ Difference $-2.12 $0.17 $-0.67 $0.02 %Difference-11.11% 0.96% 4% 0.08% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 73 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PROJECT COORDINATOR - UTILITIES Index Tab 174- PROJECT COORDINATOR - UTILITIES Job Description and Qualifications: Maintain a current knowledge of all Utilities Department capital projects and subprojects, services, issues and community events to provide information to callers and visitors. Write Requests for Proposals, contracts and contract specifications for capital projects. Apply strict attention to detail in writing and reviewing such documents. Create forecasting spreadsheets to include formulas and trends; utilize this information to develop realistic timelines for capital projects. Education FLSA 4 Years College Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 4 Years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department 1-6 Months W&S Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver's License City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $25.65 $20.57 $25.71 $30.85 $25.65 $20.57 $25.71 $30.85 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.51 $22.69 $28.95 $33.54 $26.13 $21.56 $27.50 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $25.95 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 $25.95 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $25.93 $20.82 $26.03 $31.24 $25.93 $20.82 $26.03 $31.24 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $25.34 $20.45 $25.56 $30.67 $25.34 $20.45 $25.56 $30.67 0.50% i Averages i Match $26.08 $20.94 $26.29 $31.56 $25.80 $20.71 $26.00 $31.23 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 525.69 $20.74 $24.99 $30.99 0.49% $ Difference $-0.11 $0.03 $-1.01 $-0.24 %Difference -0.43% 0.14% -4.04% -0.77% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 74 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PROPERTY - EVIDENCE MANAGER Index Tab 175- PROPERTY -EVIDENCE MANAGER Job Description and Qualifications: Respond after hours to manage intake of large items, large quantities, or other items of evidence requiring special handling. Ensure an accurate chain of custody (both hard and electronic copy) that contains the signatures of all parties controlling the piece of property or evidence from intake to disposal. Education H.S. Diploma or GED xempt Related Experience isory Position 3 years isory rDepartment Management Experience 2 years (650) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $29.51 $22.53 $28.53 $34.23 $29.51 $22.53 $28.53 $34.23 0.52% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $31.89 $27.45 $33.36 $40.58 $30.30 $26.08 $31.69 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $30.17 $22.48 $28.09 $35.12 $30.17 $22.48 $28.09 $35.12 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Less $20.07 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 $20.07 $17.84 $22.30 $26.76 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $31.45 $22.89 $28.61 $34.33 $31.45 $22.89 $28.61 $34.33 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $30.62 $23.62 $29.53 $35.44 $30.62 $23.62 $29.53 $35.44 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $28.95 $22.80 $28.40 $34.41 i $28.69 1 $22.57 1 $28.13 1 $34.07 1 0.51% 1 Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 533.99 $22.75 M2lt 533.99 0.49% $ Difference $5.30 $0.18 $-0.72 $-0.08 %Difference 15.59% 0.79% -2.63% -0.24% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 75 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR Index Tab 176 - PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for management of in-house engineering design services consisting of surveying, drafting, design, bidding and construction management of public works projects for various divisions and departments. Evaluate the performance of assigned Public Works divisions and recommend changes to improve efficiency. Monitor the delivery of municipal services through assigned division heads to ensure that the Mayor and City Council®objectives, policies, and adopted Master Plans are followed. Education FLSA Bachelor's in Engineering Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 10 Years Supervisory Management Experience Department 7 Years Public Works Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $75.72 $45.82 $61.92 $78.02 $75.72 $45.82 $61.92 $78.02 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $88.60 $69.57 $86.69 $102.86 $84.17 $66.09 $82.36 $97.72 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $63.72 $48.43 $60.53 $75.67 $63.72 $48.43 $60.53 $75.67 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Less $52.78 $41.19 $51.49 $61.79 $52.78 $41.19 $51.49 $61.79 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $73.86 $56.27 $70.34 $84.41 $73.86 $56.27 $70.34 $84.41 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $69.10 $54.45 $68.06 $81.67 $69.10 $54.45 $68.06 $81.67 0.509/o Averages Match of Favetteville, AR Match .03 75 $ Difference $1.97 $-3.29 %Difference 2.74% -6.75% 565.78 1 579.88 1 0.53% $58.73 $72.83 $-7.05 $-7.05 -12.00% -9.68% M a rket Ave rage Hourly Rates and M a rket Ave rage Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 76 of 98 APPENDIX 5 PW PROJECTS INSPECTOR Index Tab 177-PW PROJECTS INSPECTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Perform visual site inspections of construction projects. Perform pressure and leakage testing of waterlines. Perform low pressure air test on sanitary sewer mains and vacuum test manholes. Inspect Storm Water Management and Erosion Control. Inspect street subgrade preparation and compaction testing. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position IMF- 4 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Engineering(110) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $24.69 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 $24.69 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.31 $22.69 $27.57 $33.54 $25.94 $21.56 $26.19 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $23.93 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 $23.93 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $29.29 $23.74 $29.67 $35.60 $29.29 $23.74 $29.67 $35.60 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $23.23 $18.54 $23.18 $27.82 $23.23 $18.54 $23.18 $27.82 0.50% Averages Match of Favetteville, AR Match 1.51 73 $ Difference 73 $-1.96 Difference -7.30,-10.46% 525.71 1 531.17 1 0.51% $22.57 $27.99 $-3.14 $-3.18 -13.91%-11.36% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 77 of 98 APPENDIX 5 RECREATION PROGRAMS MANAGER Index Tab 178 - RECREATION PROGRAMS MANAGER Job Description and Qualifications: Provide program and event management, customer service, general facility supervision of adult and youth athletic programs and camps, summer concert series and City pool. Plan and implement assigned programs. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED, BS/BA Degree in P & R Admin. Preferred Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 4 years Supervisory Management Experience Department Parks (120) Certificates & Licenses Certified Pool Operator CPR and First Aid City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $27.09 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 $27.09 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $20.70 $19.10 $23.88 $29.81 $21.11 $19.48 $24.36 $30.41 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $35.32 $27.45 $35.03 $40.58 $33.55 $26.08 $33.28 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $31.53 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 $31.53 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $23.70 $23.33 $29.17 $35.00 $23.70 $23.33 $29.17 $35.00 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $28.48 $23.12 $28.90 $34.68 $28.48 $23.12 $28.90 $34.68 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $28.45 $22.94 $28.68 $34.42 1 $28.45 $22.94 $28.68 $34.42 0.50% Averages Match $27.90 $23.20 $29.10 $35.09 $27.70 $23.06 $28.92 $34.89 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 527.12 523.76 $288 3 535.50 0.49% $ Difference $-0.58 $ $-0.29 $0.61 %Difference -2.14% 2.95% -1.01% T72% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 78 of 98 APPENDIX 5 RECREATION SUPERINTENDENT Index Tab 179- RECREATION SUPERINTENDENT Job Description and Qualifications: Education Responsible for planning, developing, promoting, supervising and evaluating a comprehensive recreation program for Parks and Recreation. Oversee recreation staff, programs and Community Center. FLSA B.S./.B.A degree in related field Exempt Related Experience 4 years Supervisory Position Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Parks(120) Certificates & Licenses Certified Parks and Recreation Professional, CPR and First Aid City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $38.63 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 $38.63 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $40.69 $35.11 $44.81 $51.91 $38.66 $33.35 $42.57 $49.31 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $40.73 $29.97 $37.47 $46.83 $40.73 $29.97 $37.47 $46.83 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $26.34 $30.20 $37.75 $45.30 $26.34 $30.20 $37.75 $45.30 0.50% CompAnalyst Match $44.14 $34.25 $42.81 $51.37 $44.14 $34.25 $42.81 $51.37 0.50% Compdata Match $43.86 $33.29 $41.61 $49.93 $43.86 $33.29 $41.61 $49.93 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $40.08 $30.45 $38.06 $45.67 $40.08 $30.45 $38.06 $45.67 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $40.36 $30.61 $38.26 $45.91 $40.36 $30.61 $38.26 $45.91 0.50% Averages Match $39.35 $31.75 $40.18 $48.52 $39.10 $31.53 $39.90 $48.20 0.53% CitvofFavetteville.AR Match 546.24 530.95 537.29 546.24 0.49% 1%Difference 1 15.44% 1 -1.87% 1 -7.00% 1 -4.24% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 79 of 98 APPENDIX 5 RECYCLING TRASH COLLECTIONS OPERATIONS MANAGER Index Tab 180 - RECYCLING & TRASH COLLECTIONS OPERATIONS MANAGER Job Description and Qualifications: Manage and supervise day to day operations of the Recycling and Trash Collections Division which includes collection, disposal, transfer, and recycling operations. Ensure all routes are completed as scheduled and all waste is properly removed at the end of each day. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma/ GED Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 8 years Supervisory Management Experience F Department 5 years Solid Waste (140) Certificates & Licenses Class B CDL within 120 day, Solid Waste Management Facility Operators License Levels 2C and 3C within 6 months City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $38.11 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 $38.11 $30.12 $40.70 $51.28 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $38.92 $36.16 $45.05 $53.45 $36.97 $34.35 $42.80 $50.78 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $40.67 $29.97 $37.47 $46.83 $40.67 $29.97 $37.47 $46.83 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $39.94 $30.74 $38.42 $46.10 $39.94 $30.74 $38.42 $46.10 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $39.02 $30.61 $38.26 $45.91 $39.02 $30.61 $38.26 $45.91 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $39.21 $31.13 $39.33 $47.72 i $38.94 1 $31.16 1 $39.53 1 $48.18 1 0.53% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 118.18 $30.95 537.29 $46.24 0.49% $ Difference $-0.76 $-0.21 $-1 1.4 $-1.94 %Difference -1.99% -0.68% -6.01% -4.20% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 80 of 98 APPENDIX 5 RESIDENTIAL PLANS EXAMINER Index Tab 181 - RESIDENTIAL PLANS EXAMINER Job Description and Qualifications: Assist supervisor with interpretation of codes ordinances and applicable laws for residential and non-residential building inspectors. Understand and perform duties of permitting technicians and building inspectors. Coordinate inspection criteria with P PP g P P P g g P P 1 site construction supervisor and inspectors to determine compliance. Organize and file plans, specifications, and related documents through the review, construction, and archiving processes. Prepare detailed reports and document inspection activity Education FLSA High School diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Building Safety (626) Certificates & Licenses valid Driver®License. Ability to obtain International Code Council (ICC) certification as a Residential Inspector and Residential Plans Examiner within two years of hire date. Obtain Arkansas State Plumbing, Mechanical, and Electrical Inspector licenses within one year of hire date. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $24.98 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 $24.98 $20.57 $25.72 $30.86 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $30.26 $24.96 $30.35 $36.91 $28.75 $23.71 $28.83 $35.06 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $24.28 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 $24.28 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $36.18 $25.17 $31.46 $37.75 $36.18 $25.17 $31.46 $37.75 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $25.65 $20.77 $25.96 $31.15 $25.65 $20.77 $25.96 $31.15 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $25.55 $20.40 $25.50 $30.60 $25.55 $20.40 $25.50 $30.60 0.509/o Averages Match $27.82 1 $22.01 1 $27.37 1 $33.13 1 $27.56 1 $21.80 1 $27.11 1 $32.82 1 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 1 $24.48 $20.74 $24.99 $30.99 f---2.49% $ Difference a $-3.08 $-1.06 $-2.12 $-1.83 Difference1 -12.58% 1 -5.11% 1 -8.48% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 81 of 98 APPENDIX 5 ROUTE DRIVER Index Tab 182-ROUTE DRIVER Job Description and Qualifications: Operate a variety of equipment and trucks to assist in the day-to-day collection of trash and recycling on assigned routes. Perform pre and post trip inspections on a daily basis. Collect and separate recyclable items. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 1 year Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Solid Waste (140) Certificates & Licenses Class "B" CDL within 120 days City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $21.40 $17.20 $21.50 $25.80 $21.40 $17.20 $21.50 $25.80 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $19.07 $15.52 $19.40 $24.22 $19.45 $15.83 $19.79 $24.70 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.69 $20.68 $25.13 $30.57 $26.31 $19.65 $23.87 $29.04 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $22.16 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 $22.16 $17.86 $22.33 $27.91 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $23.08 $17.62 $22.03 $26.44 $23.08 $17.62 $22.03 $26.44 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $23.53 $18.19 $22.74 $27.29 $23.53 $18.19 $22.74 $27.29 0.50% Averages Match $22.82 $17.85 $22.19 $27.04 $22.65 1 $17.72 $22.04 $26.86 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AIR Match $22.00 $11.72 $20.15 524.99 0.49% $ Difference $-0.65 $-1.00 $-1.89 $-1.87 %Difference -2.95. -5.98% -9.38% -7.48% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 82 of 98 APPENDIX 5 ROUTE SUPERVISOR Index Tab 183- ROUTE SUPERVISOR Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for training and supervising drivers performing collection and processing duties. Perform route audits to improve efficiency. Respond to service requests. Investigate accidents and injuries and complete necessary reports. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Supervisory Management Experience Department Solid Waste (140) Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid Commercial Driver® License, class B. Solid Waste management Facility Operator License Class 3A within one year City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $26.86 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 $26.86 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $27.05 $23.02 $28.77 $35.92 $27.59 $23.48 $29.35 $36.64 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $33.38 $27.45 $33.36 $40.58 $31.71 $26.08 $31.69 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $25.92 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 $25.92 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $27.73 $19.97 $24.96 $29.95 $27.73 $19.97 $24.96 $29.95 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $26.98 $21.07 $26.34 $31.61 $26.98 $21.07 $26.34 $31.61 0.50% i Averages i Match $27.99 $21.86 $27.16 $33.12 $27.80 $21.70 $26.98 $32.90 0.52% City of Favetteville, AIR Match 526.78 IN 74 122 78 529.49 0.49% $ Difference $-1.02 $-1.96 $-3.20 $-3.41 %Difference -3.81% -9.93%-13.46%-11.56% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 83 of 98 APPENDIX 5 SENIOR ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT - MAYORS OFFICE Index Tab 184- SENIOR ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT - MAYORS OFFICE Job Description and Qualifications: Handle administrative and record keeping requirements for P-card transactions, purchase orders and check requests for assigned department directors and Mayor. Manage travel arrangements including accounting and record -keeping functions for assigned directors and Mayor. Respond and research difficult citizen complaints and provide proper follow-up. Use judgment and tact to assist in routing visitors and callers to the appropriate division or individual. Maintain a current knowledge of all city projects, services, issues and community events to provide information to callers and visitors. Develop and maintain files and record keeping systems for department directors. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Mayor's Office (564) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $26.96 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 $26.96 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $28.06 $22.69 $28.95 $33.54 $26.66 $21.56 $27.50 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $28.92 $21.32 $26.65 $33.32 $28.92 $21.32 $26.65 $33.32 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $32.34 $26.54 $33.17 $39.81 $32.34 $26.54 $33.17 $39.81 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $30.79 $23.46 $29.32 $35.18 $30.79 $23.46 $29.32 $35.18 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $27.36 $21.35 $26.69 $32.03 $27.36 $21.35 $26.69 $32.03 0.509/o i Averages i Match 1 $29.07 $22.47 $28.18 $33.84 i $28.84 1 $22.28 1 $27.94 1 $33.56 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 530.69 $18.73 $22.57 527.99 0.49% $ Difference $1.85 -$3.55 -$5.37 -$5.57 Difference 6.03%-18.95%-23.79% -19.90 o Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 84 of 98 APPENDIX 5 SENIOR PLANNER Index Tab 185-SENIOR PLANNER Job Description and Qualifications: Review development and zoning proposals. Review building permits for commercial, multi -family, and certain single family structures. Provide development proposal responses. Prepare and present staff recommendations and reports. Assist in neighborhood planning, revitalization and preservation activities. Prepare maps, drawings and other graphics. Identify, analyze and solve problems in support of group, department, and organization objectives; consider cause and effect among different Education FLSA B.S./.B.A degree in related field Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 3 years Supervisory Management Experience Department Prefer project management or supervisory experience Planning (525) Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver®License AICP Certification preferred City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $34.37 $26.98 $36.46 $45.94 $34.37 $26.98 $36.46 $45.94 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $22.41 $20.84 $26.05 $32.53 $22.86 $21.26 $26.57 $33.18 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $37.44 $31.35 $38.12 $46.36 $35.57 $29.78 $36.21 $44.04 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $34.25 $29.97 $37.47 $46.83 $34.25 $29.97 $37.47 $46.83 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $37.36 $23.33 $31.46 $61.79 $37.36 $23.33 $31.46 $61.79 1.65% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $31.01 $24.03 $30.04 $36.05 $31.01 $24.03 $30.04 $36.05 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $33.00 $26.25 $32.81 $39.37 $33.00 $26.25 $32.81 $39.37 0.50% i Averages i Match $32.92 $26.33 $33.35 $43.35 i $32.63 $25.94 $33.00 $43.89 0.65% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 530.91 525.66 530.91 538.33 0.49% $ Difference $-1.72 $-0.28 $-2.09 5-5.56 Difference -5.56% -1.09% -6.76%-14.51% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 85 of 98 APPENDIX 5 SENIOR POLICE SUPPORT SPECIALIST Index Tab 186 - SENIOR POLICE SUPPORT SPECIALIST Job Description and Qualifications: Provide training for Police Support Specialist in all aspects of theirjob. Complete Weekly Observation Reports (WOR) to document trainee progress and recommend when a trainee completes, continues, or terminates from the training program. Provide leadership and mentor role on assigned shift. Provide excellent customer service with the ability to effectively de-escalate upset and/or angry citizens in a friendly manner in person and/or over the phone. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 Years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Police Civilian Certificates & Licenses Ability to obtain ACIC Basic Certification within three months of hire and Advanced Certification within six months of hire. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $24.12 $18.33 $22.91 $27.49 $24.12 $18.33 $22.91 $27.49 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $27.25 $21.25 $27.12 $31.42 $25.89 $20.19 $25.76 $29.85 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $25.80 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 $25.80 $20.17 $25.21 $31.51 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $23.59 $20.59 $29.17 $37.75 $23.59 $20.59 $29.17 $37.75 0.83% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $25.17 $19.51 $24.39 $29.27 $25.17 $19.51 $24.39 $29.27 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $25.34 $19.56 $24.45 $29.34 $25.34 $19.56 $24.45 $29.34 0.50% i Averages i Match $25.21 $19.90 $25.54 $31.13 $24.98 $19.72 1 $25.32 $30.87 0.56% Citv of Favetteville, AIR Match $24.32 $19.74 $23.78 529.49 0.49% $ Difference dPlII$-0.66 $0.02 $-1.54 $-1.38 Difference -2.71% 0.10% -6.48% -4.68% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 86 of 98 APPENDIX 5 SENIOR PURCHASING AGENT Index Tab 187- SENIOR PURCHASING AGENT Job Description and Qualifications: electronic procurement systems. Manage and establish competitive solicitation schedules to ensure successful project completion on a time) basis. Prepare complex and descriptive technical specifications, bid documents and contracts. Coordinate and P Y g P p l P Y p p p P assist departments in compiling information for request for proposals, bids, and request for qualifications; coordinate information to procure services, equipment, materials and supplies, and monitor preparation and distribution of proposals and bids to Education FLSA Associate's degree or Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 2 years Purchasing (604) Certificates & Licenses Valid Driver®License Obtain Certified Professional Purchasing Officer (CPPO) & Certified Professional Public Buyer (CPPB) within five years of hire date. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $28.90 $23.94 $29.93 $35.91 $28.90 $23.94 $29.93 $35.91 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $31.77 $27.45 $33.36 $40.58 $30.18 $26.08 $31.69 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $30.17 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 $30.17 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $32.77 $25.45 $31.81 $38.17 $32.77 $25.45 $31.81 $38.17 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $31.27 $24.71 $30.89 $37.07 $31.27 $24.71 $30.89 $37.07 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $31.10 1 $24.85 1 $30.93 1 $37.41 $30.66 $24.76 $30.77 $37.32 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 530.19 $24.70 529.76 536.90 0.49% $ Difference $-0.47 $-0.06 $-1.01 $-0.41 %Difference -1.16% -0.24% -3.39% -1.14% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 87 of 98 APPENDIX 5 SHELTER ATTENDANT Index Tab 188-SHELTER ATTENDANT NMI Job Description and Qualifications: Maintain and clean animal shelter facility. Feed and socialize with animals. Perform first level examinations and assist public with animal adoptions. Assist with animal medical procedures. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Animal Services (330) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $14.91 $13.83 $17.29 $20.74 $14.91 $13.83 $17.29 $20.74 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $15.30 $14.43 $18.04 $22.53 $15.61 $14.72 $18.40 $22.98 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $17.40 $15.78 $19.18 $23.34 $16.53 $14.99 $18.22 $22.17 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $15.60 $13.25 $16.56 $20.70 $15.60 $13.25 $16.56 $20.70 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $15.70 $15.09 $18.87 $22.64 $15.70 $15.09 $18.87 $22.64 0.50% DOL-BLS-NWA Match $16.29 $13.66 $17.07 $20.48 $16.29 $13.66 $17.07 $20.48 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $17.31 $13.88 $17.35 $20.82 $17.31 $13.88 $17.35 $20.82 0.50% Averages Match 1 $16.07 1 $14.27 1 $17.77 1 $21.61 1 $15.99 1 $14.20 1 $17.68 1 $21.50 1 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 1 1 $16.45 $13.86 $16.70 $20.71 f---2.49% $ Difference $0.46 $-0.34 $-0.98 $-0.79 Difference 1 2.80% 1 -2.45% 1 -5.87% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 88 of 98 APPENDIX 5 STAFFENGINEER- UNLICENSED Index Tab 189- STAFF ENGINEER -UNLICENSED Job Description and Qualifications: Design the necessary modifications and/or new construction of public works including water, sewer, drainage and street projects within City, County, State and Federal guidelines, under the guidance of a Staff Engineer. This task requires frequently solving problems requiring engineering knowledge and skills. Education FLSA Engineering Degree Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 1-6 Months Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Engr Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid Drivers License. Must have, or be eligible to applyfor, an Engineer Intern/Engineer-In-Training designation. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $30.81 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 $30.81 $22.82 $28.53 $34.23 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $66.42 $47.38 $59.23 $73.95 $67.75 $48.33 $60.41 $75.43 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $34.99 $26.63 $33.99 $39.37 $33.24 $25.30 $32.29 $37.40 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $31.73 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 $31.73 $23.63 $29.54 $36.92 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $36.63 $19.67 $40.04 $67.28 $36.63 $19.67 $40.04 $67.28 2.42% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $31.76 $23.63 $29.54 $35.45 $31.76 $23.63 $29.54 $35.45 NOARK 2023 Match $30.18 1 $23.32 $29.15 $34.98 1 $30.18 $23.32 $29.15 $34.98 0.50% Averages Match $37.50 $26.73 $35.72 $46.03 $37.44 $26.67 $35.64 $45.96 0.72% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $33.13 $22.75 $27.41 $33.99 0.49% $ Difference $-4.31 $-3.92 $-8.23 $-11.97 Difference1 -13.01%1 -17.23%1 -30.03%1 -35.22% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 89 of 98 APPENDIX 5 SURVEYOR Index Tab 90-SURVEYOR Job Description and Qualifications: Coordinate with engineers, land agents, drafters, trail coordinator and other departments for construction staking and property boundary needs. Verify the accuracy of survey data including measurements and calculations conducted at survey sites. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 10 Years with 4 of those years as a Registered Professional Surveyor Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department 2 Years Engr Certificates & Licenses Valid Drivers License. Must possess licensure as a State of Arkansas Registered Professional Surveyor, or have the ability to achieve reciprocal registration from another State within six months of hire date. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $33.51 $26.75 $33.44 $40.12 $33.51 $26.75 $33.44 $40.12 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $38.12 $31.35 $40.03 $46.36 $36.21 $29.78 $38.03 $44.04 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $35.90 $27.67 $34.58 $43.23 $35.90 $27.67 $34.58 $43.23 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $36.90 $28.89 $36.11 $43.33 $36.90 $28.89 $36.11 $43.33 0.50% Compdata Match $35.88 $28.00 $35.00 $42.00 $35.88 $28.00 $35.00 $42.00 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $35.74 $27.23 $34.04 $40.85 $35.74 $27.23 $34.04 $40.85 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $35.56 $27.80 $34.75 $41.70 $35.56 $27.80 $34.75 $41.70 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 11.93% 1 -3.36% 1 -7.59% 1 -4.15% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.51% 0.49% Page 90 of 98 APPENDIX 5 TECHNICAL SUPPORT SPECIALIST Index Tab 191- TECHNICAL SUPPORT SPECIALIST Job Description and Qualifications: Perform installation and troubleshooting of personal computers, virtual computers, tablet devices, desktop software, and peripheral devices. Expertise on operations and applications of City standard P.C.'s. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or B.S./ B.A. related field Non- Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years or 3 years with BS/BA Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Information Technologies (370) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $32.77 $25.07 $31.34 $37.60 $32.77 $25.07 $31.34 $37.60 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR Match $19.14 $18.23 $22.79 $28.45 $19.52 $18.59 $23.25 $29.02 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $29.36 $26.63 $33.99 $39.37 $27.89 $25.30 $32.29 $37.40 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $32.03 $25.36 $31.70 $39.62 $32.03 $25.36 $31.70 $39.62 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $23.18 $21.50 $26.88 $32.25 $23.18 $21.50 $26.88 $32.25 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $34.42 $26.24 $32.80 $39.36 $34.42 $26.24 $32.80 $39.36 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $32.29 $25.26 $31.57 $37.88 1 $32.29 $25.26 $31.57 $37.88 1 0.50% Averages Match $30.29 $24.75 $31.02 $37.36 $28.87 $23.90 $29.98 1 $36.16 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 532.89 $25.66 $30.91 M8.33 0.49% $ Difference $4.02 $1.76 $0.93 $2.17 %Difference 12.22% 6.86% 3.01% 5.66% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 91 of 98 APPENDIX 5 TRAFFIC SIGNAL AND SIGNAGE TECHNICIAN Index Tab 192- TRAFFIC SIGNAL AND SIGNAGE TECHNICIAN Job Description and Qualifications: Perform construction and installation of new traffic signals such as laying conduit, drilling, erecting poles and arms, signal pole footings, installing wire, wiring poles and cabinets, setting pull boxes and assembling. Maintain and repair existing signals and signal equipment; such as camera detection systems, inductive loops and detectors, radio system, railroad pre-emption, fire/optical pre-emption, signal wiring, controllers, conflict monitors. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 2 Years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required Transportation Certificates & Licenses Valid Drivers License. Must obtain IMSA Certifications, Work Zone Safety, Signs and Markings I, Traffic Signal I, Traffic Signal II certifications within 2 years of hire date. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $22.52 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 $22.52 $19.45 $24.31 $29.17 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR More $20.54 $19.10 $23.88 $29.81 $20.95 $19.48 $24.36 $30.41 0.56% City of Lawrence, KS Match $25.82 $20.63 $26.32 $30.49 $24.53 $19.60 $25.00 $28.97 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $23.88 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 $23.88 $19.02 $23.77 $29.71 0.56% City of Springdale, AR Match $27.50 $22.42 $28.02 $33.63 $27.50 $22.42 $28.02 $33.63 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $23.55 $22 $25.13 $30.16 $23.55 $20.10 $25.13 $30.16 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $24.51 $19.89 $24.86 $29.83 1 $24.51 $19.89 $24.86 $29.83 0.50% i Averages i Match $24.05 $20.09 $25.18 $30.40 $23.92 $19.99 $25.06 $30.27 0.51% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match $22.92 519.74 123.78 529.49 0.49% $ Difference $-1.00 $-0.25 $-1.28 $-0.78 %Difference -4.36% -1.27% -5.38% -2.64% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 92 of 98 APPENDIX 5 URBAN FORESTER Index Tab 193-URBAN FORESTER Job Description and Qualifications: Evaluate trees on public property for condition or hazard rating as needed. Make decisions on pruning or removal and replacement. Inspect tree protection fencing, signs and other tree protection devices prior to site work commencing. Conduct periodic inspections to ensure development is occurring in accordance with approved plans and is in compliance with the tree preservation and protection ordinance. Conduct final inspections at project completion for compliance with the approved tree preservation plan and landscape plan and verify all sureties are in place before issuing final certificate of occupancy. Education FLSA High School Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 8 Years Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Project Management Parks Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid Drivers License. Must be a current Certified Arborist with the International Society of Arboriculture or have the ability to meet requirements and obtain certification within 1 year of hire. Municipal Specialist Certification preferred. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $29.36 1 $21.70 $27.12 $32.54 $29.36 $21.70 $27.12 $32.54 1 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $26.95 $22.69 $28.95 $33.54 $25.60 $21.56 $27.50 $31.86 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $29.50 $22.48 $28.09 $35.12 $29.50 $22.48 $28.09 $35.12 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $29.52 $22.84 $28.55 $34.26 $29.52 $22.84 $28.55 $34.26 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $29.16 $23.02 $28.78 $34.54 $29.16 $23.02 $28.78 $34.54 0.50% Averages Match $28.90 $22.55 $28.30 $34.00 $28.63 $22.32 $28.01 $33.66 0.51% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 529.69 $22.75 527.41 533.99 0.49% $ Difference $1.06 $0.43 $-0.60 $0.33 %Difference 3.57% 1.59% -20.97% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 93 of 98 APPENDIX 5 UTILITIES ENGINEER Index Tab 94-UTILITIES ENGINEER Job Description and Qualifications: Ell Perform professional engineering work including but not limited to design, drafting, cost estimating, and developing contract documents, specifications and plans for various City departments including wastewater treatment and collection, water distribution and storage, emergency response and management, and items for other departments City-wide as needed. Design work includes design and inspection of facilities, specifications and submittals for compliance with City requirements and coordination of other engineering and operational functions, and regular field inspection of project sites. Education FLSA Bachelor®degree (B.A. or B.S.) in Civil or Environmental Engineering. Master's degree preferred Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 9 - 10 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 5 years Water & Sewer (160) Certificates & Licenses Professional Engineering License City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $47.30 $33.26 $44.95 $56.63 $47.30 $33.26 $44.95 $56.63 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $45.29 $39.32 $50.19 $58.14 $43.03 $37.35 $47.68 $55.23 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $49.75 $36.89 $46.12 $57.64 $49.75 $36.89 $46.12 $57.64 0.56% City of Springdale, AR CompAnalyst Match $53.35 $42.22 $52.77 $63.32 $53.35 $42.22 $52.77 $63.32 0.50% Compdata Match $52.27 $40.92 $51.15 $61.38 $52.27 $40.92 $51.15 $61.38 0.50% DOL- BLS -NWA Match $53.32 $38.78 $48.47 $58.16 $53.32 $38.78 $48.47 $58.16 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $50.58 $38.54 $48.17 $57.80 $50.58 $38.54 $48.17 $57.80 0.50% Match AR Match 1%Difference 1 2.38% 1 0.93% 1 -4.12% 1 -1.51% 1 Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) 0.53% 0.49% Page 94 of 98 APPENDIX 5 UTILITIES FINANCIAL SERVICES DIRECTOR Index Tab 195- UTILITIES FINANCIAL SERVICES DIRECTOR Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for periodic utility billing for water, sewer, recycling and trash and storm water utilities. Responsible for daily updates of all the City®web based payments, including parking, water, business licenses and accounts receivable. Coordinate with meter operations to create cyclical utility billing/penalty/cutoff calendars. Set yearly sewer averages. Provide information for the rate study development process for water and sewer utility rates. Education FLSA Associate's degree Prefer B.S. / B.A. Accounting and Finance Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years Utilities Financial Services (420) Certificates & Licenses City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $51.00 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 $51.00 $36.40 $49.19 $61.98 0.70% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $54.55 $44.04 $53.53 $65.11 $51.82 $41.84 $50.85 $61.85 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $55.39 $36.89 $46.12 $57.64 $55.39 $36.89 $46.12 $57.64 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $53.77 $39.10 $48.88 $58.66 $53.77 $39.10 $48.88 $58.66 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $51.49 $38.74 $48.42 $58.10 $51.49 $38.74 $48.42 $58.10 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $53.16 $39.86 $50.13 $61.04 $52.69 1 $38.59 1 $48.69 $59.65 0.53% Citv of Favetteville, AR Match NMI9 $38.64 $46.55 $57.72 0.49% $ Difference $-0.10 $0.05 $-1.14 $-1.93 %Difference -0.19% 0.13% -4.60% -3.34% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 95 of 98 APPENDIX 5 WAREHOUSE SUPERVISOR Index Tab 196- WAREHOUSE SUPERVISOR Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for reviewing bids and quotes as well as purchasing parts, supplies and equipment necessaryto maintain efficient and effective operations of the Water & Sewer warehouse inventory system. Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 12 years Supervisory Management Experience Department 1 year Water & Sewer (160) Certificates & Licenses Class A CDL with tanker endorsement within 6 months, Water License Grade IV Mistribution and Wastewater License Class I within 2 years. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $27.55 $21.70 $27.12 $32.54 $27.55 $21.70 $27.12 $32.54 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $29.75 $24.96 $30.35 $36.91 $28.26 $23.71 $28.83 $35.06 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $25.99 $21.32 $26.65 $33.32 $25.99 $21.32 $26.65 $33.32 0.56% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $27.73 $21.43 $26.79 $32.15 $27.73 $21.43 $26.79 $32.15 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $26.00 $20.43 $25.54 $30.65 $26.00 $20.43 $25.54 $30.65 0.50% i Averages i Match 1 $27.40 $21.97 $27.29 $33.11 i $27.11 1 $21.72 1 $26.99 1 $32.74 1 0.51% 1 Citv of Favetteville, AR Match 526.20 $21.75 126.20 M32 , 0.49% $ Difference $-0.91 $0.03 $-0.79 %Difference -3.47% 0.14% -3.02% -0.77% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 96 of 98 APPENDIX 5 WATER SEWER FIELD MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR Index Tab 197 - WATER & SEWER FIELD MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for overseeing water and sewer field operations. Prepare labor, material, time and equipment estimates for work performed in the complaints. area of assignment. Interact with utilities, public agencies and City departments in response to inquiries and Education FLSA H.S. Diploma or GED Exempt Related Experience Supervisory Position 5 years ]Water Supervisory Management Experience Department 3 years & Sewer (160) Certificates & Licenses Class A CDLwith Tanker Endorsement within 6 months, Water Distribution License Grade IV III and Class I Sewer License with 2 years City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $37.64 $28.99 $36.24 $43.49 $37.64 $28.99 $36.24 $43.49 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $35.46 $27.45 $35.03 $40.58 $33.69 $26.08 $33.28 $38.55 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $35.55 $28.95 $36.19 $43.43 $35.55 $28.95 $36.19 $43.43 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $35.51 $27.09 $33.86 $40.63 $35.51 $27.09 $33.86 $40.63 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $34.96 $27.07 $33.84 $40.61 $34.96 $27.07 $33.84 $40.61 0.50% Averages Match 1 $36.55 1 $28.56 1 $35.80 1 $42.75 $35.47 $27.64 $34.68 $41.34 0.50% City of Fayetteville, AR Match 535.24 527.11 $32.66 $40.50 0.49% $ Difference $-0.23 $-0.53 $-2.02 $-0.84 %Difference -0.65% -1.95% 118% -2.07% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 97 of 98 APPENDIX 5 WATER SEWER OPERATIONS CLERK Index Tab 198 - WATER & SEWER OPERATIONS CLERK Job Description and Qualifications: Responsible for providing clerical, administrative and secretarial support by assisting the department manager and other personnel by planning and organizing the day to day operations of the office. Respond to city and public calls to the division, perform crew and field service representative dispatching, process all Arkansas One Call requests. Education FLSA High School or GED Non -Exempt Related Experience 2 Years Supervisory Position Non -Supervisory Management Experience Department Not Required W&S Certificates & Licenses Must possess a valid Arkansas Driver's License. City Job Match Average Hourly Salary Salary Range Geo Adjusted Hourly Salary Geo Adjusted Salary Range Range Width Minimum Midpoint Maximum Minimum Midpoint Maximum City of Bentonville, AR Match $18.92 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 $18.92 $14.91 $18.67 $22.43 0.50% City of Jonesboro, AR City of Lawrence, KS Match $21.12 $18.75 $23.93 $27.73 $20.06 $17.81 $22.73 $26.34 0.48% City of Rogers, AR Match $19.48 $15.39 $19.24 $23.08 $19.48 $15.39 $19.24 $23.08 0.50% City of Springdale, AR DOL- BLS -NWA Match $20.38 $15.80 $19.75 $23.70 $20.38 $15.80 $19.75 $23.70 0.50% NOARK 2023 Match $20.82 $16.23 $20.29 $24.35 $20.82 $16.23 $20.29 $24.35 0.50% Averages Match $20.14 $16.22 $20.38 $24.261$19.93 1 $16.03 1 $20.14 $23.98 0.50% City of Fayetteville, AR Match $20.80 515.71 $18.93 523.47 0.49% $ Difference $0.87 $-0.32 $-1.21 $-0.51 %Difference 4.181. -2.04% -6.391. -2.17% Market Average Hourly Rates and Market Average Range Minimums, Midpoints and Maximums adjusted for Geographic Compensation Differential (GCD) Page 98 of 98 APPENDIX 6 Summary SalaryJob Title Grade Average Market Hourly Rate Fayetteville Average Hourly Rate Difference at Average Average Market Min Fayetteville Min Difference at Min Average Market Mid Fayetteville Mid Difference at Mid Average Market Max Fayetteville Max Difference at Max ACCOUNTING CLERK - PAYABLES J415 $22.54 $22.08 -2.08% $17.88 $18.73 4.54% $22.42 $22.57 0.66% $27.09 $27.99 3.22% ACCOUNTING DIRECTOR J433 $52.42 $51.98 -1.04% $42.56 $42.56 $53.45 $51.28 -4.23% $65.25 $63.59 -2.61% ACCOUNTING MANAGER- PAYROLL AND PENSION J428 $41.20 $42.07 2.07°k $33.00 $34.79 5.15% $41.42 $41.92 1.19% $50.48 $51.98 2.89% AIRPORT MAINTENANCE WORKER III J412 $21.22 $23.47 9.59% $16.98 $15.71 -7.45% $21.00 $18.93 -10.94% $25.45 $23.47 -8.44% ANIMAL SERVICES OFFICER J413 $19.46 $19.53 r 0.36% $16.89 $16.72 -1.02% $21.18 $20.15 -5.11% $25.58 $24.99 r -2.36% ASSISTANT FIRE CHIEF J433 $56.43 $63.59 11.26% $43.35 $42.56 -1.86% $52.99 $51.28 -3.33% $63.40 $63.59 0.30% ASSISTANT WATER & SEWER OPERATIONS MANAGER J426 $42.45 $37.73 -12.51% $32.81 $30.95 -6.01% $41.02 $37.29 -10.00% $49.46 $46.24 -6.96% AUTOMOTIVE PARTS SPECIALIST J416 $22.54 $20.92 -7.74% $19.27 $19.74 2.38% $24.11 $23.78 -1.39% $28.96 $29.49 1.80% BACKFLOW PREVENTION TECHNICIAN J415 $24.17 $23.92 -1.05% $19.17 $18.73 -2.35% $23.71 $22.57 -5.05% $28.67 $27.99 -2.43% BENEFITS & LEAVE ADMINISTRATOR J418 $26.95 $27.78 2.99% $22.08 $21.75 -1.52% $27.65 $26.20 -5.53% $33.50 $32.49 -3.11% BUDGET DIRECTOR J433 $58.40 $63.59 8.16% $45.28 $42.56 -6.39% $57.10 $51.28 -11.35% $69.20 $63.59 -8.82% BUSINESS LICENSE CLERK J413 $19.88 $19.23 -3.39% $16.63 $16.72 0.54% $20.86 $20.15 -3.52% $25.33 $24.99 -1.36% BUSINESS SYSTEMS ANALYST J425 $39.27 $36.99 -6.16% $29.49 $29.03 -1.58% $37.06 $34.97 -5.98% $45.04 $43.36 -3.87% CAD DRAFTER J417 $27.24 $28.85 5.58% $20.54 $20.74 0.96% $25.52 $24.99 2.12% $30.96 $30.99 0.10% CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER J437 $69.75 $75.90 8.10% $56.07 $50.80 -10.37% $70.61 $61.21 -15.36% $85.50 $75.90 -12.65% CHIEF OF STAFF J439 $74.42 $72.41 -2.78% $57.48 $54.92 -4.66% $72.05 $66.17 -8.89% $87.72 $92.05 -6.91% CITY ATTORNEY J439 $76.89 $71.54 -7.48% $57.13 $54.92 -4.02% $71.73 $66.17 -8.40% $37.16 $82.05 -6.23% CITY CLERK/TREASURER J432 $53.20 $51.57 -3.16% $42.26 $40.50 -4.35% $52.95 $48.80 -8.50% $63.60 $60.51 -5.11% CITY PROSECUTOR J432 $55.57 $60.51 8.16% $40.04 $40.50 1.14% $52.38 $48.90 -7.34% $63.81 $60.51 -5.45% CODE COMPLIANCE OFFICER J415 $22.65 $20.99 -7.91% $18.00 $18.73 3.90% $22.58 $22.57 -0.04% $27.24 $27.99 2.69% COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING DIRECTOR J433 $50.03 $52.88 5.39% $40.55 $42.56 4.72% $51.05 $51.28 0.45% $62.66 $63.59 1.46% COMMUNICATIONS PROJECT MANAGER -WEB J421 $30.56 $28.80 -6.11% $24.55 $23.80 -3.15% $30.56 $28.67 -6.59% $36.95 $35.55 -3.94% COMMUNITY RESOURCES DIRECTOR/EQUITYOFFICER J428 $47.34 $51.98 8.93% $37.47 $34.79 -7.70% $47.23 $41.92 -12.67% $57.18 $51.98 -10.00% CONSTRUCTION LEAD MAINTENANCE WORKER J414 $23.43 $22.50 -4.13% $18.74 $17.72 5.76% $23.29 $21.35 -9.09% $28.25 $26.47 -6.72% CREW LEADER -TRANSPORTATION J415 $24.08 $23.23 -3.66% $19.70 $18.73 -5.18% $24.52 $22.57 -8.64% $29.91 $27.99 -6.50% CREW LEADER WATER LICENSE J417 $27.17 $27.49 1.16% $21.32 $20.74 -2.80% $26.50 $24.99 -6.04% $31.89 $30.99 -2.90% CRIME SCENE TECHINICIAN J417 $28.83 $26.80 -7.57% $23.03 $20.74 -11.04% $28.40 $24.99 -13.65% $34.29 $30.99 -10.65% CUSTOMER SERVICE COORDINATOR I J414 $19.46 $17.99 -8.79% $17.29 $17.72 2.43% $21.70 $21.35 -1.64% $25.86 $26.47 2.30% DEPUTY COURT CLERK J415 $21.29 $24.48 13.03% $18.11 $18.73 3.31% $22.72 $22.57 -0.66% $27.28 $27.99 2.54% DIRECTOR OF ECONOMIC VITALITY J433 $56.40 $56.20 -0.36% $44.10 $42.56 -3.62% $55.42 $51.28 -8.07% $67.43 $63.59 -6.04% DIRECTOR OF PARKS, NATURAL RESOURCES & CULTURAL AFFAIRS J436 $61.11 $58.86 -3.82% $46.00 $48.75 5.64% $57.95 $58.73 1.33% $70.40 $72.83 3.34% DISPATCH MANAGER J427 $43.23 $49.10 11.96% 1 $32.55 $32.87 0.97% $40.66 $39.60 -2.69% $49.41 $49.10 -0.63% DISPATCH SHIFT SUPERVISOR J421 $29.75 $29.79 0.13% $23.59 $23.80 0.88% $29.35 $28.67 -2.37% $35.57 $35.55 -0.06% APPENDIX 6 DISPATCH SHIFT SUPERVISOR J421 $29.75 $29.79 0.13% $23.59 r $23.80 0.88% $29.35 $28.67 r -2.37% $35.57 $35.55 r -0.06% DISPATCHER J415 $20.86 $19.35 -7.80% $18.33 $18.73 2.14% $22.71 $22.57 -0.62% $27.44 $27.99 1.96% DISTRICT COURT ADMINISTRATOR J430 $46.57 $48.94 4.94% $35.50 $38.64 8.13% $44.86 $46.55 3.63% $54.21 $57.72 6.08% ENVIRONMENTAL DIRECTOR J435 $60.46 $57.73 -4.73% $46.90 $46.68 -0.47% $58.96 $56.24 -4.84% $71.76 $69.74 -2.90% EQUIPMENT MECHANIC II J415 $22.84 $21.63 -5.59% $18.87 $18.73 -0.75% $23.43 $22.57 -3.81% $28.50 $27.99 -1.82% FACILITIES & BUILDING MAINTENANCE MANAGER J427 $39.59 $39.68 0.23% $31.94 $32.87 2.83% $40.37 $39.60 -1.94% $48.97 $49.10 0.26% FIELD OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR- FORESTRY J419 $29.54 $26.63 -10.93% $23.76 $22.75 -4.44% $29.51 $27.41 -7.66% $35.80 $33.99 -5.33% FIELD OPERATIONS SUPERVISOR -TRANSPORTATION J419 $32.26 $30.61 -5.39% $25.10 $22.75 -10.33% $31.22 $27.41 -13.90% $37.80 $33.99 1.21% FIELD SERVICE REPRESENTATIVE J418 $28.84 $30.20 4.50% $22.76 $21.75 -4.64% $28.27 $26.20 -7.90% $34.02 $32.49.71% FINANCIAL ANALYST - FIRE J421 $31.69 $33.73 6.05% $25.31 $23.80 -6.34% $31.51 $28.67 -9.91% $38.09 $35.55 r-7.14% FIRE CHIEF J437 $68.39 $68.56 0.25% $54.62 $50.80 -7.52% $67.05 $61.21 -9.54% $80.09 $75.90.52% FLIGHT LINE OPERATIONS TECHNICIAN J412 $19.25 $17.81 -8.09% $16.36 $15.71 -4.14% $20.32 $18.93 -7.34% $24.66 $23.47.07% GIS ANALYST J423 $29.94 $29.06 -3.03% $24.93 $25.66 2.84% $31.24 $30.91 -1.07% $37.46 $38.33 2.27% GISMANAGER J428 $43.88 $46.69 6.02% $33.39 $34.79 4.02% $41.93 $41.92 -0.02% $51.07 $51.98 1.75% GIS TECNICIAN J417 $25.57 $30.99 17.49% $20.86 $20.74 -0.58% $26.18 $24.99 -4.76% $31.44 $30.99 -1.45% HORTICULTURAL ASSISTANT II J412 $18.40 $17.63 -4.37% $17.06 $15.71 -8.59% $21.22 $18.93 -12.10% $25.70 $23.47 -9.50% HUMAN RESOURCES DIRECTOR J434 $58.89 $58.45 -0.75% $46.65 $44.63 -4.53% $58.54 $53.77 -8.87% $71.28 $66.67 -6.91% HUMAN RESOURCES GENERALIST J423 $31.07 $30.91 -0.52% $25.28 $25.66 1.48% $31.67 $30.91 -2.46% $38.16 $38.33 0.44% INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES DIRECTOR J435 $60.40 $62.23 2.94% $48.50 $46.68 -3.90% $60.84 $56.24 -8.18% $74.05 $69.74 -6.18% INSPECTOR/COMMERCIAL & RESIDENTIAL J417 $24.73 $23.97 -3.17% $20.21 $20.74 2.56% $25.53 $24.99 -2.16% $31.04 $30.99 -0.16% INTERNALAUDITOR J427 $39.42 $37.80 -4.29% $31.98 $32.87 2.71% $40.53 $39.60 -2.35`,S $49.03 $49.10 0.14% LEAD MAINTENANCE WORKER GROUNDS - PARKS J414 $23.48 $21.60 -8.70% $19.42 $17.72 -9.59% $24.16 $21.35 -13.16% $29.42 $26.47 -11.14% MAINTENANCE WORKER II PARKS J410 $17.63 $17.05 -3.40% $14.87 $13.86 -7.29% $18.51 $16.70 -10.84% $22.53 $20.71 -8.79% MAINTENANCE WORKER III PARKS J411 $19.93 $17.79 -12.03% $16.36 $15.21 -7.56% $20.32 $18.32 -10.92% $24.65 $22.72 -8.49% MAINTENANCE WORKER III TRANSPORTATION J411 $18.94 $17.48 -8.35% $16.04 $15.21 -5.46% $20.05 $18.32 -9.44% $24.47 $22.72 -7.70% MAINTENANCE WORKER III WATER SEWER J414 $23.07 $18.76 -22.97% $18.74 $17.72 -5.76% $23.16 $21.35 -8.48% $27.79 $26.47 -4.99% MAINTENANCE WORKER IV CONCRETE J413 $20.64 $18.43 -11.99% $17.50 $16.72 -4.67% $21.76 $20.15 -7.99% $26.34 $24.99 -5.40% MAINTENANCE WORKER IV WATER & SEWER LICENSED J415 $24.73 $21.86 -13.13% $19.76 $18.73 -5.50% $24.66 $22.57 -9.26% $29.25 $27.99 -4.50% METER MAINTENANCE TECHNICIAN J415 $26.11 $25.56 -2.15% $19.88 $18.73 -6.14% $24.96 $22.57 -10.59% $29.72 $27.99 -6.18% METER READER J412 $19.22 $17.90 -7.37% $16.37 $15.71 -4.20% $20.34 $18.93 -7.45% $24.49 $23.47 -4.35% NETWORK ANALYST J424 $33.35 $31.65 -5.37% $27.86 $27.11 -2.77% $34.70 $32.66 -6.25% $42.08 $40.50 -3.90% NETWORK ENGINEER J427 $44.47 $49.08 9.39% $34.95 $32.87 -6.33% $43.87 $39.60 -10.78% $53.38 $49.10 -8.72% OPERATIONS ASSISTANT - TRANSPORTATION J412 $21.53 $19.47 -10.58% $16.79 $15.71 -6.87% $20.88 $18.93 -10.30`, $25.48 523.47 -8.52% PARK OPERATIONS DIRECTOR 1429 $48.63 $52.83 7.95% $36.80 $36.71 -0.25% $46.56 $44.23 -5.27°k $56.22 $54.85 -2.50% PARK PLANNING SUPERINTENDENT J426 %1.27 $46.03 10.34% $31.09 $30.95 -0.45% $39.65 $37.29 -6.33% $48.08 $46.24 -3.98% PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER 1475 $21.73 $21.61 -0.56% $17.96 $18.73 4.11% $22.55 $22.57 0.09% $27.09 $27.99 3.22% PERMIT COORDINATOR 1413 520.83 $19.53 -6.66% $17.60 $16.72 -5.26% $21.90 $20.15 -8.68`5 $26.79 $24.99 -7.20% APPENDIX 6 PLANNER J419 $27.38 $27.89 1.83% $22.71 $22.75 0.18% $28.58 $27.41 -4.27% $34.47 $33.99 -1.41% POLICE CAPTAIN J433 $57.44 $63.26 9.20E $42.44 $42.56 0.28% $52.38 $51.28 -2.15% $62.87 $63.59 1.13% POUCE CHIEF J437 $70.03 $75.77 7.58% $53.58 $50.80 -5.47% $65.72 $61.21 -7.37% $76.92 $75.90 -1.34% POLICE SUPPORT SPECIALIST J414 $21.21 $19.09 -11.11% $17.55 $17.72 0.96% $22.02 $21.35 -3.14% $26.45 $26.47 0.08% PROJECT COORDINATOR - UTILITIES J417 $25.80 $25.69 -0.43% $20.71 $20.74 0.14% $26.00 $24.99 -4.04% $31.23 $30.99 -0.77% PROPERTY/EVIDENCE MANAGER J419 $28.69 $33.99 15.59% $22.57 $22.75 0.79% $28.13 $27.41 -2.63% $34.07 $33.99 -0.24% PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR J436 $69.99 $71.86 2.74% $52.04 $48.75 -6.75% $65.78 $58.73 -12.00% $79.88 $72.83 -9.69% PW PROJECTS INSPECTOR J415 $25.42 $23.69 -7.30% $20.69 $18.73 -10.46% $25.71 $22.57 -13.91% $31.17 $27.99 -11.36% RECREATION PROGRAMS MANAGER J420 $27.70 $27.12 -2.14% $23.06 $23.76 2.95% $28.92 $28.63 -1.01% $34.89 $35.50 1.72% RECREATION SUPERINTENDENT J426 $39.10 $46.24 15.44E $31.53 $30.95 -1.87% $39.90 $37.29 -7.00% $48.20 $46.24 -4.24% RECYCLING & TRASH COLLECTIONS OPERATIONS MANAGER J426 $38.94 $38.18 -1.99% $31.16 $30.95 -0.68% $39.53 $37.29 -6.01% $48.18 $46.24 -4.20% RESIDENTIAL PLANS EXAMINER J417 $27.56 $24.48 -12.58% $21.80 $20.74 -5.11% $27.11 $24.99 -8.48% $32.82 $30.99 -5.91% ROUTE DRIVER J413 $22.65 $22.00 -2.95% $17.72 $16.72 -5.98% $22.04 $20.15 -9.38% $26.86 $24.99 -7.48% ROUTE SUPERVISOR J416 $27.80 $26.78 -3.81% $21.70 $19.74 -9.93% $26.98 $23.78 -13.46% $32.90 $29.49 -11.56% SENIOR ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT - MAYOR'SOFFICE J415 $28.94 $30.69 6.03% $22.28 $18.73 -18.95% $27.94 $22.57 -23.79% $33.56 $27.99 -19.90% SENIOR PLANNER J423 $32.63 $30.91 -5.56% $25.94 $25.66 -1.09% $33.00 $30.91 -6.76% $43.89 $38.33 -14.51% SENIOR POLICE SUPPORT SPECIALIST J416 $24.98 $24.32 -2.71% $19.72 $19.74 0.10% $25.32 $23.78 -6.48% $30.87 $29.49 -4.68% SENIOR PURCHASING AGENT J422 $30.66 $30.19 -1.56% $24.76 $24.70 -0.24% $30.77 $29.76 -3.39% $37.32 $36.90 -1.14% SHELTER ATTENDANT J410 $15.99 $16.45 2.80% $14.20 $13.86 -2.45% $17.68 $16.70 -5.87% $21.50 $20.71 -3.81% STAFF ENGINEER- UNLICENSED J419 $37.44 $33.13 -13.01"% $26.67 $22.75 -17.23% $35.64 $27.41 -30.03% $45.96 $33.99 -35.22% SURVEYOR J424 $35.67 $40.50 11.93% $28.02 $27.11 -3.36% $35.14 $32.66 -7.59% $42.18 $40.50 -4.15% TECHNICAL SUPPORT SPECIALIST J423 $28.87 $32.89 12.22% $23.90 $25.66 6.86E $29.98 $30.91 3.01% $36.16 $38.33 5.66% TRAFFIC SIGNALAND SIGNAGE TECHNICIAN J416 $23.92 $22.92 -4.36% $19.99 $19.74 -1.27% $25.06 $23.78 -5.38% $30.27 $29.49 -2.64% URBAN FORESTER J419 $28.63 $29.69 3.57% $22.32 $22.75 1.89% $28.01 $27.41 -2.19% $33.66 $33.99 0.97E UTILITIES ENGINEER J430 $49.94 $51.16 2.38% $38.28 $38.64 0.93% $48.47 $46.55 -4.12% $58.59 $57.72 -1.51% UTILITIES FINANCIAL SERVICES DIRECTOR J430 $52.69 $52.59 -0.19% $38.59 $38.64 0.13% $48.69 $46.55 -4.60% $59.65 $57.72 -3.34% WAREHOUSE SUPERVISOR 1418 $27.11 $26.20 -3.47% $21.72 $21.75 0.14E $26.99 $26.20 -3.02% $32.74 $32.49 WATER & SEWER FIELD MAINTENANCE SUPERVISOR J424 $35.47 $35.24 -0.65% $27.54 $27.11 -1.95% $34.68 $32.66 -6.18% $41.34 $40.50 -2.07% WATER & SEWER OPERATIONS CLERK J412 $19.93 $20.80 4.18E $16.03 $15.71 -2.04% $20.14 $18.93 -6.39% $23.98 $23.47 -2.17% Overall Averages $35.00 $35.28 0.80E $27.69 $27.09 -2.21% $34.71 $32.64 -6.34% $42.05 $40.47 -3.90% APPENDIX 7 MEDICALMONTHLY Bentonville Springdale Rogers Jonesboro Lawrence, KS NOARK Study Fayetteville HDHP Employee Only Employee 11% $43.65 30% $96.97 10% $56.00 29% $165.85 3% $23.49 16% $54.00 14% $63.74 City 89% $353.14 70% $226.27 90% $501.00 71% $406.10 97% $825.87 84% $280.00 86% $389.70 Employee & Spouse Employee 11% $99.08 30% $193.73 13% $232.38 32% $169.00 15% $145.52 City 89% $801.64 70% $452.03 87% $1,590.88 68% $364.00 85% $832.42 Employee & Child(ren) Employee 11% $77.69 30% $174.26 1 20% $154.00 1 13% $213.61 27% $138.00 15% $210.22 City 89% $628.60 70% $406.62 80% $615.00 87% $1,437.41 73% $369.00 85% $630.58 Employee & Family Employee 11% 1 $126.94 1 30% 1 $266.38 22% 1 $275.00 29% 1 $356.34 1 15% $391.99 31% $290.00 15% $204.34 City 89% 1 $1,027.07 70% $621.54 78% 1 $1,011.00 71% DENTAL PREMIUM COST SHARES $872.46 85% $2,231.84 69% $659.00 85% $1,168.94 Bentonville Springdale Rogers Jonesboro Lawrence, KS NOARK Study Fayetteville Employee Only Employee 15% $4.93 30% $9.35 100% $24.68 0% $0.00 Included in Medical Plan 53% $10.00 100% $30.22 City 85% $27.93 70% $21.81 0% $0.00 100% $28.22 47% $9.00 0% $0.00 Employee & Spouse Employee 15% $9.86 30% $19.49 61% $19.00 100% $60.44 City 85% $55.88 70% $45.49 39% $12.00 0% $0.00 Employee & Child(ren) Employee 15% 1 $11.34 1 30% 1 $17.53 1 100% 1 $46.90 1 61% 1 $20.00 1 100% 1 $69.52 City 85% $64.24 70% $40.89 0% $0.00 39% $13.00 0% $0.00 Employee & Family Employee 15% $13.58 30% $29.78 100% $105.34 66% $40.00 100% $107.80 City 85% $76.94 70% $69.48 0% $0.00 34% $21.00 0% $0.00 HSA Contribution Bentonville Springdale Rogers Jonesboro Lawrence, KS NOARK Study Fayetteville Employer Contribution/Year Employee Contribution/Year Employer $$/Year Employer/ Monthly Employer/ Annually Employee Only City $1,080 $1,216 $300 to $3,850 $87.50 $1,050.00 Employee & Spouse City $1,800 $2,232 $775 to $7,750 $123.34 $1,480.08 Employee & Child(ren) City $1,800 $2,031 $775 to $7,750 $157.50 $1,890.00 Employee & Family City 1 $1,800 1 $2,297 1 1 1 1 $775 to $7,750 $190.00 $2,280.00 A majority of the Fayetteville City employees have selected the HDHP Plan with $3,200 and $6,400 Annual Out of Pocket Limits. Employee Medical Premium Expense Comparison MarketAvg.1 FYVHDHP Variance Employee Only 16% 14% -2% $71.63 $63.74 -$7.89 Employee & Spouse 21% 15% -6% $166.89 $145.52 -$21.37 Employee & Child(ren) 20% 15% -5% $143.97 $110.22 -$33.75 Employee & Family 1 23% 1 15% 1 -8% $271.94 1 $204.34 1 -$67.60 per month per month per month oer month Market Average Fayetteville OOP OOP-HSA$ Variance Individual 1 $3,405 $2,150 -$1,255 Family 1 $7,725 1 $4,120 1 -$3,605 Page 1 of 2 APPENDIX 7 aTv RETIREMENT MEDICAL & DENTAL PLANS TIME OFF PLANS FOR MERIT POSITIONS SHIFT / ON CALL PAY REIMBURSEMENT a, _ davrroear zaan/vwr Pw/NSA cecgsl is me DmaNiaaal/s1.00D Pam swtm personnel dope)chv pays l2%,emplryee can 3%ND .Pinar MBElcal antoNion-h Famlly/$z,OW; aueV$3.DOD PPaOndl ymgY/56,GOD; EE OnIY: $1,0s0 dependent arel HDHP: Flu shots; Hep Bshots; Wellbeing DaY; Free Cay ays/ywr =16 days/rear waiternopn orfngnt Fayetteville " mayrontri al 9s% see test snare: Tame NDxP maieiaual/ P"aivi aaaV $3.2oo Dada EE/Famay: 5;2go S.A., Iimrtm parpa a Naental/vlzlon Gym; Inaiviaaal'aea realm chi"q and 12 _ aays/yea 12/year 2/rear smR on y-$1.s0/nr $zoas per day xo upto lhs 0sl ann maxlmumbm nl nand Deha 0emal $3,2DO and Famlly/ $6A00 Famlly/56,a00 xoxP only and p ent rare Wellness Incentives =2D days/vear = 24aan/yw krall Hours pM1YSIaIIY wonm za ywrs=2Bdays/vear usury pan ls.3:%nrg,ew wage. MENNEN 1 ear is aays/vwr Bentonville rd—plwee pays s.sD%, s'ezted after s ND NP legal and Dena st snare Table $3,200IiRwiaual and $3,2001naNia"al and ee cat snare Table No realm Assessment Screening 12 Areers - la aya/year 2D/year 0 Na $ls $1"' maximum wryear ye o sery p vo. p r Dental 56,00D Famlly $6,4W Famlly After 11=2D days/year ye =22 to 24 aan/yr pe•aay matched up1 s% PPOiB®gland FO lnalvlaual/$)s0 PO McNal reimbursement and alaounts for local gyms and wNtcen wellness rv'ce_Dan =1D nays/year Palaaz avenlme Jonesboro arvan-B ,R1 can a Arkansas Dlamondw'a Dena Demal s Cmt sn Tbl ee are. a e d,/$, n Famlly/53,2sD awvD,725 Famlly/$1D,22s pore e"nry p ent rare p 11 /year 12/year Nnne No R. paltlo- N. da 1s.=zD days/year wmnws ammror wemws and acptearemshs. �zRp, ears/vw.n s: ciry can 9.—d gras wage: NPana m-Pay plan PPo mrbutlons b/ de Rdem are... ePmniaklmmnlranons. Annual saan/ye n-whPeeIh— La —en e,K$ na emP'-.ePz6%plusavDlumary wDItM1 HaA IAe[naland Ia"aaaV$1,2sn See cat snaresable "'w N znd Inalvlaual/$4,000 eby:$so car maNiaaal 53,oso xtaamum car mtand Denul Cleanings/Exams/%-ren, 10 19 days/ywr 12/rear 2tyear N. Pe rek "'gm No p Delta Dental Famlly/$3,sG0 Famiry/$g.OW Deaualble and SsoD Pot Empluvee and Ss,GOD er year. Aaational$WC for NhA 2mrrbutlon - 22 aays/yea, 2hours wrantl Famiry DetluaiN. Y.- mum per yea household LO ror meeting wellness goals. =2a days/year keno or M1ol .- ayslvear u/vr Rogers z%of gras wagesRd, emNoyee s%. vested otters PPOIB®61and s Cmt sn Tbl FO InaN'dual/$1s0 ee arcs a e o dual/$:,2so N " Voluntary Flu snots. some 1mems offer mn of service -Dan - 0aan/year Dr servla� ys 1 = tlan/rear Nne N. No No can y.arsof zervlce plus wlunnrvan pin oche Demal naF amiN/$1b00 Famlly/$s,s00 ,mwn ry meter scree g p days/veer -ERdays/year 1 20 1a-2 aays/ywr - gg aan/yw - ls. .gg aays/vear A: eiry cans%of gras wages and ymplwees Co- PPo, O lmlvmual/$z,EW Empi y Pad ears of --Dan an/year sly per aayror non Springdale wv3%. vested afters vacs x PwMSA IBcgsl and Po $1.D00 see cod snares table Sa,00D mdy/$a000 Faiviaual/Sa,ODO 'B'n 51,21s BB/swase $2, eai depenaentare to m al reimb�aemen aae oury Gym and tree memheahip m 12 =lsaavz/rear zo/vwr N one N. umrormed dent Parame an Sz,aoo per orservm, p naI p Delta Dental xD HP na lamb,/$g,000 EE/FE cnlld.$2,031 FF/Famnv$2,297 sp ringaale aec Cencer - aays/year p Woos year z0 yeas xs days/rear 001ikl or CO3ibl Ave age of $1,1in.ion00 for 1%offer H.S.A.plans. sMR Pay Per Hour P.VP rbnt NOverageARK Study %De9nea Benefit h)=rg[ % offer Medlwl and eevemgea D%ofrer Wellness P--ms Top Four mgramammam giamemr srmemnga s%ChUr watbn Days ngingrmm a-z: Dave $1 o oNerB ton e�mbmsem 01(q Cpntrlbu[lonz %Mme4%ns.22% FO plans and Seec al snow Tame IndmS.idual/$2,sWand mmadwbnd Famnlw r dE..tlndN1d.a'$30D1. r3%otter Fsys moking cessmon, on -she Gym and Wnchg Avenge 11 6%INrer Pro Dan hanging 1D/rear z/rear mode $1.zs3m snit Nh Nansh Averages A 6%offers HD p Famiry/$sp00 eof51A001. ang$1a,DDD $3,RED-d Family522B m$7,75D team M1wttM1 etlurmion.sessions Rom lg zs n rd Nx sundaes Page 2 of 2